3 ms·
Electric resistance heat is 1.0 or 100% efficient, all electricity put into the heating element is converted to heat. Not sure if your trying to include power p
by SigmundA 8y ago
Electric resistance heat is 1.0 or 100% efficient, all electricity put into the heating element is converted to heat. Not sure if your trying to include power plant conversion and transmission losses, but that gets very complicated.
Gas units range in efficiency based on how much heat they recover from the exhaust, 80% is typical, 90+ for a condensing heater with two stage heat recovery. The problem with condensing is the exhaust gases fall below condensation point for the water vapor created during combustion requiring a condensate drain complicating the install location and cost significantly.
Heat pumps are over unity they use some energy to move more energy from the environment into the water, they are basically solar assisted resistance heaters.
The energy cost difference is not as clear when comparing a heat pump tank storage unit to a gas on demand tankless they are both typically more cost effective than tank storage electric or gas.
I have a 80% efficient tankless natural gas, it is wonderful having endless hot water at all faucets concurrently with a family of 4 plus occasional guests. I wanted to go condensing 90+ efficient but it was to complex based on its install location.
- fulafel 8y agoIn typical mounting of electric radiator elements, some of the heat might be absorbed in the walls and windows that are facing outdoors. Then the temperature gardient in the wall/window insulation is steeper, leaking more heat outside. So yes, all the energy is converted into heat, but some of it may be heating the outdoors.
- SigmundA 8y agoThis has nothing to do with the type of heater but rather the placement. When talking about relative efficiency you look at the heater itself and not common factors as they can be eliminated from the equation.