6 ms·
The value of my time that it would require far exceeds the value of this activity. It's of net negative economic benefit to society.
by pfdietz 8y ago
The value of my time that it would require far exceeds the value of this activity. It's of net negative economic benefit to society.
- c1sc0 8y agoYou do realize that there are plenty of countries where people separate recyclables at home, right? And that it’s not a big deal. Your attitude is why we can’t have nice things, like a healthy planet for my grandkids to live on.
- edmundsauto 8y agoI wonder which is more expensive to the environment: OPs refusal to sort recyclables, or the existence of your descendants.
- darkerside 8y agoIf it's so valuable, you could pay for someone else to do it for you. Just like you pay to have people clean your house, wash and sort your dishes, do your taxes, walk your dog, etc etc etc.
- baq 8y agoYou have no idea how much time it takes if you think it’s too much. Source: living in a place that legally requires to sort garbage into 5 (five) fractions.
- shard 8y agoWhere I live, we sort 6 different categories: Food, glass, metal, paper, hard plastic, soft plastic. Was a hassle at first, but now I get warm fuzzies knowing that I am reducing waste.
- speedplane 8y agoI only have 2 categories of recycling, and even those can be a hassle (e.g., I can never if soft plastic bags go in the plastic bin). But I too get the warm "fuzzies" when I do it. But those fuzzies are more than just being seen as "eco-conscious" or whatever, it's about efficiency. We go through enormous lengths to be efficient about our time, sleep, food we eat, etc. Being efficient with the products we use and waste we create makes me feel like my life is running like a precision machine rather than a beat up old clunker. I'd personally love the concept of living a life that created no waste, where every output I created could be used as another's input. Alas, I don't think we're there yet.
- baq 8y agowe used to be there before industrialization. there was scarcely any waste - pretty much everything solid except broken pottery was repurposed for something else. the challenge is making it reasonable to do when economies of scale make it cheaper to discard stuff instead of reuse.
- speedplane 8y agoThere was plenty of waste pre-industrialization... e.g., the most basic form: feces. In some cases, industrialization made us more efficient with our waste; modern waste management plants can turn feces into methane and heat homes. Industrialization's negative effect wasn't about efficiency, it was that it allowed us to create far more stuff. Today, we go through far more single-use products than ever could have been imagined pre-industrialization. We're far more efficient about handling that waste than they were, but because we create so, so much more of it today, the net effect is more waste. So even though industrialization had a big effect, it's not for the reasons you raise. Going one step further, industrialization doesn't have to be the enemy. There could very plausibly exist a society with mass plentiful produced goods that all get easily recycled/reused. Industrialization can help here.
- busterarm 8y agoOnly a couple of products are efficiently recycled anyway and as more types of recycling we have people sort at home, the _less efficiently_ we recycle.
- saltcured 8y agoI'm sure you could hire someone whose time is less valuable so they can do your part for you...
- pfdietz 8y agoAnd I'm sure that would also be grotesquely economically destructive. Let's do some simple math, shall we? One of the most recycleable commodities is aluminum. A soda can contains about 15 grams of metal. You can get maybe $0.40/lb for aluminum can metal. This comes to about $.013/can. If I were to value my time at $10/hour, then if I spend more than a few seconds recycling a can it isn't worth it. So, no, it's not worth it to hire anyone to recycle most stuff. Labor is far too expensive, compared to the value produced by recycling.
- jobigoud 8y agoBut it doesn't take a few seconds. When you are about to throw it you just throw it in a different bin. It doesn't take more time. Where i live (yes Europe) we have compostable, recyclable and general bins, so we have the same mini bins at home. And nobody was recycling 40 years ago so it's just a matter of habit/culture.
- pfdietz 8y agoThey don't require you to wash out your cans before recycling? That itself will take more than the couple of seconds per can. Yes, it's habit/culture. Lots of silly things are done just because it's the habit to do them. It doesn't mean they're good ideas.