6 ms·
I don't quite understand the fascination of the HN crowd with intermittent fasting. To me it looks like just another "fad" diet: grand claims, a handful of flaw
by andrepd 8y ago
I don't quite understand the fascination of the HN crowd with intermittent fasting. To me it looks like just another "fad" diet: grand claims, a handful of flawed or limited studies, establishing possible benefits, touted as proof the whole thing is rock-solid.
My feeling is it gives off a certain "body hacking" vibe that HNers are attracted to.
- retzkek 8y ago> I don't quite understand the fascination of the HN crowd with intermittent fasting. Well, have you tried it? Unlike many fad diets there's nothing to buy, no long-term commitment, just one or a few days where you don't eat. You can do some reading to find tricks to make it easier, but all it really takes is willpower. Maybe it will do something for you, maybe not. > a handful of flawed or limited studies As much as we worship high quality, large-population, peer-reviewed studies, ultimately the only study that matters is the n=1, yourself - only you can find out what works for you.
- concernedctzn 8y ago>As much as we worship high quality, large-population, peer-reviewed studies, ultimately the only study that matters is the n=1, yourself - only you can find out what works for you. I understand what you're trying to say but found it funny you tried to conflate real vetted science with "worship" and then said to throw all that out in favor of a personal opinion.
- retzkek 8y agoPerhaps that was an overly antagonistic choice of words, but when you consider the way such studies are analyzed, summarized, and reconstituted for consumption by the public, all nuance is lost and all that's left is a generic guideline that may have little or no relevance for any given person.
- jerf 8y agoWhat "works for you" doesn't have to be "personal opinion". You can freely conduct scientific experiments on yourself. Analysis of such experiments is even abnormally easy, because you can ignore issues of drawing from a "sample" population in favor of analysis techniques that are based on the fact that you're taking data from 100% of the population of interest. (You may still be "sampling" data, depending on what you're measuring, but you've still only got one dimension of sampling instead of two then, which is still easier to deal with.) You just aren't allowed to take the n=1 experiment you just ran and claim it applies to everybody equally. But if you want to know what works for you, and do not particularly care to publish a scientific paper, you can do experiments freely, and the results are as valid as your experimental methodology and the resulting statistical power justify. You are also further entitled at that point to trust your n=1 experiment for yourself over any future n=50 experiment in the future, because it doesn't matter whether 35 of 50 people slept better when taking Vitamin C before bed or whatever; what you personally care about is whether you do, and no amount of reading that paper will tell you whether you're going to be in the 35 or the 15. I've had to experiment on myself like crazy for various reasons. My results are (most likely) utterly inapplicable to you. And I don't care very much about that. You can do your own experiments on you. In the meantime, while I don't know exactly what the parallel universe looks like in which I didn't do these experiments, I am very confident (95%+) parallel Jerf is in pretty bad shape and almost certainly on some rather powerful and nasty meds that he does not in fact need to be on that are actually making things worse in the long term. My experiments have been informed by various papers related to my condition, so it's not like that science is useless; far from it! But, again, no amount of reading papers about Celiac disease and how taking more Taurine helped 80% of people's hearts work better will tell me whether I'm in the 80% or the 20%.
- pstuart 8y agoI'm curious about your thoughts on Taurine (which I'm currently supplementing for eye health).
- jerf 8y agoIt had an immediate and significant positive effect on my heart, which at ~38 years old was starting to seriously misbehave. (Most likely paroxysmal atrial fibrillation, although after wearing a heart monitor for two weeks the doctors declined to diagnose. At this point my heart was misbehaving badly enough that I straight-up was not getting any quality sleep, just to give you an idea of how thump-ety-thump we're talking here.) Re my comment about science still being useful, there are certainly papers about taurine supplementation being useful for people suffering from atrial fibrellation. IIRC, I did not find any references on that for Celiac specifically, but since Celiac is basically "generalized failure to properly absorb nutrients" it's not much of a leap to assume it's related. For heart purposes, it should be matched with 1/2-1/3rd (from the looks of it; it's about as well tested as most dosages, which if you dig into them, are often a lot more guess-and-check than you might like) as much L-Arginine by mass, i.e., I take about 3g Taurine and 1g L-Arginine about three times a day. (I'm a big guy, but the papers often tested twice that, too, so it shouldn't be a dosage issue.) It was ultimately only a part of the nutrient cocktail I ultimately ended up needing, but it was/is a very important part of it. On those occasions I run out of it, I can tell less than 24 hours later. There are worse things than Celiac; at least I can supplement my way out of the worst aspects of it, and that's not a thing you can say about all chronic conditions. But it still sorta blows; I'm constantly playing nutrient catch-up with my body.
- tomp 8y agoA population study is not "real vetted science".
- mb_72 8y ago"... only you can find out what works for you." How do you know one specific thing worked, and it wasn't something else? Or just mere coincidence? As someone who has Crohn's disease I have lost track of the times someone has said "oh, blah worked for this person" etc etc.... all anecdotes, with no way of deciding whether there are side-effects that need to be weighed-up. No thanks.
- NeutronStar 8y agoMaybe read the study then decide if science is real or not?
- hombre_fatal 8y agoWhat's the alternative? Inaction until science figures out the human body? At the end of the day, it's just you doing what works for you. When you do find something that works for you, it's just another anecdote that won't work for everyone else, but it's hard to argue with what makes you happier. Also, it's not like eating less is exotic or risky. It's one of the many things I'd try if I was suffering.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoHow do you know one specific thing worked, and it wasn't something else? Keep a journal. Try to have an established routine, then try one and only one new thing at a time. Do a lot of reading to try to develop a mental model to fit it into.
- andrepd 8y ago>Do a lot of reading to try to develop a mental model to fit it into. I have absolutely no idea what you mean by this.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoThere is a huge amount of info out there these days. Patients often know more about their own condition than most doctors they will meet. If you have never fasted before, you need to read up on fasting. If you want to make dietary changes, you read up on lots of dietary stuff. Etc. If you have a specific diagnosis, you can read up on the latest research into that, plus related stuff. For example, I read stuff about genetics and the gut biome because that helps me put things into context. You do a thing and something happens. You note it and try to figure out what the process is. Was it random? Was it coincidence? Was it causative? If so, how? You build from there.
- gnulinux 8y ago> ultimately the only study that matters is the n=1, yourself Isn't this flawed reasoning? You can try a diet, feel good but still be unhealthy in a way that will kill you earlier that your life expectancy.
- SketchySeaBeast 8y agoIn fact, you'd probably feel better longer on a pure hamburger diet than on a pure fasting diet.
- retzkek 8y agoThat's a risk of any course of action (or inaction) a person undertakes. Following your doctors or the government's guidance is no different, just shifting responsibility, and comes with its own risks (e.g. read The Big Fat Surprise). Pragmatically speaking, would you prefer a shorter life where you feel great, or a longer one where you just feel "OK"? What if we're talking one month? One year?
- afiori 8y agoOnly if you use flawed metrics. If you use the same metrics for health and the same methodology of a reasonable scientific paper then you get a purely better result. the gotcha is that it is useless for everyone but you. A problem would be if you do too many experiments too often, but this you also need to control in n=50. There is a huge difference between subjectivity and n=1
- andrepd 8y agoHow would you measure the effect of a diet on your lifespan?
- afiori 8y agoDiet researches do not measure lifespans of participants. Those who do are rare, as they would need to last at least a few decades. IIRC to publish actual research on diet effect on lifespan you need 80 years. What you do is develop metrics useful to predict lifespan and quality of life and then see the impact of a diet of those metrics. There is nothing you cannot do privately here (using some laboratory for analysis obviously) I am not saying it is easy and for sure it is error prone, but so is science itself.
- andrepd 8y agoI get where you're coming for (you want to draw conclusions for yourself, not for a whole population), but I don't think that is as you paint it. You are not a good observer of yourself. You have biases and subjectivity when "measuring" yourself, so that makes your own "measurements" of yourself unreliable. Furthermore, there are certain observations you cannot even make. For obvious reasons, you cannot even do something so simple as estimating the effect on life expectancy :).
- retzkek 8y ago> You have biases and subjectivity when "measuring" yourself As do the nurse who draws your blood, the tech who tests it, and the doctor who interprets the results. By all means recruit them to assist in your study, but don't do it in blind faith. > that makes your own "measurements" of yourself unreliable Perhaps in some ways and for some metrics, but conversely you are the best at knowing where you experience pain, how you "feel," and how today differs from yesterday. > you cannot even do something so simple as estimating the effect on life expectancy :) Well, no more than anyone else can :)
- smilliken 8y agoIt's difficult to sift through all the bad information about nutrition. It's too important to our health to give up, though. The variance between a good day and a bad day, based on diet, is difficult to overstate (not to mention long-term benefits/risks). I've had luck reading primary research and doing my own self-experiments. For what it's worth, fasting gives me substantially more energy and clarity of mind. Maybe it does for you too? Or maybe not. Probably worth the experiment.
- Spearchucker 8y ago"It's difficult to sift through all the bad information about nutrition." True. I tried, got spectacularly confused and gave up. So now I just eat lots of fruit, vegetables and some meat. I don't eat candy, crisps, fat food of any sort, and nothing processed. No alcohol. I eat when I'm hungry, and I drink when I'm thirsty (couple coffees in the morning, then only water). Nobody has been able to convince me there's a better way to eat and drink.
- magduf 8y agoThat sounds a lot like the Mediterranean Diet, which most nutritionists seem to agree is healthy. The main exception is the alcohol bit.
- alanfranz 8y agoActually, we don't drink that much in Italy and other mediterranean countries. Maybe half a glass of wine, while dining. No binge drinking. I think the drinking patterns do matter.
- magduf 8y agoYeah, that's what I figured, but the OP said specifically that he doesn't drink alcohol at all.
- chimpburger 8y agoEat what our ancestors ate. Meat, potatoes, vegetables, fruit, dairy, in reasonable proportions. Ignore all modern artificial junk food (that includes unnatural omega-6 industrialized vegetable oils - soy, rapeseed, etc). Ignore all the dietary advice of the past 100 years. Much of it is corrupt, funded by industry. It was recently discovered that the anti-saturated-fat nonsense was from studies funded by the sugar industry in the 60s.
- loceng 8y agoHere are a few good videos to watch: Dr. Jason Fung - 'Therapeutic Fasting - Solving the Two-Compartment Problem' - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tIuj-oMN-Fk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tIuj-oMN-Fk Dr. Georgia Ede - 'Our Descent into Madness: Modern Diets and the Global Mental Health Crisis' - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TXlVfwJ6RQU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TXlVfwJ6RQU
- andrepd 8y agoAre those videos peer-reviewed?
- randlet 8y agoFor me IF is just a very effective means of caloric restriction with little downside (I would hesitate to call it a diet, it's just the way I eat). Skipping breakfast means I eliminate ~500 calories from my daily intake which allows me to maintain my weight much easier than if I start eating when I wake up. I don't get hungry before 11am now and I usually eat my first meal at 11:30 am and my last meal at 6pm. I do drink black coffee and water in the mornings though of course. The only downside is sometimes I experience envy watching my kids plowing back oatmeal and bagels in the morning :)
- rsync 8y ago" don't quite understand the fascination of the HN crowd with intermittent fasting." I do hope that you will try it. It costs nothing, takes a negative amount of time since you gain at least a meal of free time out of it, and further, many people (like myself) find that it enhances athletic output. I have never been on a "diet" in my life and have no affinity toward them (or that line of thinking at all). You'll note that "diets" all focus on new and interesting things to eat ... fasting is the opposite of that (IMO, flawed) line of thinking.
- Novashi 8y agoIF is better because unlike fad diets, you aren't actually buying anything new, and the discipline to do the fasting (IMO) helps avoid overeating or unhealthy choices by default. It is removing something whereas most of the other diets simply want to replace something.
- chimpburger 8y agoIt's not a fad. It has been practiced for thousands of years in religious contexts and was a natural part of life before it was done intentionally. If you think this is based on "a handful of flawed or limited studies" then you need to look again. There is an abundance of solid research on the topic https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20534972 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20534972
- Chlorus 8y ago> It has been practiced for thousands of years in religious context A buddy of mine was wondering when flagellation will be touted as a self-improvement technique in Silicon Valley circles, and it looks like that day is coming sooner rather than later.
- chimpburger 8y agoPeople have experienced positive effects from prayer, meditation, and fasting. I don't know if we can add flagellation to the list. Needs more studies.
- AdrianB1 8y agoThere is no need for studies, as it's said people are doing it for thousands of years and also it matters what is good for you, not for others. Just quoting from various responses.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- afiori 8y agoTo give a serious answer: first you would need some prediction about how it could be useful or healthy, then you would have to check whether this prediction is satisfied in animals or in similar cases. Here enters the remark about being commonly predicted in the millennia is weakly relevant as it might suggest that we somehow evolved to accommodate this type of diet (obviously this is not a sound argument in general eg anti-vaxxers), self flagellation does not match this criteria as it was not that common and only for very little time. For example maybe the skin repairing process produce proteins that also lower stress. Then, most important phase, you should check whether it can be dangerous. I would guess that there are 0 scientific papers affirming positive effects of self flagellation.
- tomp 8y agoWhat's your definition of a "fad diet" vs. "non-fad diet"? I'd say all diets are "fad"... They all have grand claims and "proofs" (as soon as there's money in it, everything turns into advertising for a "magic bullet to solve your problems" including diets), and none of them are scientific (even those that have "studies" - most of which are completely false or inconclusive). On the other hand, fasting has been practiced for at least 1000 years (Ramadan) so at least it's not harmful...
- JamesBarney 8y ago> a handful of flawed or limited studies The research on caloric restriction and fasting is wide and deep. I'm curious where you got the impression the research was only a handful of flawed or limited studies?
- andrepd 8y agoPlease, a reference.
- JamesBarney 8y ago"intermittent fasting" 413 studies https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/?term=%22intermittent+fasting%22 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/?term=%22intermittent+fa... "caloric restriction" 8089 studies https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/?term=%22caloric+restriction%22 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/?term=%22caloric+restric... fast mimicking diet 80 studies https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/?term=fasting+mimicking+diet https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/?term=fasting+mimicking+...
- itchyouch 8y agoThere's health benefits and potential longevity benefits. I would hardly call fasting a fad. It has been around through the ages. Here's some legitimate information on a fast. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d6PyyatqJSE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d6PyyatqJSE We know enough about some of the mechanisms involved and how it can promote healing the body by offering it a "reset" so-to-speak via autophagy.
- andrepd 8y agoAgain, please, can you refer me to a peer-reviewed paper, not to a fitness youtube channel? -.-
- everdrive 8y agoI think the obsession has to do with how prone the HN crowd is to being a bit OCD. Fasting is all about asceticism, and controlling your impulses. This is why it appeals to me, anyhow. Maybe the rest of HN feels differently?
- peterwwillis 8y agoYou must not have been here a few years ago when lifting and workout regimens were the talk of the town. Other communities have similar irrational obsessions.
- sgift 8y ago> a handful of flawed or limited studies Compared to the studies which have been done to support the current eating guidelines the studies on fasting have been wide and deep. Most current eating guidelines are based on a mix of "we though it sounds good", "everyone knows that fat is bad", "my friend from coca-cola told me that and he knows things" or "someone paid me to do the study and made it pretty clear that my future funding depends on the results".