3 ms·
Definitely rings true. I managed to get accepted to one of the “top-ish” business schools a decade or so back, and got to witness first-hand these non-obvious r
by ryandrake 8y ago
Definitely rings true. I managed to get accepted to one of the “top-ish” business schools a decade or so back, and got to witness first-hand these non-obvious rules and norms and these invisible barriers. There’s an obvious class chasm. You’ve got the bros (and yes they were mostly men in a narrow age band) who were already investment bankers and management consultants, going back to finishing school to “get their tickets punched”. And then there was everyone else: international students trying to get a foothold in American business, non-traditional, entrepreneurial types, and working-class schmucks like myself trying to change careers into something more lucrative.
The ‘bros all seemed to know each other already, and knew all these hidden rules, norms, and behaviors. They had similar interests and hobbies. Liked similar overseas vacationing spots. Did their wine tasting together. Went to the same polo and yachting clubs. They spoke the language of privilege and class fluently. They even dressed pretty much the same. Their elite backgrounds have them an enormous and obvious advantage.
When it came time to do the grueling company meet-and-greets and interview gauntlet, these guys were the only ones not sweating it. They already by and large had their elite jobs lined up by virtue of this hidden network. The rest of us did 25 interviews a week fighting over the scraps.
Never managed to do a career change, but still found the experience to be valuable. It changed a lot of my attitudes and beliefs about class mobility, how much of the world actually runs on these secret rules and understandings, and the differences between certain and uncertain paths to economic/career success. I feel the author of this article really gets it.
- wtvanhest 8y agoI didn't do IB, but I did work at BlackRock in strategy post MBA with a lot of IBers. The thing about IB is that it is super focused on getting deals done which inherently creates a lower stress level when looking for jobs or other transactional type work [1]. While most are from really solid backgrounds, many are not. The salaries give all IBers the ability to do things that most normal 22-25 year olds can't because the salaries are so big. [1] My experience in business school was interesting because I didn't have a well known brand on my resume, or network outside of a niche industry I wanted to leave, but I did have transnational experience which made me super confident. While my colleagues were trying to optimize grades or prep for interviews by learning every detail about the company, I was working on talking points. When I went to an interview I was stress fee because (even though it was 2009), I was confident that I would have multiple offers. There are class divides, and there are divides based on experience.
- asdffdsa 8y agoNot really sure what your point is, besides drawing attention to your impressive confidence and singular success
- wtvanhest 8y ago"There are class divides, and there are divides based on experience." The OP is describing what sounds like a divide on experience, not class. I use my personal example and understanding of the process to highlight why I believe his feelings on the process may be a little off.
- rbanffy 8y agoNever underestimate the value of a good network. A lot of opportunities will show up outside a work environment first, as a passing comment or an invitation for coffee or dinner. This is a segment where first mover advantage is very significant. Lower level jobs can be more objectively assigned because you have a much higher number of matches and mismatches to draw conclusions from. The higher up you go, the more subjective factors play a role. There has been a lot of progress in measuring ability at the top tiers, but relatively few companies hire professional psychometric assessment.
- watwut 8y agoThere is subjective evaluation as a necessary reality and there is flat out nepotism. The line may be fuzzy at times, but the above sounds like the latter with no doubt.