11 ms·
Can you tell me precisely what question you want the answer to?
by pg 19y ago
Can you tell me precisely what question you want the answer to?
- eru 19y agoYes. I want to see if giving an item upvotes makes it more likely that it gets more upvotes still. I hope to be able to distinguish statistically between the influence of inherent quality and current upvotes. My arm-chair hypothesis is that prevalence of inherent quality leads to a geometric distribution. And prevalence of attention grabbing effects should make the distribution look more like a power-law. If that simple histogram turns out to be inconclusive extending the analysis from the final scores of items to their value over time might help. P.S. A simple observation started me on this line of thought: I had the feeling that upvoting comments close to mine makes it more likely that mine will be upvoted. I wonder whether such strategic voting really makes a difference.
- pg 19y agoHow about this: can you tell me precisely what statistic you want?
- eru 19y agoYes. For each n, please state how many comments got exactly n points. Is this precisely enough?
- byrneseyeview 19y agoHow will you control your experiment without arbitrarily voting stuff up? Especially if you don't have access to data on how long something is on the new page?
- eru 19y agoI just wanted to look at the distribution of points in the first place. And see if I can discover anything interesting. Your questions are valuable hints. Why are you so concerned about the new page? Perhaps I should have made clearer that my focus was on the comments not so much on the articles.