3 ms·
I feel like this is fair. People like to paint enemies of the east while essentially letting the west get away with much more heinous stuff. The difference of
by dijit 8y ago
I feel like this is fair. People like to paint enemies of the east while essentially letting the west get away with much more heinous stuff.
The difference of course is that we implicitly trust US tech companies, of course we do, nobody else has such a monopoly on CPUs and Operating System production. Not to mention web browsers and all kinds of technology. Avoiding the USA in your tech stack is quite literally impossible.
And we permit the US government (by extension the NSA and 5eyes) to do what ever they want to us without fear of repercussion because what course of action could we take? As long as we are not a US citizen we have literally zero protections.
it’s to the point that my EU based company is applying US sanctions (to Crimea for instance, where no EU sanction covers telecommunications) because we would fall out of line in many of our contracts from US tech companies.
It is clearly a double standard. But the answer is to hold the US to account. Not bring more of this hostile crap in.
- microcolonel 8y ago> People like to paint enemies of the east while essentially letting the west get away with much more heinous stuff. > It is clearly a double standard. But the answer is to hold the US to account. Not bring more of this hostile crap in. I mean, I think it's the nature of things like this that they are justifiable but not pleasant to suffer from. This is weaponry, not poetry; if theirs is better we suffer, that's it.
- dijit 8y agoEven if you're right it is not perceived that way. It's akin to economic dependence. The thought of Europe depending on Russia (or the USA) for energy/electricity is unfathomable, yet we allow the US in particular to be the "holder" of an enormous part of our economy. IT is literally used by every industry and in some cases is very central to it. (IE; power stations make heavy use of automation and computers with CPU's and Operating Systems living at the very heart of that.) It's troubling that we don't do more to offset this, especially if you're right, and holding this industry is a weapon of sorts.
- YUMad 8y agoEurope does depend on Russia for energy, at least in winter.
- dijit 8y agoIn natural gas; https://www.forbes.com/sites/annalisagirardi/2018/12/12/growing-dependent-on-russia-the-gas-routes-in-europe/#3b311fdb62b0 https://www.forbes.com/sites/annalisagirardi/2018/12/12/grow... However there is no strong dependence: https://www.forbes.com/sites/davekeating/2018/07/19/how-dependent-is-germany-on-russian-gas/#200285493b48 https://www.forbes.com/sites/davekeating/2018/07/19/how-depe... tl;dr: 23% of German power comes from gas; that 35% of that gas comes from Russia. That's a power dependency of roughly 8%. Personally I don't think that's the same as being held entirely captive by a monopoly country as is the case when it comes to IT. But, it's a fair point, I'll take it. Replacing 8% of a countries energy input would be difficult, but I would argue that it's not impossible.
- YUMad 8y ago> In natural gas; https://www.forbes.com/sites/annalisagirardi/2018/12/12/grow.. https://www.forbes.com/sites/annalisagirardi/2018/12/12/grow.... > However there is no strong dependence: https://www.forbes.com/sites/davekeating/2018/07/19/how-depe.. https://www.forbes.com/sites/davekeating/2018/07/19/how-depe.... > tl;dr: 23% of German power comes from gas; that 35% of that gas comes from Russia. That's a power dependency of roughly 8%. > Personally I don't think that's the same as being held entirely captive by a monopoly country as is the case when it comes to IT. > But, it's a fair point, I'll take it. Dependence used to be worse, this is result of efforts to lower it because Russia was using it as a blackmail tool. But I'm just nitpicking anyway, it's not the actual topic.
- dijit 8y ago>But I'm just nitpicking anyway, it's not the actual topic. Maybe not, but it's a very good point. We used to have a reliance on Russia but due to poor behaviour we took steps to remove their power. I believe we should do that again with technology in regards to the USA.
- hatsunearu 8y agoI don't like the false equivalence of what the US-lead western intelligence does and what the Chinese state does. Obviously in a perfect world none of the "bad" things happen, but I'd rather take the US government spying on me than the Chinese government spy on me.
- miaklesp 8y ago> I'd rather take the US government spying on me than the Chinese government spy on me. Not everyone shares your opinion.
- iknowstuff2 8y agoChinese don't randomly & regularly drone attack the people they surviel which is some nice peace of mind.
- OG_BME 8y agoIf the Uighurs had a voice, I think they might have something to say about that[1]. [1] https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/global-opinions/china-has-turned-xinjiang-into-a-zone-of-repression--and-a-frightening-window-into-the-future/2019/02/23/780092fe-353f-11e9-854a-7a14d7fec96a_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/global-opinions/chin...
- YUMad 8y agoCool story bro. Me, just like Uyghurs, would prefer to be spied on by the evil empire which DOESN'T rule me. Uyghurs are ruled by China so they'd rather be spied on by us for sure. I live in Europe so I'm ruled by US, and therefore would prefer China to spy on me.
- 687u655r 8y agoSame with the Iraqis.
- ataturk 8y agoIt's not a false equivalance. Yes, China is worse on human rights and they are using technology to enable tyranny. But the US is bugging all these devices and they don't like to be called out on it! I never imagined that in 2019 we would be having this conversation about rogue intelligence agencies that have been so successful in bugging all our tech. The cyberpunks of the '80s lost the argument. We can regain our footing, however. We can demand spy-free, hard-crypto electronics.
- everdrive 8y agoIf we accept this moral equivalency, it still doesn't make support or acceptance of Huawei OK. This line of argument is all about moral blame, and not related to practical outcome. Correctly morally blaming the US for its practices won't protect you from Chinese malfeasance.
- dijit 8y agoI agree. I said it was fair, I didn’t say it was acceptable.