2 ms·
The obvious critique is that people in extreme poverty deserve every attention moment they can get, to derive a benefit with the lowest cost (to them) possible.
by ggm 8y ago
The obvious critique is that people in extreme poverty deserve every attention moment they can get, to derive a benefit with the lowest cost (to them) possible. But, when this represents an ad-hoc, it can often leave them stranded on a low increment from zero. So, adding proper drains to a favela is good because it reduces child mortality from bad drains, but its still a slum: the fix is unclear but probably involves a revolution.
These mechanisms are good because they can be easily understood and whilst they will require patching and hacking and repair and are inefficient and can't do all things, if they can provide a stable heat source to remove the burden of burning things, which actually kills more women and children because of lack of oxygen, CO/CO2 poisoning, asthma and other effects, there is a huge positive upside.
But, as has been said since at least the 1920s what we really need is soviet power, plus electricity.