3 ms·
The only solution would be a tradeoff no one would agree to--guaranteed minimum income, but no franchise for net negative taxpayers.
by philwelch 16y ago
The only solution would be a tradeoff no one would agree to--guaranteed minimum income, but no franchise for net negative taxpayers.
- melvinram 16y agoBy that you mean "The right to vote". Here in the US I haven't ever heard of the word used in that context so I thought other's would find it useful to know what you meant. http://www.google.com/dictionary?langpair=en|en&q=franchise http://www.google.com/dictionary?langpair=en|en&q=franch...
- philwelch 16y agoIt's the root word of "disenfranchised", which is the form most people are familiar with.
- jamesbritt 16y agoAKA, No representation without taxation
- icegreentea 16y agoI think a lot of people pick it up from reading Starship Troopers. I know I did.
- Qz 16y agoThat's an absolutely terrible idea.
- philwelch 16y agoI anticipate a lot of people would think so (which is why I called it a tradeoff no one would agree to). It would be more interesting to know why you think it's a terrible idea.
- ezy 16y agoWell, for one, it treats poor people like criminals who need to be punished for being poor. Granted, we do that to a large degree in the US now implicitly, but this would be very explicit -- and, I feel, tremendously mean-spirited. More practically, it removes the poor as a voice in their own governance by using what amounts to a bribe. And in practice, it would probably remove most poor people from the voting rolls, because short-term, taking the 10k or whatever to make ends meet is the rational decision over pulling a lever that may or may not have any affect on your particular situation. I think my main objection here is that there is no real guarantee that the extra money, generally, will push people out of poverty and back into enfranchisement -- and if it doesn't work, what you've done is institutionalize bribery and legitimize an explicit oligarchy of the rich.
- Sisyphus_of_IT 16y agoSo if you think there's "no real guarantee that the extra money, generally, will push people out of poverty", then why bother giving them extra money at all?
- gojomo 16y agoA milder form of the same would be to have a bicameral legislature, where one house is elected by universal suffrage (including the perpetually dependent), and another house limited to those who are net-positive taxpayers. (Or perhaps similar: subject to a poll tax equal or larger than the guaranteed minimum income.) An interesting question is whether government employees and large government contractors count as dependents for representation purposes or not. Some of the same tight-feedback-driving-increased-benefits-without-regard-for-true-value loops that are of concern in the generous-welfare case are also at play with regard to civil servants and large companies wholly dependent on government spending.