3 ms·
> Why is this a big deal? It matters because algorithmic justice, of a complex or simple variety, has come in for a lot of flack in the US, in part because of o
by jrochkind1 8y ago
> Why is this a big deal? It matters because algorithmic justice, of a complex or simple variety, has come in for a lot of flack in the US, in part because of one truly major mess that was caused by the COMPAS system. So, it’s great to see algorithmic justice doing good.
That's because these don't seem like the same things at all to me. Lumping them both under "algorithmic justice" with an agenda to make the one look better doesn't change that. This thing in this story involves zero machine-learning, zero statistics at all, zero attempts at statistical prediction of likelyhoods of anything, or even any heuristics at all. Those are all the things that have come for a lot of flack. Looking things up in databases and using them to automatically fill out forms, indeed, has not come under a "lot of flack."
- lallysingh 8y agoThe public doesn't care about those distinctions. So it's useful to cancel out a negative gut-reaction to encourage a more nuanced view.
- rayiner 8y agoThis isn’t algorithmic justice, just regular automation. So it’s dishonest to suggest it should cancel out the problems that have been created by algorithmic justice.
- chrismeller 8y agoAgreed. > select * from judgements where description like ‘%marijuana%’ Is one of the least impressive IT feats ever.
- amenod 8y agoI strongly disagree. A trivial SQL statement that saves thousands of people lots of hassle is a very impressive IT feat in my eyes.
- jrochkind1 8y agofair!
- pizza 8y agotrees for the forest
- bilbo0s 8y agoI don't know man? Just Devil's Advocate here, but it I think if Trump did that, and then tried to say he was just trying to encourage a "nuanced" view, we'd all yell, "See! Politicians are always lying!"
- hnaccy 8y agoThat seems manipulative.
- jrochkind1 8y agoYou think the public is going to be opposed to _this_ sort of thing, because of what they've heard about the _actual_ statistical algorithmic things? I seriously doubt it. I think the author was trying to do exactly the reverse, get people to _support_ the statistical algorithmic things because of this thing, which seems obviously a good idea. It seems like (exagerrated of course) saying "Yeah, I know you don't like autonomous military robots killing people, but you like YOUR TOASTER, right? It also works on electric power, and turns itself off unattended when your toast is done. Maybe there's a role for Autonomous Killing Robots after all, they might even be able to toast your bread with their lasers!" Most of the public has never even heard the term "algorithmic justice", of course. You're saying "the public doesn't care about those distinctions," but it's the OP author _suggesting_ we include software providing _decision-making_ based on statistical algorithms, along with simple rule-based automation, both under "algorithmic justice", _rather_ than making a distinction. The OP author encouraging us not to make distinctions. I think the public is smart enough to distinguish between software that is _making decisions_ and software that isn't, and it's the OP that is asking this distinction not be made. As the public is indeed just starting to learn how to think about and categorize these things, I think it's irresponsible to try to educate them _not_ to make distinctions, and I think it's being done for an agenda.
- dak1 8y agoYes, they really will. If you oppose this initiative, you start running ads: "Your legislator wants to let a computer overrule judges and juries and put criminals back on the streets. Call your legislator now to tell them you oppose HB-555." There's enough truth there, that explaining it away takes far too much effort, and in politics, if you're explaining, you're losing. If you don't think this is how this kind of thing works, you haven't been paying attention.
- yarrel 8y agoIt might be, but using the benefits of a very different thing to launder the reputation of something that people have very legitimate concerns about isn't nuance - it's dishonesty.
- crb002 8y agoThis issue is transparency. Iowa's "algorithmic" bail program has zero transparency. They have even violated Iowa's public records law and refused to let me inspect the software.