15 ms·
FTC Brings First Case Challenging Fake Paid Reviews on an Indie Retail Website
- jawns 8y ago> Finally, the order imposes a judgment of $12.8 million, which will be suspended upon payment of $50,000 to the Commission and the payment of certain unpaid income tax obligations. If the defendants are later found to have misrepresented their financial condition to the FTC, the full amount of the judgment will immediately become due. That's an interesting way of structuring the penalty. I wonder how enforceable it would be.
- ceejayoz 8y agoWhy wouldn't it be enforceable? It's a court order. It's also quite standard: https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/blogs/business-blog/2016/03/suspension-prevention-story-behind-suspended-judgments https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/blogs/business-blog/2016/03/...
- jawns 8y agoMy apologies. I should have said "recoverable" rather than "enforceable." I would assume that if a company is in trouble with the FTC, it's probably not in the best financial shape after paying even the costs associated with the suspended judgment. So if the FTC finds that the company made an omission and the full judgment comes due, will it actually recover that money? Or is the point to just fine them out of existence, without concern for actually recovering the money?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- ceejayoz 8y agoIf the FTC discovers they've hidden assets, they can go back to court, reinstate the full penalty, and go after those assets. I suspect there'd be additional criminal charges like perjury available to them, as well.
- owenmarshall 8y ago> Or is the point to just fine them out of existence, without concern for actually recovering the money? That’s my read. The FTC seems to be hanging the sword of Damocles in a very public way. If this company doesn’t comply, a press release describing how the US government is absolutely wrecking them is probably worth not recovering all the judgement.
- gav 8y agoI still don't understand why Amazon has done so little to combat the plague of fake reviews. It seems like it's something that's going to blow up eventually and bite them. Along those lines: why do they still value reviews that aren't associated with a purchase? This is the logical first step.
- onlyrealcuzzo 8y agoI think you can assume that Amazon operates in its own best interest. If fake reviews were hurting sales, it'd stop them within weeks. I'm guessing, for the time being, they're helping sales. Although, I haven't bought anything on Amazon in 3 years now, and I never will again. I think this problem is creating HUGE long-term downsides. Those are a lot tougher to calculate/quantify than the short-term benefits, though.
- fossuser 8y agoI wonder what the actual outcome is for sales - fake reviews and counterfeit products have driven me to purchase a certain class of items directly from the manufacturer and not on Amazon. Maybe most people don't bother with this though?
- appsonify 8y agoI no longer have amazon prime-had an awful experience with getting shit shipped, and come to think of it most were cheap alibaba electronics with markup. but when I need some cables or other mundane things, it's convenient, although I don't really need it ASAP TMR like with Prime. I found that it puts a lot of pressure on the couriers and it just ruins the experience for everybody involved. The end of this quarter for Amazon will disappoint.
- trumped 8y agomonoprice.com used to be better for cables and stuff like that... haven't use them in a while though..
- 8y ago
- yazr 8y agoNot clear if this is mostly a "wonder food false advertisement" enforcement, or a "false review" enforcement. Maybe this was an easy "starter case" to advertise (ha ha) the new FTC position.
- advisedwang 8y agoThe FDA usually peruses issues of false health claims, so I'm guessing the latter.
- potatofarmer45 8y agoThere are so many fake reviews on Amazon that the "average" stars for a product are no longer reliable indicators of quality. Especially for cheap electronics (read: headphones), products that have only been listed for a month somehow have hundreds of 5 star glowing reviews. When I do research nowadays I have to deliberately select the 1 star reviews to see if there is a real issue that's glossed over by the paid reviews.
- xfitm3 8y agoI always search for negative information first. When using a search engine for a product I always append "sucks", "broken", etc. Generally speaking three star reviews are the most informative to me.
- smt88 8y agoSellers know people do this and plant fake, negative reviews on competitors at the same time they give themselves good reviews. I noticed this once when repurchasing a space heater I'd bought multiple times in the past. Several reviews mentioned the temperature sensor failing, but this particular heater had no temperature sensor. That isn't the only product I've seen with suspicious bad reviews, and I've read pieces of investigative journalism that confirm it's fairly widespread.
- Rapzid 8y ago"Sucks" is one of the true casualties of today's PC climate. Used to be you could get all sorts of great opposing opinions with that search keyword, particularly in IT. Sure, it's around here in there. But back in the day if you were going to write about why you didn't like something, you were going to write an article about why it "sucks".
- xfitm3 8y agoThat sucks.
- president 8y agoEven the 1 star negative reviews are faked. Sellers pay users to leave negative reviews to competitors. EDIT: Funny how completely broken and anti-customer the Amazon review system is given that the #1 leadership principle at Amazon [1] is the following: "Customer Obsession - Leaders start with the customer and work backwards. They work vigorously to earn and keep customer trust. Although leaders pay attention to competitors, they obsess over customers." Just goes to show how these things are always BS. [1] https://www.aboutamazon.com/working-at-amazon/our-leadership-principles https://www.aboutamazon.com/working-at-amazon/our-leadership...
- mc32 8y agoCrowdsourced reviews are problematic (often but not always lacking context). Paid reviews make them worthless. Perhaps this is one use of a blockchain which could add credibility to reviews. Still by and large I prefer independent professional reviews (combined with authentic crowdsourced reviews), the problem with these, like CR, is that they’re not scalable to thousands of new products periodically, so we have to rely on crowdsourced reviews that don’t include a “trustworthiness” quotient.
- samat 8y agoHow on earth would blockchain help?
- mc32 8y agoTying buyer to review, although not perfect, in that you could still have a confederate problem, it would help.
- nomel 8y agoThis is defeated by simply giving people amazon gift cards to purchase the product to submit the review. I've seen many reviews state that this is already happening: a review in exchange for the product.
- baroffoos 8y agoDidn't you hear? Blockchains solve every issue in the world. You just put your stuff on the blockchain and it all works.
- dontbenebby 8y ago>Perhaps this is one use of a blockchain which could add credibility to reviews. Amazon offers the option to only view reviews from confirmed purchasers. The problem is that people often receive free products in exchange for the review. "The blockchain" would show that the buyer sent BTC to the seller, but it does nothing to address the fact the seller can put more things into a box and ship them after the review is posted.
- elektor 8y agoLast year I bought a set of cheap Bluetooth headphones on Amazon which I use on a daily basis. It's obvious they have an affiliate program because I often seem on those daily deal roundup posts that a lot of tech blogs now have. Recently, I've been getting emails from the vendors asking me to leave a review in return for a free product. Here is a copy and paste of one: Dear Customer, Thank you for purchasing our (HEADPHONES). Are you satisfied with the Bluetooth headphones that you bought? If there is any question or concern regarding product quality, please don't hesitate to contact us first. If your (BRAND) experience has been everything you hoped it would be, share it with the world! Meanwhile, to express our sincere thanks for your kind support, we are more than happy to send you a (FREE PRODUCT) for free if you are willing to leave us a review since this would be very helpful for other customers who are also interested in this product. If you are interested in a (FREE PRODUCT), please get back to us with the screenshot of your review. Note: you can click the link below directly to leave your positive review: (LINK TO AMAZON TO LEAVE REVIEW) Please rest assured that we’ll arrange (FREE PRODUCT) to you ASAP after we receive the screenshot of your review together with your shipping address. Any questions, please kindly let us know. Have a nice day!
- dontbenebby 8y ago>If you are interested in a (FREE PRODUCT), please get back to us with the screenshot of your review. >Note: you can click the link below directly to leave your positive review: (LINK TO AMAZON TO LEAVE REVIEW) >Please rest assured that we’ll arrange (FREE PRODUCT) to you ASAP after we receive the screenshot of your review together with your shipping address. It'd be interesting to see what they do if you left a neutral review. (Eg: "Three stars. Cheap build quality but decent for the price I guess"). I suspect they're trying to maintain the illusion they're not paying for positive reviews, just for reviews. If they're dumb enough to reply back over email that only positive reviews qualify, you could probably forward that to a regulator.
- uodtl 8y agoCan't you edit the review or just take it back once you've received (FREE PRODUCT)?
- femto113 8y agoTitle would be more descriptive if "Indie Retail Website" was replaced with "Amazon.com". What I find most notable here is that the FTC's settlement is with the manufacturer/seller, and doesn't seem to affect the company that wrote the reviews (amazonverifiedreviews.com).
- dylan604 8y agoI think they should be forced to list the number of items returned right next to the number of reviews.
- omouse 8y agoFINALLY. "In addition, the order requires the defendants to notify Amazon, Inc. that they purchased Amazon reviews of their Quality Encapsulations Garcinia Cambogia capsules and to identify to Amazon the purchased reviews." Online reviews don't work without trust. Maintaining trust is done by Amazon in this case, but sometimes the job is too big, especially at this scale. Amazon needs better tools perhaps, but the judgement of a court, backed up by a state? Damn, that is a powerful way to ensure there is some minimum level of trust in the marketplace. I'm against too much government interference in the marketplace, but it's in everyone's interest to increase trust in the marketplace rather than let it become a market for lemons.
- Theodores 8y agoThe thing is that trust with Amazon is just not about the product reviews. I have been genuinely amazed by Amazon service, delivery and choice but those days are over. Years ago some right on woman ticked me off for recommending her a book that you could just get on Amazon. At the time I thought her attitude was a bit extreme - essentially she was already of the boycott Amazon persuasion. At the time I could not care less for bookshops, that battle had been lost and Amazon gave choice, delivery and price that couldn't be argued with. Years later I have almost came to this woman's conclusion. What has changed? There are lots of small trust things. It seems that Amazon will gladly tender and take on the most odious work for the spy agencies that the rest of Silicon Valley would not touch with a bargepole. It doesn't appear that Amazon want to pay any taxes, which is all very clever but I would prefer to see a society where businesses pay taxes and individuals don't. But, despite these problems, I will still want Amazon stuff. Now if the reviews are not trustworthy and I can't trust them to have the best prices then that is it really, I stop being a customer of Amazon and, a decade after crazy woman scorned me for buying from Amazon, I become of the opinion that she was right all along with all her talk of 'illegal monopoly' and 'tax avoidance'. Trust is a fragile belief-y thing and when it has gone it has gone.
- kanox 8y ago> FINALLY Identities in comment sections have always been fake and anonymous and this is a good thing even if it results in occasional spam reviews. Legal action to enforce real IDs would make the internet worse. I don't get it. I'd expect highly technical forums to value anonymity despite its drawbacks but I'm continuously disappointed.
- nimish 8y agoThe wrong actor is being targeted here: Amazon is just as culpable for encouraging bad behavior.
- gscott 8y agoAmazon has their own "Vine" program to do the same thing.
- thatoneuser 8y agoWorst part is this creates a rift in the market where vendors are not incentivized to produce quality products, but rather to manipulate and game. Who could have possibly thought that A single entity handling so much of the nation's purchasing would end up with terrible oversight in quality?
- president 8y agoThat's what "business" is now. People already have everything they could possibly need - food, shelter, and basic necessities. "Business" is now a game of tricking people into wanting things they don't need and trampling over each other for profits.
- i_am_nomad 8y agoSeems like there’s a huge business opportunity for trusted, independent review websites. Or for a company that certifies such websites as trusted.
- Gpetrium 8y agoUntil the trusted, independent review websites are paid to let some things slide. It is a very difficult environment to maintain.
- appsonify 8y agoThere's an obvious problem with the way we are trying to gauge with a 5 star rating system from the Middle Ages. But what would you use instead?
- Gpetrium 8y agoThis is an interesting case since it has the potential to impact other larger entities such as Amazon (Goods), Google (Apps), Apple (Apps). The issue with fake paid reviews is extremely difficult to gauge and act upon. On one end, the owner of the marketplace doesn't want their place to be seeing as 'full of fakes' on the other end, they don't want to be seeing as censoring legit feedback. How do you know who is who? The second you figure that out, the 'bad actors' will find different, innovative ways to break your system. On another side, because review has become a huge part of the decision people take, new entrants are finding it harder to get a piece of the market (even if they are legit) without paying someone to provide reviews. Finding the right balance in this area will be a continuous effort on all sides, we will likely need better independent customer review sites, the marketplaces will need to find better ways to gauge what is real and what is not, the customers will need to be proactive and check information from different angles, businesses will need to find new ways to prove their legitimacy to get the trust of clients.
- lightedman 8y agoFTC: We are too lazy to go after the most egregious abuser - Amazon - so we're going to go after some indie site. For once, I wish the Gov't would actually nail the big fish, instead of playing hook, line, and sinker with the smaller fish.
- manav 8y agoI was worried for a moment since the company, "Cure Encapsulations" sounds familiar to the product line I frequently buy "Pure Encapsulations", luckily they are not the same. What's interesting is that they only seem to have one product on Amazon: https://amzn.to/2Ef2XH9 https://amzn.to/2Ef2XH9, for which they are Amazon's top choice for the category. I wouldn't be surprised if one of their competitors made the complaint to the FCC.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Razengan 8y agoCan such problems ever really be solved without associating every online account with a person's identity (at least internally) and enforcing one account per person per social platform?
- gibyan 8y agoIf you have lost money trading binary options don’t feel bad, Contact hackwhitewizard@yahoo.com , they just helped me recover my funds $89,000 from iq options the whole process was smooth and after what these brokers had done to me this guys were really true to their word, very happy to share this with everybody that lost to binary options