3 ms·
America's industry is running on software from the '80s. You can't imagine the horrors on the shop floor. Never mind XP or Windows ME - DOS with green-screen te
by JoeAltmaier 8y ago
America's industry is running on software from the '80s. You can't imagine the horrors on the shop floor. Never mind XP or Windows ME - DOS with green-screen terminals; hand-coded apps booting on home-brew hardware; IBM dinosaurs that should be extinct but lumber on in the back office.
And there's nobody that can help them fix anything. So upgrade you say? Then they'd have to start from scratch. And they long ago laid off the accounting experts, tax lawyers and business planners. They have button-pushers and data entry folks. Nobody left who knows were the data comes from, where it goes, or who all uses it.
- bluedino 8y agoWe recently bought a $4 million dollar steel fabrication system, automated, top of the line, runs Windows XP. Rumor is the company has been trying to re-write the control software to run on Windows 7 for the last 10 years (name rhymes with spaghetti) We interact with it using little data packets (ASCII, sent from a VB app) of coordinates to tell it what to do. Insane amounts of money would be lost if that machine goes offline for a day. We can't just replace it unless it's 100% compatible. Some of our bigger competitors have 10 of these machines. There's no real benefit of upgrading them, though. We'd still run the whole damn machine behind it's own ASA and on it's own network. The users don't care. And our programmers wouldn't be happy to change it.
- southern_cross 8y agoI regularly see stories of software that is at least 20 years old now, running multimillion dollar industrial systems that are expected to last for at least another 20 years before being retired (if even then). There will probably be no changes to that software in the interim, and it's possible that it can't be changed even if you wanted to, for various reasons. As long as the computer is well-isolated, the biggest ongoing risk here is replacing old and failing PC components when necessary. But the same might be also be true of the industrial systems themselves.
- reaperducer 8y agoYou can't imagine the horrors on the shop floor OK... DOS with green-screen terminals Not a horror. If it works, why mess with it? hand-coded apps booting on home-brew hardware Also not a horror. Bespoke hardware is everywhere, as are hand-coded apps. AI does not yet build software. IBM dinosaurs Still not a horror. Perhaps you just don't have a lot of experience with legacy systems.
- linuxftw 8y ago> Not a horror. If it works, why mess with it? Can you still get parts for said machine? Do the disk have bit errors? Is the RAM faulty? Things fail, sometimes in non-obvious ways. It's important to be able to fix your existing system. Often times that means having a plan to upgrade to a new system.
- reaperducer 8y agoCan you still get parts for said machine? Sure, why not? Worst case scenario for a DOS machine is that you run it in DOSBOX or a similar VM.
- JoeAltmaier 8y ago...until you need to replace an old DOS-supported SCSI RAID controller that hasn't been made in 20 years. Or find an ancient Borland compiler to rebuild the messages in Spanish. Off to the thrift store!
- superkuh 8y agoMy local hydroelectric dam still runs on OS/2. And I don't think it's the modern eComStation 2.1 or anything. I mean old OS/2.
- Aloha 8y agowhy should those IBM dinosaurs be extinct? I can still buy the hardware, my software from 1973 will still run on a current z/OS machine - why change?