6 ms·
I've often wondered why there aren't laws against predatory pricing. Things like unknowingly racking up $2,000 in cell phone charges, or $3,000 in overdraft ch
by crazygringo 8y ago
I've often wondered why there aren't laws against predatory pricing.
Things like unknowingly racking up $2,000 in cell phone charges, or $3,000 in overdraft charges of $50 each for 60 different tiny transactions when you had no idea you were over the limit.
I get that it would be hard to craft a law that worked effectively in all cases, but something as simple as for any recurring billing relationship with a consumer, any time a period's accrued billing reaches double their previous period, the consumer cannot be on the hook for additional charges unless the account holder (not user) authorizes them up to a new amount? (And for the first period, whenever it goes over, say, an average national user's spending.)
It would be up to the utility to suspend service temporarily in the meantime or not... but you could never be stuck with a surprise horrible bill because you didn't understand your iPhone was sucking up data in another country without you realizing.
I've actually used a monthly automatic pre-paid SIM card on my iPhone for years (in NYC), because it's cheaper and I know it's impossible to accrue surprise charges.
- jlarocco 8y ago> Things like unknowingly racking up $2,000 in cell phone charges, or $3,000 in overdraft charges of $50 each for 60 different tiny transactions when you had no idea you were over the limit. Was this predatory, though? Every phone contract I've signed for is pretty explicit about things like text message cost, data costs, etc. From my perspective it seems more likely the parent's either didn't communicate that info to their daughter, or the daughter just did it anyway - both of which are parenting problems and not phone company problems. Not to say the phone company handled it well, but the parent's signed the contract, too, so they should've had some idea. EDIT: Now that I think about it more, I wonder if having the family on a business plan isn't part of the reason the phone company's being so stubborn about it?
- microcolonel 8y ago> Was this predatory, though? Every phone contract I've signed for is pretty explicit about things like text message cost, data costs, etc. Bell Canada is generally pretty bad about explaining the charges in the contract, and anecdotally I have heard many people say they were billed for things that actually didn't happen (and were able to get Bell to erase the charges with enough hours of phonecalls). It puts people under a lot of stress, even middle class people. Unlike the U.S, ordinary people in Canada have a hard time (or believe they will have a hard time) suing companies.
- pjc50 8y agoI've known several adults hit with big charges for overseas calls/data. It's not obvious when it's happening.
- scott_s 8y agoWhen the price charged for a thing is completely unrelated to the cost of that thing, it's going to be hard for people to intuit what they will pay for their usage of that thing - both adults and kids.
- jlarocco 8y agoBut there's no need to use intuition because the prices are spelled out in the contract. You probably don't try to intuit the price of other products, so why would you in this case?
- scott_s 8y agoPeople don't refer to contracts often, and we intuit costs all the time. We have many services and utilities which are pay-for-what-you-use, such as gas, electric and internet. I don't know how much it's going to cost me to turn on my tv, but I have an intuition it's not enough to prevent me from doing so. I don't look at the price of most of my groceries. I just do a mental "looks about right" at the final total before paying it. And none of this applies to a 14-year-old, who no one should expect to read a contract to figure out that normal use of a device will cost thousands of dollars a month.
- brlewis 8y agoIANAL and I am not Canadian, but I think in the US one could argue the contract unconscionable: https://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/unenforceable-contracts-tips-33079.html https://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/unenforceable-contra...
- user5994461 8y agoThere are laws against that in Europe dedicated to telecom. Surprised it doesn't exist in the US. It happened about a decade ago when everybody started getting a cellphone. You should have noticed if you had teenagers yourself or in your entourage with a phone. Bills in the hundreds of dollars after a few hours of phone calls, or using some MB of data. Roaming charges were insane and could bill a thousand euros when traveling within Europe or abroad. Some regulations came in and prohibited that. They mandated to send notifications and block billing after some ceilings.
- pkaye 8y agoProbably because the US in a big country so not many people call outside of the US and there are no roaming charges within the US. In Europe, there are lots of different countries close to each other.
- chrismcb 8y agoEven if the US had these sort is laws, I don't think they would apply to Canada.
- mirages 8y agoMy EU conutry requires that phone bill cannot exceed 3 times your monthly subsbription price. If you'd go above that you would need to pay in advance