4 ms·
In most other developed countries, it is politically straightforward to spend $20,000 a year on coaxing and cajoling a patient into managing their diabetes bett
by Mz 16y ago
In most other developed countries, it is politically straightforward to spend $20,000 a year on coaxing and cajoling a patient into managing their diabetes better in order to prevent them from becoming a $70,000 a year dialysis patient. Needless to say that the benefits to this approach are greater than just a cost saving.
I agree with your basic points. But as someone who both is American and has a serious life threatening medical condition, I think there must be some deeper reason for this American quirk.
I know that a lot of "standard wisdom" concerning nutrition and the like not only doesn't work for me but is actively harmful to me. I have managed to get off 8 or 9 prescription drugs and now manage my health issues via diet and lifestyle (and herbs and supplements when necessary). But I have gotten there by following a pig-headed, asinine, "don't tread on me" sort of path. It has been really important to actively reject outside intervention in favor of home-grown solutions for my issue. I suspect something similar may be true for most Americans. America was founded by social outcasts who left their countries of origins to go elsewhere under really harsh, deadly conditions -- conditions which were, nonetheless, more tolerable than the social expectations they were fleeing.
Most people cannot fathom my choice to live without furniture and without a car. I sleep on the floor and most of the time I own only two or three outfits. I get lots of comments from people who are often just trying to make conversation but nonetheless are basically butting in to things that they know nothing about and which are none of their business. For example, I do not own a jacket. Jackets are too hard to keep adequately clean and most are not designed to be washed regularly (ie every single I wear it). I find that undershirts work better for me than jackets. I have also been known to walk to work in flip flops in 40 degree weather. People inevitably feel compelled to tell me to get a jacket or comment that my feet must be cold or something. It is usually under circumstances where I do not have the time (even if I had the inclination) to explain to them that whatever annoyance I suffer from the cold is laughable compared to the suffering it has allowed me to walk away from. It is also usually from people at work, this in spite of a company policy that no one other than my immediate boss is to offer "constructive feedback" on my appearance, and then only if I am in violation of dress code. It annoys me to no end yet I realize that if I made a big stink about it, I would most likely be the one deemed to be 'a problem' (and it would unnecessarily call attention to my medical condition, which I do not wish to do). Most of these people are well-meaning and genuinely concerned for my welfare and/or just trying to make conversation. So I try to handle things diplomatically and lightly and good-naturedly, without referencing the serious medical situation that drives my unconventional literally "remarkable" (ie worthy of remarking upon by these people) choices.
So I think it is possible that most Americans have some deep-seated reason(s) for balking at the idea of someone interceding in their diet and lifestyle choices at an earlier stage in the process. I know outside interference is one of the things that I feel most threatened by. Since I don't have a doctor's note for doing what I do, I can't really justify or defend it on some kind of "legal" grounds or some such. I'm just some lone nut-case who occasionally makes fantastical claims that most folks find unbelievable -- an issue I work very hard to keep out of my place of employment.
It is unfortunate that the results are so expensive. But I am not entirely convinced that the cajoling and convincing that works in other cultures would necessarily be such a good thing for a society of outcasts who could not conform and chose to face so much hardship in order to start over elsewhere. For me, conforming -- even in seemingly small matters like wearing a jacket -- leads to enormous suffering and would eventually kill me. So I just am unable to "go along to get along", in spite of internal wiring that makes me want very much to do that. But I just can't. Maybe a lot of Americans also just can't, yet are willing to accept intervention at a later stage of more serious crisis because at that point there is nothing to lose and a great deal to gain.
- Retric 16y agoWhat I find interesting is how well you indirectly answer the question. Americans are irrational. We are superstitious and confuse things like the availability of early treatment with being forced to use it. We are also selfish and unwilling to live with the results of our poor decision making process. PS: It's not hard to demonstrate that universal heath care would cost less and be more useful than are current system. However, most people already decided to do something else so people are not going to change their mind over something as silly as a rational argument.
- Mz 16y agoI have no idea what you mean. I've done a lot of research to come up with solutions which work for me. I don't see how that is irrational or superstitious (though perhaps you aren't suggesting I am, it sounds to me kind of like that is what you are implying). All I am saying is that if Americans are fundamentally different in their physiology/basic wiring, then the things that work for some other group may not work for them. Even if people cannot explain that very well, they can have some awareness that the expectations other people try to impose on them routinely cause more harm than good. I have also worked extremely hard to resolve my problems in spite of most of the world actively telling me it cannot be done. I don't see how that indicates I am making bad decisions but want other people to fix it. Anyway, I really have no idea what your point is. So probably no point in going on. EDIT: In regards to the PS you added after I replied, since diet and lifestyle changes have been my primary means of getting well and I have not seen a doctor in several years, I don't much care what the US does about the "healthcare system".
- Retric 16y agoif Americans are fundamentally different in their physiology/basic wiring, then the things that work for some other group may not work for them. On the surface that may seem like a perfectly rational standpoint. The reason why it's part of a superstitious belief is how that idea links up with other ideas. You are not arguing based on social data, but rather the abstract idea of what America is and for better or worse that's an superstitious argument. Anyway, Western Medicine as understood by the specialists in their respective areas is vary different from that practices by doctors in the field. It's all well and good to prescribe proper nutrition and exercise, but there is no reason not to do it. If your goal is peak physical condition then there is a lot of research in that area, but doctors work around the lifestyles of their customers and most practical research is designed for that setting. PS: The heath care system protects you in ways that you are probably unaware. Sanitation, food safety, vaccination area all obvious, but healthy populations reduce the spread of disease. The influenza outbreak of 1918, a global plague that killed between 20 and 40 million people, resulted in large part from a local breakdown in heath care on the front lines. http://virus.stanford.edu/uda/ http://virus.stanford.edu/uda/ Edit: The evidence of the breakdown starts with: However, a first wave of influenza appeared early in the spring of 1918 in Kansas and in military camps throughout the US http://virus.stanford.edu/uda/ http://virus.stanford.edu/uda/ and it's well worth the read.