4 ms·
So, a reasonable person (maybe not from here) would ask themselves why the lightbulb has a secret password to access the Network. After all we want the Network
by tialaramex 8y ago
So, a reasonable person (maybe not from here) would ask themselves why the lightbulb has a secret password to access the Network. After all we want the Network to be ubiquitous, so why is there a password anyway? If there wasn't a password then bad guys couldn't find out what it is. (You may think, aha - but with ubiquitous access they wouldn't need to, but as we saw for SSH shared passwords mean that getting a password may be _more_ not less valuable than access to the thing it was protecting).
It turns out that besides the stupid sociological reasons (which also result in us trying to make it impossible to sleep on a park bench rather than providing people with homes so that they won't _need_ to sleep on a park bench) there's a technical reason, and maybe that we can fix.
WiFi (802.11) has traditionally been plaintext out of the box. So every participant can see everything sent and received by every other participant. If you have a password this isn't so. Thus, a WiFi network plus a billboard announcing the WiFi password to everyone in the neighbourhood is actually slightly _more_ secure than one with no password at all.
Finally in WPA3 this is fixed, participants with passwords use a PAKE but everybody without a password gets OWE (RFC8110) to secure their network access. Since they don't have a way any way to authenticate they can be MITM'd of course, but you can't just passively decrypt everything they're sending and receiving. So a WPA3 era WiFi network that's "open" to everybody is protected better than your WPA2 PSK "ThanksMike" password for Mike's Coffee Shop.
- JoshTriplett 8y agoA reasonable person might also ask why the lightbulb has the same password to access the network that everything else does. Ideally, when you try to connect a new device to your network, an existing device with "network administrator" privileges (e.g. a computer) would get asked "do you want Philips Hue Smart Bulb Controller (printed ID x7a39q) to connect to your network?", and if you say "yes" on that device, the new device would get a unique asymmetric key pair. When setting up a brand new network, you could either enter something printed on the router or scan a QR code. And then you could have a button to revoke a device's credentials (showing recently disconnected devices first), and a button to revoke the credentials of every device not currently on the network.
- heywire 8y agoMaybe the next iteration of WPS will move in this direction (and with less vulnerabilities)