4 ms·
Relative to the Military or Social Security budgets, the cost would barely even register on the balance sheet. WTF? We already spent more on education than the
by yummyfajitas 16y ago
Relative to the Military or Social Security budgets, the cost would barely even register on the balance sheet.
WTF? We already spent more on education than the military ($859B > $731B, circa 2008, 2009 numbers not available yet). If we tripled spending, education would be bigger than SS, military, medicare and medicaid combined. Unless you are Paul Krugman, I think that level of spending would register on the balance sheet.
http://www.usgovernmentspending.com/ http://www.usgovernmentspending.com/
Further, teachers are already paid roughly as well as engineers (per month worked, not per calendar year). See this thread for details:
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1673075 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1673075
Further, do you have evidence that our "best and brightest" would provide significantly better education than the people we get now? Going by pay/education level, I probably qualify as best and brightest. But I wasn't a great teacher at all.
- tzs 16y agoI once made $7000 for 30 minutes work. By your argument, I'm paid roughly as well as a top athlete (per minute worked, not per calendar year). The problem, of course, is that was a one-time opportunity. I can't get 30-minute intervals at will that pay anything remotely like that.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoThe problem, of course, is that was a one-time opportunity. I can't get 30-minute intervals at will that pay anything remotely like that. Teachers can regularly get 9 months of 37 hour weeks that pay quite well. It's not a one-time opportunity.
- hdctambien 16y ago37 Hour weeks plus time spend prepping for classes, and time spend correcting homework, and time spend helping students after school, plus time spent giving makeup exams ... I was a teacher. I worked way more than the 7-4 that class was in session. That's like saying professional football players only work for 3 hours a week.
- yummyfajitas 16y ago37 hours total, averaged over all full time teachers. Sorry, should have been more clear. This includes work done at home (e.g., grading). http://www.bls.gov/opub/mlr/2008/03/art4full.pdf http://www.bls.gov/opub/mlr/2008/03/art4full.pdf You might have done more work, but you were above average.
- aik 16y ago1. Those stats are from 2003. New programs (especially No Child Left Behind) have caused a lot of teachers to have to put in a lot more hours (of pointless work). 2. Any truly dedicated and correctly-focused teacher I would imagine would have to spend more hours per week, talking to parents, spending extra time with students, research, etc.
- niels_olson 16y agoDocumentation is pointless work? I think doctors, the highest-paying profession, would disagree.
- aik 16y agoDocumentation isn't pointless, but pointless documentation is pointless. If the documentation at any point would turn around to improve on the teacher effectiveness or student learning (and have a specific focus on that), it would make sense, but if the documentation goes into a random folder far away to never return in any form (from my experience) it doesn't help much.
- tzs 16y agoBut engineers (who you compared them to on a per month basis) regularly get 12 months of work, so they aren't comparable.
- mkramlich 16y ago> Further, teachers are already paid roughly as well as engineers (per month worked, not per calendar year). See this thread for details: For certain rather extreme and wide definitions of "roughly". :) Part-time Kindergarten teachers != community college professors != Harvard professors. Pretty wide range of pay there. Whereas engineers always pay pretty damn good, and don't have to babysit children.
- apu 16y agoI dunno how they were calculated, but the education vs. military spending numbers you quote are really out of whack. For education vs. military (dod + homeland security), I see the following from different sources: [1] reports 45.4 billion vs. 660.6 billion [2] reports ~100 billion vs. ~700 billion [3] reports 157 billion vs. 895 billion [4] reports 89.4 billion vs. 544.5 billion Your source is clearly an outlier. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2009_United_States_federal_budget http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2009_United_States_federal_budg... [2] http://www.federalbudget.com/ http://www.federalbudget.com/ [3] http://www.usgovernmentspending.com/budget_pie_gs.php?span=usgs302&year=2010&view=1&expand=&expandC=&units=b&fy=fy11&local=undefined&state=US#usgs302 http://www.usgovernmentspending.com/budget_pie_gs.php?span=u... [4] http://www.usaspending.gov/explore?carryfilters=on http://www.usaspending.gov/explore?carryfilters=on
- yummyfajitas 16y agoEducation is provided by state and local governments. Your sources are all federal. Mine adds up federal, state and local numbers. Military spending is also negligible if we focus only on city government. So what?
- ohyes 16y agoWTF? You are extremely recklessly wrong and should be ashamed of it... We actually spend about 70 billion on education. If you look at this department of education's website, you can find a .pdf or excel sheet of the actual budget. It is here: http://www2.ed.gov/about/overview/budget/history/index.html http://www2.ed.gov/about/overview/budget/history/index.html If you look at the department of defense's website here: http://comptroller.defense.gov/budget.html http://comptroller.defense.gov/budget.html You will notice that its budget is around 700 billion. (Meaning we could multiply the DoE's budget by 10 and be about equal). That is just DoD, and does not include departments like homeland security or the FBI. I will probably get down-voted for this comment, but seriously, check your fucking sources, check their biases, and go to any primary sources available. Don't just click the first link out of Google machine. This is a clear failing of the education system, as you should have been taught this before exiting high school! Government expenditures are quite obviously freely available... There is no need to go to a '.com' website for them. If you actually see who is behind the site: 'http://www.usgovernmentspending.com/ http://www.usgovernmentspending.com/. The proprietor of your cited source (Christopher Chantrill), has a notable political bias. http://www.christopherchantrill.com/ http://www.christopherchantrill.com/ Going by your research ability, I'd say you aren't the best and aren't that bright.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoWe actually spend about 70 billion on education. You have a very narrow definition of "we", which apparently only includes the federal government. It's true - if you focus solely on the branch of government which is not responsible for education, you find low spending on education. Also, Chantrill may be biased, but he also cites his sources. Specifically, the census and the CBO. I refer to his site because he combines both state and federal numbers.