4 ms·
It showed Stanford as one of the cities, but clicking the link displayed the message "The Meetup Group you're looking for doesn't exist." It would be a shame i
by gnicholas 8y ago
It showed Stanford as one of the cities, but clicking the link displayed the message "The Meetup Group you're looking for doesn't exist."
It would be a shame if we had to rely on Meetup.com to organize these things. I've heard complaints from attendees and organizers about the platform/fees. Ideas for alternative ways to organize?
- all2 8y agoopenmeet.io is available. We could spin up a Django or flask site and build a HN style meetup application.
- _rovyko 8y ago>openmeet.io I've heard bad things about the IO TLD. What about openmeet.org? I'm just starting in Webdev but I'd like to be involved! https://hackernoon.com/stop-using-io-domain-names-for-production-traffic-b6aa17eeac20 https://hackernoon.com/stop-using-io-domain-names-for-produc... https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15663988 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15663988
- CydeWeys 8y agoOr even more terrifyingly, this: http://domainincite.com/23957-un-ruling-may-put-io-domains-at-risk http://domainincite.com/23957-un-ruling-may-put-io-domains-a... Fortuitously, .dev happens to be hitting General Availability tomorrow. And both meetup.dev and openmeet.dev are still available! Disclaimer: .dev is my baby.
- meruru 8y agoI remember seeing a federated meetup.com alternative in the brief time I used Mastodon. I can't find it anymore though.
- iBelieve 8y agoYou might be thinking of https://gettogether.community/ https://gettogether.community/ (https://github.com/GetTogetherComm/GetTogether https://github.com/GetTogetherComm/GetTogether)
- meruru 8y agoYes, I think that was it. It needs work, I can't even figure out how to search for my city.
- mushufasa 8y agoI've actually run into what seems like a dozen startups who are, in various ways, attempting to build a better Meetup.com. The technology doesn't seem to be the hard part -- it's the business model and mindshare. Go for it as well if you like, but rest assured that there are already several talented people already trying to figure this out.
- karmelapple 8y agoIt’s a social network. As an attendee, by having a meetup.com account, I’m told about other similar meetups. And it works reasonably well. If some federated option were to work, there would have to be ways for various meetups to broadcast their existence, and have these recommendations be available.
- qnsi 8y agofor me it doesn't work that well... There are a lot of dead meetups, with no meetings littering the search. I also have a hard time following groups I am interested in. I think meetup sends a lot of emails at start, so meetup mails land in my spam folder now. Also if a lot of people click "Im interested" I think there should be a forum enabled, so you can find someone else to organize the meetup. Now it says "become an organiser" but it's hard to do it alone IMO.
- qnsi 8y agoCan you list some interesting alternatives? I searched before and found few people on HN trying to improve meetup experience, but most are dead now
- riffic 8y agoIf you do, can you look at the existing ActivityPub implementations for some pointers??
- Animats 8y agoRight. And the SF "group" is just a collection of links to vaguely related events in the past.
- chiefalchemist 8y agoNot to get off topic but I was a Meetup organizer for a year. In theory it's worth the ~$8 - $10 per month they charge. But I have two major complaints (from when I used MU a couple years ago): 1) Their onboarding sucks __for organizers__. When someone is new to Meetup, Meetup forces them to pick three (or more) groups to join as part of the sign up process. The person may or may not have an legit interest in your group. Maybe they came for another group and your group is just fulfilling the onboarding process. This matters because if as an organizer you went for their cheaper tier w/ a smaller group size you get to that cap fairly quickly. Which mean you either keep the group closed and "eat" the dead members, or you pay more so you don't have to close the group. 2) You can send a group email / message but they have no analytics. Not even something as basic as an open rate. You can export members but not their emails so something like MailChimp is not an option. After a year I decided that Meetup was good for Meetup but not for me.
- jsingleton 8y agoWe found meetup.com to be bad value for our meetup too so we moved away https://unop.uk/starting-a-tech-meetup/ https://unop.uk/starting-a-tech-meetup/
- neilv 8y agoI hope it's not sacrilege to say in a dotcom startup-oriented community, but, as individuals and technologists, it's good practice to see how we can get by without dotcom tracking. In this case, for example, perhaps a meetup can be coordinated by simply posting the meeting info to HN. If there's a real need for an turnout estimate ahead of time, such as making a group table/room reservation at a venue that requires that, see how low-tech that can be. For example, an optional RSVP to email, and guess at the RSVP ratio.
- karmelapple 8y agoAs someone who has organized many meetups, there is always a real need for turnout estimates in my mind. Can you describe an example you have in mind where that’s not the case? I would typically try to have some snacks and drinks, and wouldn’t want to be bringing either way too many or far too few. Also, I want everyone to be comfortable and have a positive experience, so if we have a concert hall for a meetup of 5 people, or a meeting room for a turnout of 100, plans need to change to give a quality experience for attendees.
- gnicholas 8y agoFor the meetup based at/near Stanford, we could meet various spots on campus and have nearby food/drink options, and plenty of space. Perhaps outside the Treehouse?
- dylan604 8y agoWhat about a 'Meet HN' to go along with 'Ask HN'?