4 ms·
The problem isn't the %. It's the perpetual IP license, which grants Facebook complete non exclusive rights to the Creator's IP, including licensing it to third
by gamblor956 8y ago
The problem isn't the %. It's the perpetual IP license, which grants Facebook complete non exclusive rights to the Creator's IP, including licensing it to third parties without further pay to the Creator.
- Deimorz 8y agoPatreon requires you to grant them an extremely similar license: > You keep full ownership of all content that you post on Patreon, but to operate we need licenses from you. > By posting content to Patreon you grant us a royalty-free, perpetual, irrevocable, non-exclusive, sublicensable, worldwide license to use, reproduce, distribute, perform, publicly display or prepare derivative works of your content. The purpose of this license is to allow us to operate Patreon, promote Patreon and promote your content on Patreon. We are not trying to steal your content or use it in an exploitative way. (from https://www.patreon.com/legal https://www.patreon.com/legal)
- girzel 8y agobut... sublicensable?
- Deimorz 8y agoI don't know what you're asking. It says "sublicensable" in there, yes.
- himlion 8y agoI think he means that's the most unacceptable from the bunch
- fgonzag 8y agoI think it makes sense if the business relationship is actually artist <--> patreon <---> consumer. The client pays patreon, so patreon must sublicense the content to him. Otherwise I'm lost.
- spyhi 8y agoSublicensing is what legally enables things like rich media link previews (the kind you see on Facebook and Twitter) or APIs to exist. Yeah, theoretically they could use that to sell content, but in practice it's generally used to make the web more interoperable.
- antiviral 8y agoIt also states that it's for the purpose of promoting the creator's content on Patreon. For example, showing a thumbnail image of your video on another page as a recommendation would count as a 'derivative work.' Without this right, it would be virtually impossible to get permission from the creator for every instance in which Patreon wants to promote content in a new way. Also, it seems that the creator on Patreon would continue to benefit when Patreon earns value on the content. Facebook, on the other hand, has numerous ways to benefit that don't proportionally benefit the creator, including from indirect revenue sources like advertising and data enrichment that don't flow back to the creator in any way. I suppose this is alright when you are just showing cat photos to your family, but it's quite different when you are basing your business on someone else's market-dominating platform with large negotiating leverage. And there are known cases where Facebook has been known to very liberally appropriate ideas from companies that are competitive with them (e.g., Snapchat).
- leereeves 8y agoIt states clearly that it's also "to allow us to operate Patreon, promote Patreon, ...". So if your content would make a good ad for Patreon, you've given them permission to use it without compensating you.
- xpaulbettsx 8y agoThis boilerplate exists in literally every site that hosts user-created content in some form and displays it to other people. If it didn't exist, the site would immediately be violating your copyright if they showed your content to anyone other than you
- gnicholas 8y agoThat doesn’t explain why it needs to stay in effect after you terminate your relationship with them.
- jrockway 8y agoBackups. Why commit to reliable destruction of data when you don't have to? Google has a guarantee on when your deleted data disappears from tapes in vaults, and it was something that every engineer at the company had to think about (not to mention a ton of work in actually implementing it). You may wish for Some New Startup with 2 engineers to do it for you, but it's hard, takes time, and nobody actually cares. Look at how many people use Patreon despite that policy. Why spend years of engineering work when your lawyer can get the problem fixed in 5 minutes? It's just economics.
- speedplane 8y agoThe issue with facebook is not that they simply hold a copy of your data after your relationship ends, but that they have permission to continue using it. Few content creators would object to Facebook keeping a random copy of their content on a tape drive. It's like a book publisher keeping your a copy of a rejected manuscript in a warehouse somewhere. The real problem is when Facebook uses that content to further their business interests. Likewise, the publisher shouldn't be sending that rejected manuscript around for others to mine for ideas. (that said, to avoid the temptation that gives rise to this precise problem, it's common practice for publishers to return rejected manuscripts)
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]