6 ms·
I don't like it. But it raises another problem: What's a democracy? Is Turkey a democracy? If not, why not? Is it a flawed [1] democracy then? [1] Like the US?
by Tepix 8y ago
I don't like it. But it raises another problem: What's a democracy? Is Turkey a democracy? If not, why not? Is it a flawed [1] democracy then?
[1] Like the US? https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/america-democracy-rated-donald-trump-not-fully-democratic-us-president-report-the-economist-a8195121.html https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/america-de...
- hguhghuff 8y agoDemocracy is a dictatorship of the majority. The problem with our form of democracy is that once voted in, the winner is given power. Instead, power should be expendable. Votes that a party wins should be able to be used to either to push through legislation or to defeat legislation, and once those votes are used, they’re gone. This would lead politicians to be much more careful about how they expend their power, spending votes in what they really want, and spending votes to stop what they really disagree with. Closely related concept is that it should not be “one person, one vote”. Instead, everyone should get 100 or 1000 votes to distribute across the politicians/parties that represent their many interests and values.
- jcims 8y agoHow would they reup and why would we punish the representatives that participate in more decisions vs less?
- hguhghuff 8y agoPunish? I dint understand. Politicians get votes to spend, either on backing or opposing legislation.
- Sammi 8y agoOnly if you assume a voting system like First Past The Post where the winner indeed takes all. May countries have voting systems where candidates and parties take proportional seats in parliament according to their votes. This means there is a need for coalitions and consensus seeking across in order to get anything voted through parliament.
- Joakal 8y agoThis already happens in most countries. No one votes for a lone representative's crazy proposal. I notice something, with your proposal one person can keep proposing 100 to 1000 votes to make all taxes go to them, effectively killing the government.
- hguhghuff 8y agoActually it should definitely be the case that a line crazy proposal can be put up by an independent politician, who backs it with the votes they won. If other politicians oppose it, then they can spend their votes/power on defeating it. But of course if they spend all their votes on defeating things then they get nothing done. So so small initiatives would be able to get through, that currently cannot because there is currently no cost to politician opposing things. Expendable power is the idea, not unlimited power, which is what we have now.
- Joakal 8y agoWell, having trillions of dollars go to one person instead of defeating a bill because a politician wants to cling to power. That's.. unrealistic. In fact, if I offer 1 billion dollars to each politician that votes for my bill of 1 trillion dollars for me? Well, I get 1 trillion dollars, and politicians get a cut. I keep at least 600 billion dollars. Still overall a loss for democracy. I think culture is the issue. Independence of judiciary and anti-corruption investigations will lead to a golden democracy. Few countries can accomplish this.
- microcolonel 8y ago> Is Turkey a democracy? Some say not. > If not, why not? Probably because the elections are thoroughly suspect, and people have a weird habit of being abducted. > Is it a flawed democracy like the US? Well, it is probably flawed in the sense that the elections are thoroughly suspect and people seem to be getting abducted a lot. Neither of these particular criticisms apply to the U.S. in anything approaching the same capacity. > https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/america-democracy-rated-donald-trump-not-fully-democratic-us-president-report-the-economist-a8195121.html https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/america-de... Ah yes, the UK EIU calling the U.S. a "flawed democracy", and not the UK, when in the UK politicians are seen openly calling to discard the result of the largest referendum with the highest turnout in the history of the country, more or less because they do not agree with the people. I don't know what their indicators are, mainly because I don't want to fill out a twenty-field survey just to find out if the PDF even explains their methodology, but what could they possibly be measuring? As for the question what is a democracy, I feel like it's easier to answer what isn't a democracy. In China, the President has committed to live out the rest of his life in the office; so maybe we start there.
- Accacin 8y agoI think you are misunderstanding how our system works, perhaps if you read about how our system works you'd realise why this is not really a bad thing. However, our system is FAR from perfect (and I'm not claiming it to be).
- microcolonel 8y ago> I think you are misunderstanding how our system works, perhaps if you read about how our system works you'd realise why this is not really a bad thing. However, our system is FAR from perfect (and I'm not claiming it to be). Whose system?
- Accacin 8y agoUK! Sorry I wasn't more clear heh.
- fallingfrog 8y agoIt’s a democracy when we put a fuddruckers in Ankara.
- raducu 8y agoTurkey is a democracy, but democracy in itself is meaningless, "rule of law" also needs to apply.
- danols 8y agoThe definition of democracy varies over time and is defined by each new US administration to best serve their political and personal agenda.
- mda 8y agoIt is a democracy. Democracy by definition is flawed.
- deltron3030 8y agoDepends on your perspective. Democracy is essentially an outcome and dynamic state of a society, formed by the opinions and opinion driven actions of individuals. So in a different culture with different "influencers" at the top, and therefore a different public sphere, the outcome can be something completely different from what most people associate with democracy (positive and negative freedom). It's basically a shared experience. Religion was first as centralizing force, then came the traditional mass media and now there is social media and individual influencers, everything is getting less gated. The dilemma is that most people didn't learn the true hierarchies in school, or how the system and democracy really works and what holds it together. And those who research it on their own may easily drift off into conspiracy stuff, because conspiracies feed the people with tiny bits of the truth (among many lies) they weren't meant to know.
- anoncake 8y agoThat's an odd definition. So a democracy with no corruption, no power imbalances and a perfectly informed populace that never makes a wrong decision (which is of course unrealistic) is by definition not a democracy?
- Joakal 8y agoChina and North Korea are democracies, even if they effectively have one party. Would USA's effectively having a two party system be better definition of democracy? Meanwhile, most other democracies have multi-party systems.
- pjc50 8y agoI'm reminded of an old Tony Benn joke "the Americans have a one-party state, but with typical American luxury, they have two of them."
- Sammi 8y agoThis is indeed a complicated subject and there exists a non-profit that tries to track freedom/democracy in the world. This is their latest report: https://freedomhouse.org/report/freedom-world/freedom-world-2019 https://freedomhouse.org/report/freedom-world/freedom-world-...