7 ms·
Will A.I. Ever Be Smarter Than a Four-Year-Old?
- nabla9 8y ago36092596e621d27a4c23e4624b31cb09b96b030c
- nabla9 8y ago= sha1("The title of the article will distract HN readers from the content.")
- zackkatz 8y agoYes. I found this article to be slanted. This quote, for example, assigns too much creativity to a logic-based statement that I think is precisely the type of reasoning AI exhibits. > Four-year-olds can immediately recognize cats and understand words, but they can also make creative and surprising new inferences that go far beyond their experience. My own grandson recently explained, for example, that if an adult wants to become a child again, he should try not eating any healthy vegetables, since healthy vegetables make a child grow into an adult. This kind of hypothesis, a plausible one that no grown-up would ever entertain, is characteristic of young children. Also, I suggest updating the title to be less click bait-y. “The difference between bottom-up and top-down machine learning for beginners” or something like that.
- mfritsche 8y agoBetteridge's law of headlines.
- mhb 8y agoLaw of Comments to Headlines to Which Betteridge's Law Apply: Useless comment will reference all-too-familiar Betteridge's Law.
- JustSomeNobody 8y agoDon't underestimate how intelligent 4 year olds are.
- MagnumOpus 8y agoDon't overestimate how logical and structured 4-year-olds are. (I have one right now, and I would trust an AI I trained for a day over the child I trained for a day -- for just about any task.) A 7-year-old, on the other hand, is a tall order for AI, especially once you introduce the complex combination of skills with optical image recognition, haptic feedback and physical principles that need broader context and/or creativity...
- sgift 8y agoSince "ever" is a very long time: Probably yes. Far more interesting: Will it be smarter in some areas that can be used for something? That already happened. AI is very smart for specific use cases and it is useful.
- lelima 8y agoI think we first have to scope what definition of intelligence we want to compare: 1)having good understanding or a high mental capacity; quick to comprehend, as persons or animals: an intelligent student. 2)displaying or characterized by quickness of understanding, sound thought, or good judgment: an intelligent reply. 3)having the faculty of reasoning and understanding; possessing intelligence: intelligent beings in outer space. 4)Computers. pertaining to the ability to do data processing locally; smart: An intelligent terminal can edit input before transmission to a host computer. Depending on the definition computers already beat humans, not only 4 years old.
- flavor8 8y ago"Ever" is not a useful word here. It's like saying "Will four year olds ever be grown in pods?" A better headline might be "Can AI learn as flexibly as a four year old with today's known techniques?", to which the answer is of course "No".
- b_tterc_p 8y agoThose sound like different questions. The original is asking if it is theoretically plausible. I don’t think that’s out of line.
- eof 8y agoTo be fair, the article did little to nothing to address if it's theoretically plausible. Just that we are far away at the moment.
- laumars 8y agoThe OP's point was that adding "ever" in the title means the question isn't just relevant to our current understanding of what is theoretically plausible but it also doesn't exclude some currently unknown theory that might be derived at a distant point in the future. While I do see - and to an extent agree with - their point, I there is a lot more wrong with that heading than just the lack of a contextual end date.
- eli_gottlieb 8y ago> The OP's point was that adding "ever" in the title means the question isn't just relevant to our current understanding of what is theoretically plausible but it also doesn't exclude some currently unknown theory that might be derived at a distant point in the future. Or, somewhat more plausibly, some theory or technique that constitutes a minor subfield right now but could be the next big thing in another 20-30 years, or whenever someone just makes it really fast.
- laumars 8y ago
- laichzeit0 8y agoI'm okay if it takes 100 or 200 years. That's like going from the year 1800 to the year 2000. It's not a long time at all. I think it's completely doable and a reasonable upper bound. Everyone just needs to relax a bit and let progress run its course.
- goatlover 8y agoThe longer the better, as it gives society time to adapt/prepare for such a potentially powerful technology.
- hardmaru 8y agoNo
- mcv 8y agoDepends on what you consider "smarter" of course. At the moment, the best AI is much smarter at chess than any 4 year old. AI is also better at translating text to different languages. It's better at driving cars. But there are still many things a 4 year old can do that no AI can do. Sometimes I feel like our AI research is leading us to consider ourselves increasingly unintelligent rather than our computers more intelligent. It's leading us to question what we really mean by the word "intelligence". Is it being good at certain skills? Is it being able to acquire arbitrary skills? Does it matter how much guidance we or the AI needs in order to learn?
- jkholm 8y agoI agree with your points on AI being better at certain tasks, except of course regarding translation. There are definitely bilingual 4-year-olds who translate better than the state of the art machine translator. You could maybe say a machine translator can poorly translate a greater set of strings, including highly-technical strings. But a 4-year-old easily can translate a greater proportion of strings correctly or at least intelligibly.
- pen2l 8y agoReally? Because I continue to be more and more amazed by Google Translate everyday. It gets subtleties and strange things right that I never thought a computer translation system could get right. I'm an ESL-speaker, and I think certainly the translation I can do to/from English to my mother language is going to be inferior to Google Translate any day of the week, ignoring completely the fact that I take a _LONG_ time to do translation and Google Translate does it in a second
- jkholm 8y agoLearning a language as an adult is a different story. This isn't a no-true-scotsman, either, because I posit that there are quite a lot of 4-year-olds who match my description.
- Foobar8568 8y ago
- BucketSort 8y agoOnce we can rigorously define what "smarter than a four-year-old" means, then yes. But until we even know what we are talking about, no.
- jobigoud 8y agoI'm not sure that is true. For example I can tell you are "smarter than a four-year-old", even though we can't rigorously define what that means. I would even go as far as saying that the fact that we can't rigorously define what "smarter than a four-year-old" means is a limitation of the current intelligence or knowledge of Humans. Part of the trajectory of machine intelligence is independent of our own knowledge, for example through hardware improvements. They could get past our level before we can understand it ourselves.
- BucketSort 8y agoWe understand what "smart" means in relation to what one can do in the world, but that says nothing of what it actually is. It's like if I make an analogy: "That guy is like a dog chasing a bone." It only means something if you understand it, it has no substance on its own. I feel the same way about the way people use terms like "smart," "intelligent" they only mean something if we already know what they mean, but we only know what they mean in relation to the world, not their character independent of it. I do see the trajectories being different, but I believe they must also converge at some point. Edit: Also, the documentary "Baby Geniuses" has extensive evidence that babies are really smart, they just can't communicate how smart they are.
- objektif 8y agoThe answer is yes. Ever is a very long time.
- SketchySeaBeast 8y agoThat's possible, but it's also why the question is useless - if we want to draw out a line long enough where it's inevitable, it's also entirely possible that for whatever reason human advancement stops before then.
- Spooky23 8y agoI doubt it. End of the day human consciousness is incredibly powerful. The whole is greater than the sum of the parts.
- ben_w 8y agoTransistors are faster than synapses to the same degree that wolves are faster than hills. And synergy is just as relevant for digital minds as organic ones.
- Spooky23 8y agoThink about how much a gorilla has in common with a human. We’re close, but only one species is in a zoo. Every human gets smarter as our tools like AI get better.
- ben_w 8y agoThat minor differences put gorillas in zoos and humans watching them is part of the problem. AI can look a very long way from human right up until it beats everyone. And even after it’s exceeded humans for decades, judging by someone I’ve seen in the last year or so who insisted they could beat any computer at chess. For example, imagine that there is just one thing about our minds that we don’t understand how to replicate, which leaves our AI at gorilla-level. No real grasp of language, poor physics model, fails mirror test, etc. Now build into that the software behind WolframAlpha, Siri, Google Translate, Tesla, and AlphaZero, and you have a gorilla who beats every human at chess, go, and shogi; drive about as well as the average American; knows more languages than most people can name; can solve advanced calculus, chemistry, physics, and economics problems; and has some limited capacity for speech. It would still be an idiot by most people’s evaluation. Now add that one little thing that separates us from gorillas. (That’s assuming they still count as “tools” rather than as “people”, which is a whole different kettle of fish).
- ballenf 8y agoThe question is really whether an AI will ever be able to process all the sensory data that a 4-year-old has (including time in the womb), plus the input from epigenetic data resulting from the parent's environment. Plus data from the particular gut flora inherited from the mother and influenced by the environment. We can see no roadblock preventing advances from getting to that point. But the volume of data is admittedly beyond our ability to currently accurately even quantify much less record or process.
- MAXPOOL 8y agoThe human retina communicates to brain with 10 Mbps. The 4-year old's brain has experienced 9 months in a womb and 4 years outside the womb. That's less than 150 million seconds. More than third of that while sleeping. Assuming the full sensory data rate is 50 Mbps total (probably less), 4-year old has received 100×10^6 × 50Mbps = 625 TB sensory information while in a waking state.
- freediver 8y ago4 month old performance is the barrier. If we ever get past that, else is just a matter of time. Darpa launched MCS challange few months ago to attempt to address this. https://www.darpa.mil/program/machine-common-sense https://www.darpa.mil/program/machine-common-sense
- ykevinator 8y agoThe current ai paradigm is good and improving at classification. It's terrible at synthesis (is it too risky to leave without an umbrella) and question formulation (what do I need to know before deciding if I should leave without an umbrella). My opinion is that the current paradigm will never get better than a really smart dog. But, someone will come up with a new paradigm.