5 ms·
Dialysis is a proxy issue. The majority of renal failure in the US is the result of diabetes or hypertension. The huge increase in the number of dialysis patie
by jdietrich 16y ago
Dialysis is a proxy issue.
The majority of renal failure in the US is the result of diabetes or hypertension. The huge increase in the number of dialysis patients is overwhelmingly attributable to these two causes. In the vast majority of these cases, renal failure can be prevented with relatively inexpensive intervention to better manage the primary condition.
In most other developed countries, it is politically straightforward to spend $20,000 a year on coaxing and cajoling a patient into managing their diabetes better in order to prevent them from becoming a $70,000 a year dialysis patient. Needless to say that the benefits to this approach are greater than just a cost saving.
The United States has a quite peculiar set of popular attitudes to healthcare. It is clear that a large number of US citizens believe that healthcare ought not be a universal right, but most also find it unpalatable to simply allow people to die of preventable diseases. Consequently, cheap early intervention to preserve health is often shunned in favour of expensive, late intervention to prevent death. To my mind the most egregious example of this is drug abuse and alcoholism - huge amounts are spent on ER care for disastrously ill addicts, but little is spent on basic social work and rehabilitation.
I can't honestly say that I understand the mindset that completely opposes government involvement in healthcare, but it seems obvious to me that the current situation is the worst of all worlds - the worst outcomes and the highest costs. I don't know how healthcare became such an ideological battleground, but it's not doing anyone any good - not patients and certainly not the taxpayer. I really don't want to be negative, but I have no idea how this stalemate can be broken.
- alecco 16y agoWhat's perplexing to me is how big soda and junk food suppliers get away using so much sodium in their products to increase sales.
- puredemo 16y agoThey "get away with it" because hundreds of millions of people continually buy their products.
- andreyf 16y agoFor what it's worth, the NYC Department of Health and Mental Hygiene is running a "education campaign" addressing exactly that: http://www.nyc.gov/html/doh/html/pr2009/pr057-09.shtml http://www.nyc.gov/html/doh/html/pr2009/pr057-09.shtml We also have one of the highest taxes on nicotine sales in the country, for similar reasons. I say that government can experiment in social engineering, but only as long as they're completely transparent about what they're doing.
- stretchwithme 16y agoI say we have rights that supercede your say so.
- dantheman 16y agoThe mindset that is against government healthcare is one based on a clear conception of natural rights theory. It recognizes the validity of negative rights and the complete contradiction that is positive rights. Though most aren't against providing healthcare through non-coercive means such as private charity.
- stretchwithme 16y agoSo, you'd classify a right to the belongings of others as a positive right?
- dantheman 16y agoYes, positive rights are claims that someone can make against another -- I have a right to food, you must provide it for me, etc. In this case, I have a right to healthcare, you must provide it for me. From wikipedia: Under the theory of positive and negative rights, a negative right is a right not to be subjected to an action of another person or group—a government, for example—usually in the form of abuse or coercion. A positive right is a right to be subjected to an action of another person or group. In theory, a negative right forbids others from acting against the right holder, while a positive right obligates others to act with respect to the right holder. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Negative_and_positive_rights http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Negative_and_positive_rights
- stretchwithme 16y agoSo all people have the right to have all people provide their material needs. Seems unworkable to me. Maybe it just works for parasites.
- gloob 16y ago"I am a citizen, you must hold (if you are the government) or fund (if you are a taxpayer) an election for me to vote in." What's your feeling on that positive right? I've encountered people who argue against democracy, and I've encountered people who will re-word the right as stated above and then call it a negative right. I disagree with the former, and the latter only succeed in demonstrating that the difference between positive and negative rights is one of phrasing, and not of the right itself. Do you have a different take on the matter?
- dkarl 16y agoIt is clear that a large number of US citizens believe that healthcare ought not be a universal right, but most also find it unpalatable to simply allow people to die of preventable diseases. That's the dilemma of a certain category of moralists in the United States: people shouldn't have anything they can't pay for, so they deserve to suffer and die, but it's immoral not to help them and unseemly to leave them helpless and suffering. Torn between the desire to enforce justice on others (let the bums die!), fulfill their own moral obligations (do unto others!), and maintain appearances (we're ranked with Mexico, for God's sake?), they muddle through in contradictions. In reply to dantheman's sibling comment, there may be some people who reason that way, but the popular argument is based on no clear conception of anything. It's just contradictory impulses that aren't logically reconciled at all. That's how it can be so popular to decry "socialism" while simultaneously defining socialism so broadly that almost all Americans support some instances of it.
- arethuza 16y agoI'm in the UK - I'm more than happy that some of my taxes go to giving everyone a pretty decent level of healthcare, does that make me a socialist?
- jamii 16y agoPretty much. Between the NHS and the dole Britain is a fairly socialist country, as is most of western Europe. I'm not sure when socialism became a dirty word.
- Retric 16y agoI don't think tithing a small percentage of your income to help society's poor is a socialist concept. Traditionally you gave the church 10% and they spent much of that on the poor.
- rdtsc 16y ago> I'm not sure when socialism became a dirty word. I think certain interests in US have put a considerable effort into their propaganda to make it so. It stems from the "Red Scare" and what used to be the fear-du-jour for us before it was replaced by "terrorism". But the previous fear hasn't been completely replaced. It was planted there and periodically, when appropriate, politicians and other interests are able to tap into it to further their purposes. Think of these fears as backdoors into into a system. The typical access to a system is through a rational, objective argument. The faster and more effective is to bypass that use the "fear" backdoor. These fears take a while to cultivate. Once they are there, they are ready to be used and abused.
- Mz 16y agoIn most other developed countries, it is politically straightforward to spend $20,000 a year on coaxing and cajoling a patient into managing their diabetes better in order to prevent them from becoming a $70,000 a year dialysis patient. Needless to say that the benefits to this approach are greater than just a cost saving. I agree with your basic points. But as someone who both is American and has a serious life threatening medical condition, I think there must be some deeper reason for this American quirk. I know that a lot of "standard wisdom" concerning nutrition and the like not only doesn't work for me but is actively harmful to me. I have managed to get off 8 or 9 prescription drugs and now manage my health issues via diet and lifestyle (and herbs and supplements when necessary). But I have gotten there by following a pig-headed, asinine, "don't tread on me" sort of path. It has been really important to actively reject outside intervention in favor of home-grown solutions for my issue. I suspect something similar may be true for most Americans. America was founded by social outcasts who left their countries of origins to go elsewhere under really harsh, deadly conditions -- conditions which were, nonetheless, more tolerable than the social expectations they were fleeing. Most people cannot fathom my choice to live without furniture and without a car. I sleep on the floor and most of the time I own only two or three outfits. I get lots of comments from people who are often just trying to make conversation but nonetheless are basically butting in to things that they know nothing about and which are none of their business. For example, I do not own a jacket. Jackets are too hard to keep adequately clean and most are not designed to be washed regularly (ie every single I wear it). I find that undershirts work better for me than jackets. I have also been known to walk to work in flip flops in 40 degree weather. People inevitably feel compelled to tell me to get a jacket or comment that my feet must be cold or something. It is usually under circumstances where I do not have the time (even if I had the inclination) to explain to them that whatever annoyance I suffer from the cold is laughable compared to the suffering it has allowed me to walk away from. It is also usually from people at work, this in spite of a company policy that no one other than my immediate boss is to offer "constructive feedback" on my appearance, and then only if I am in violation of dress code. It annoys me to no end yet I realize that if I made a big stink about it, I would most likely be the one deemed to be 'a problem' (and it would unnecessarily call attention to my medical condition, which I do not wish to do). Most of these people are well-meaning and genuinely concerned for my welfare and/or just trying to make conversation. So I try to handle things diplomatically and lightly and good-naturedly, without referencing the serious medical situation that drives my unconventional literally "remarkable" (ie worthy of remarking upon by these people) choices. So I think it is possible that most Americans have some deep-seated reason(s) for balking at the idea of someone interceding in their diet and lifestyle choices at an earlier stage in the process. I know outside interference is one of the things that I feel most threatened by. Since I don't have a doctor's note for doing what I do, I can't really justify or defend it on some kind of "legal" grounds or some such. I'm just some lone nut-case who occasionally makes fantastical claims that most folks find unbelievable -- an issue I work very hard to keep out of my place of employment. It is unfortunate that the results are so expensive. But I am not entirely convinced that the cajoling and convincing that works in other cultures would necessarily be such a good thing for a society of outcasts who could not conform and chose to face so much hardship in order to start over elsewhere. For me, conforming -- even in seemingly small matters like wearing a jacket -- leads to enormous suffering and would eventually kill me. So I just am unable to "go along to get along", in spite of internal wiring that makes me want very much to do that. But I just can't. Maybe a lot of Americans also just can't, yet are willing to accept intervention at a later stage of more serious crisis because at that point there is nothing to lose and a great deal to gain.
- Tangurena 16y ago> Consequently, cheap early intervention to preserve health is often shunned in favour of expensive, late intervention to prevent death. To my mind the most egregious example of this is drug abuse and alcoholism - huge amounts are spent on ER care for disastrously ill addicts, but little is spent on basic social work and rehabilitation. One example of this that is frustrating and heartbreaking at the same time is a piece by Gladwell called "Million Dollar Murray" http://www.gladwell.com/2006/2006_02_13_a_murray.html http://www.gladwell.com/2006/2006_02_13_a_murray.html