4 ms·
You can also demonstrate this is incorrect by calculating the area of the parts of the square cut off, which is the sum of an infinite geometric series. You wi
by patio11 16y ago
You can also demonstrate this is incorrect by calculating the area of the parts of the square cut off, which is the sum of an infinite geometric series. You will find it doesn't equal the area of the unit square minus the area of the inscribed circle.
Here, let's try: the square is 1x1. Consider one quarter of the circle: radius of the circle is 1/2, half a diagonal of the square is sqrt(2) / 2, diagonal of the removed square is (rt(2) - 1) / 2. Area of the square removed is ((rt(2) - 1) / 2) ^ 2. (This is trivial via the pythagorean theorem, saving some math.)
Alright, that's the first square we accumulate. Now the magic happens: every step, we cut the square's side in half, but make two of them. Agree with me so far? Good. If we cut the side of a square in half, we cut its area to a quarter, but since we have two squares now the total area is 1/2 of the last square. Agree with me so far? Good. We can trivially sum infinite geometric series: t1 / (1 - r), where t1 is the first term and r is the fraction each term gets multiplied by. In this case, it turns out that in any one quadrant the sum of the series of squares removed is 2 * ((rt(2) - 1) / 2) ^ 2, or just (rt(2) - 1)^2 / 2.
Multiply by 4 to get the picture over all four quadrants, and we get 2 * (rt(2) - 1) ^ 2. A little simplification and we get 2 * (2 - 2 rt(2) + 1) = 6 - 4 rt(2)
So, we've got a unit square, so the area of the square is 1. If we subtract the area of the infinite series of squares, we get 4 rt(2) - 5 =~ .657. We expect the area of the circle to be pi / 4 =~ 0.7853975. Thus, the square minus and infinite series of squares doesn't approximate the known area of a circle at all.
- spicyj 16y agoThis isn't quite right; when you divide up your problem, your "quarter circle" doesn't look the same after each iteration, and so the sizes of the squares cut off don't follow a geometric sequence. In fact, I'm sure that the area of the figure does approximate the area of a circle (because no point inside the circle is ever removed, yet every point outside of it will be removed eventually). The problem lies not with the area, but the perimeter; the figure's area turns out to be unrelated for this problem.
- patio11 16y agoHmh. Its 1 AM here. Give me some time to sleep and think over that. You might be right: I can't remember why I thought the squares would go geometric. I thought I had a better reason than "It looks that way on the picture, kinda...", but it eludes me.
- xyzzyz 16y agoIf A_n is a sequence of sets bounded by these square like curves, then m(A_n) -> pi, where m is a Lebesgue measure. Each set is clearly measurable, since it is closed in Euclidean topology, and thus Borel. You can prove this sequence converges by seeing that each A_n is enclosed in some circle of diameter 1+e for some e, and, as n -> \infty, e -> 0. Thus, argumentation from area will not work here.
- pixcavator 16y agoRight. This way, you aren’t approximating the circle. And if you were, the area would converge to the right number. Areas are good this way, unlike lengths which is what the post is about.