4 ms·
I find it ironic that Windows was long derided for being unstable and in constant need of reboots, and now they're basically deliberately reducing uptime. Unwa
by userbinator 8y ago
I find it ironic that Windows was long derided for being unstable and in constant need of reboots, and now they're basically deliberately reducing uptime.
Unwanted "new features" and the aspect of silently changing behaviour aside, the technology to patch files in memory and on disk without having to restart or otherwise disturb unnecessarily the entire system has been around for a very long time (and amusingly enough, malware is probably the biggest application of those techniques today); and sending only diffs instead of entire files which may be 99% the same as before would probably save a huge amount of bandwidth.
- HenryBemis 8y agoI was discussing with a friend on solutions on how to make your PC being 'never idle'. As he told me, if the PC is never idle, then Win10 won't enforce any updates/reboots. I do not know how true is that, but when I suggested he use MouseJiggler [1] he thanked me and told me 'it worked'. It is a stand-alone/portable .exe that 'does exactly what it says on the tin'. I use it to keep away screensavers/screenlocks (on machines I don't 100% control). [1]: https://mouse-jiggler.en.uptodown.com/windows https://mouse-jiggler.en.uptodown.com/windows Edit: I keep away from W10 so I don't know to what extend this would help. I assume it would delay unwanted reboots, but I don't know the W10 update-forcing mechanism, and on the diagram depicted on the article I don't see any 'idling' criteria.
- smush 8y agoA keyboard-based similar tool is Zhorn's Caffeine which puts a pot of coffee in your system tray and presses F24(?) every 15 seconds.
- ganomi 8y agoThere is a nice little tool to stop the reboots: https://www.udse.de/en/windows-10-reboot-blocker https://www.udse.de/en/windows-10-reboot-blocker It changes the active hours every hour so that you will never be outside of active hours.
- AckSyn 8y agoI find this one to be more palatable, and it being powershell exposes the user to the actual commands that update and change the active hours: https://github.com/Maimer/update-active-hours https://github.com/Maimer/update-active-hours
- mintplant 8y agoYears ago I followed a guide I found online [0] which involves renaming the "Reboot" scheduled task file and creating a folder with the same name in its location, so that the OS fails to re-create the task file. Haven't had an unexpected reboot since. This technique was familiar to me from the Kindle jailbreaking scene, in which creating a directory with a certain path would cause the Kindle's auto-updater to error out when it tried to `rm` what it saw as a preexisting partially-downloaded update file (the Kindle's OS is Linux-based, so the file-delete operation fails on a directory). [0] https://www.windowscentral.com/how-prevent-windows-10-rebooting-after-installing-updates https://www.windowscentral.com/how-prevent-windows-10-reboot... (including the "Additional Steps")
- robocat 8y agoBut when you need to reboot for any other reason (e.g. Windows bugs out), then the update happens, and your have to wait. Shift-shutdown didn't prevent this either. Unexpected updates was a primary reason I am now using Linux full time (rather than part time as previously).
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- close04 8y agoUptime is not in itself a number to chase as long as that interruption doesn't come at the cost of your time and effort. Home users don't care about uptime, they care about using their computer without forced interruptions. And that's what MS should be focusing on: doing the updates as unobtrusively as possible.
- AlexandrB 8y agoPerhaps that’s fine for home users but I’ve lost days of test data thanks to Windows deciding that it’s a good time to update. Windows 10 is not a suitable OS for any kind of professional work IMHO. Edit: that’s not mentioning how Microsoft’s aggressive telemetry is probably exfiltraring sensitive corporate info unintentionally.
- close04 8y agoHow does that contradict what I said? > they care about using their computer without forced interruptions > MS should be focusing on: doing the updates as unobtrusively as possible How exactly did your problem happen? There are ways to manage this so it doesn't cause this kind of loss. It's not ideal that you have to use them but if you work with valuable data you should take all precautions out of principle.
- AlexandrB 8y agoOops, that's a reading comprehension fail on my part. I now know there are (hacky, unsupported) ways around it. But on principle, I should not have to fight my OS for control of the computer.