4 ms·
I'm not arguing for pigs over mice but I ask since transgenic pigs are often said to be future potentially viable transplant sources would not trials in pigs be
by ggm 8y ago
I'm not arguing for pigs over mice but I ask since transgenic pigs are often said to be future potentially viable transplant sources would not trials in pigs be a better model?
(Ethical nightmares)
- sametmax 8y agoCost. Growing pigs is expensive, it takes more space, more food, and more time.
- dmurray 8y agoPigs are used in research, but they are expensive. Maybe 1000 times the cost of mice? The techniques described in the article (bad choice of temperature and environment) are cutting corners, but testing on pigs instead would completely change the amount of testing you can do.
- interfixus 8y agoWe are closer related to rodents than to pigs. Whether this is an argument for one thing or for another or for nothing at all, I really have no idea.
- klmr 8y agoThis isn’t quite true. The issue is that rodents evolve a lot quicker due to effective population size and generation time. As a consequence, the genetic divergence between rodents and humans is in fact greater than that between humans and pigs (see e.g. https://europepmc.org/abstract/pmc/pmc1142312 https://europepmc.org/abstract/pmc/pmc1142312), even though pigs branched off earlier than rodents.
- interfixus 8y agoHad a vague that something like that might be in play. I obviously have some reading up to do. My assumption was, that our branch would, until quite recently, have been rapid breeders too. And the pigs' one as well.