4 ms·
We've been writing HTML for a couple of decades now. There have been dozens (hundreds?) of WYSIWYG editors and nothing has really caught on. My hypothesis is t
by pier25 8y ago
We've been writing HTML for a couple of decades now. There have been dozens (hundreds?) of WYSIWYG editors and nothing has really caught on.
My hypothesis is that unlike other mediums like paper or video, the elastic nature of the web makes understanding the positioning paradigms/box model/etc a necessity that no visual tool can really abstract. By the time you understand all that, it's just faster to write and maintain code.
- JesseAldridge 8y agoSquareSpace, Wix, Shopify, and Elementor (a WordPress plugin) have all caught on. The first three are more than page-builders, but the page-builder is an important component. They're just not popular with the HN crowd.
- iliketosleep 8y agoSo true, I have seen total beginners create nice looking pages with the tools you've mentioned, but if they stay in it for the long haul they find themselves limited by these tools - after which they either gain the technical skills required and move away from the page-builder or hire a dev. That's why I personally won't use such tools. They make it quicker to begin with, but I'll inevitably find myself fighting against the tool.
- mamurphy 8y agoWhat kind of beginners? If someone wants to make websites for a living, of course they need to get the skills. If they just want one website, those tools are often enough.
- iliketosleep 8y agoI'm not referring to individuals who wants to make money as a web devs. What I'm referring to is the entrepreneur who lacks technical skills but is able to put up a nice little website using page-builders, and after a while wants to take it further and add features not supported by the page-builder.
- puranjay 8y agoI used Elementor for a recent site but it churns out such bloated code that I was worried my performance was taking a hit. Ended up writing everything from scratch in HTML and site performance has improved by 25%+ It's not a dealbreaker for most businesses but when you're competing on SEO, these little things matter
- pier25 8y agoHave caught on with pros or people that do not know HTML?
- jpochtar 8y agoWe thought so too. The key idea in Pagedraw is you could design in the positon:absolute world designers think in, and we'd translate it into the Flexbox world apps need. Ultimately we didn't get all the way there, which is part of why we closed up shop
- Edmond 8y agothere is another way to tackle this but it takes a lot more work than a DnD editor can deliver: Showcase: https://youtu.be/hgFkzrqxDcs https://youtu.be/hgFkzrqxDcs https://youtu.be/IpX47gAe150 https://youtu.be/IpX47gAe150 Demos: https://youtu.be/u6uV2X1MGeY https://youtu.be/u6uV2X1MGeY https://youtu.be/s2dYVret-Ck https://youtu.be/s2dYVret-Ck https://youtu.be/X6pL0St6NM4 https://youtu.be/X6pL0St6NM4 Feel free to hit me up if you want to know more.
- YorickPeterse 8y agoI think there are also two other problems with WYSIWYG editors that haven't really been solved: 1. They tend to produce output that is not ideal to work with using another program (e.g. your editor of choice). 2. When you make changes to the output, the WYSIWYG editor might not understand it. This very much depends on what is changed, how, etc, but it could be a problem. Both essentially force you to use the same software, and I think that scares people away (rightfully so I'd say).