3 ms·
Unless the teachers are going to be individually contracted by parents, don't private-sector schools have the same evaluation problem? They still have to separa
by _delirium 16y ago
Unless the teachers are going to be individually contracted by parents, don't private-sector schools have the same evaluation problem? They still have to separate good and bad teachers via some sort of process, probably overseen by management (aka bureaucracy). The similarity of the agency problems is one reason corporations internally often look so much like governments.
- enjo 16y agoAnd fundamentally why the idea that private enterprise is always more efficient is a fundamentally flawed premise.
- WalterBright 16y agoTo some extent, sure, the larger the organization is the more bureaucratic and inefficient it gets at about everything. But there's still one fundamental difference - with public schools, one is forced to attend (truancy laws) and forced to pay for it.
- tptacek 16y agoPrivate schools can fire teachers subjectively. A good private school principal can use gut feel to evaluate a teacher. But that doesn't scale, unless we find a way to identify and recruit very smart, very trustworthy principals on a large scale.
- gruseom 16y agoIt's not obvious we'd be worse off if we just made public schools be like private schools in this respect. (That's a Jerry Weinberg use of the j-word, "just". It would be a lot of trouble to do.)
- hdctambien 16y agoI remember reading an article (linked from HN I believe) that was a response to the "Waiting for Superman" movie which cited numbers showing that private schools didn't perform any better than public schools. That would suggest that either the ability to fire teachers subjectively doesn't have an impact on student performance, or that private schools don't fire enough teachers or the metrics the private schools use to fire teachers are not in line with what would improve student achievement.
- nerfhammer 16y agoPeople are emotionally averse to firing others they may have been working with for years, and there's not a good enough reason to fire someone in a private organization unless they affect the bottom line, and outside of exceptional cases I don't see how the bottom line changes much based on individual teachers. You're probably not going to quit private school based on any one single teacher. You need a strong economic incentive for the organization in order for the "fire more easily" idea to work. For instance, if a private school got paid according to the competitiveness of the college the student is accepted into.