5 ms·
This is akin to bypassing antimalware protection by hosting the malware on your own reputable site. What are you trying to achieve here? Your entire domain wil
by Nextgrid 8y ago
This is akin to bypassing antimalware protection by hosting the malware on your own reputable site.
What are you trying to achieve here? Your entire domain will just end up blocked if you do this at scale, not to mention Google themselves would ban your reverse proxy’s IP because of too many queries (since you’ll be proxying all your visitors’ requests from a single IP).
- chrischen 8y agoIf you're doing this "at scale" then people would notice if your domain got blocked.
- Nextgrid 8y agoAssuming your domain is anything of value of course. There are plenty of domains that are technically at scale and yet when my ad blocker blocks a link to it I just go back to the previous page and don’t bother clicking through.
- StefanoC 8y agoIf you were to reverse proxy from the same domain then yes, you'd get blocked eventually. The problem is that creating reverse proxies on random domains is too easy, by distributing this to different domains it wouldn't be possible to block this effectively!
- Nextgrid 8y agoIt would turn into a standard game of cat & mouse just like with signature-based anti malware software. Eventually the world will move on to heuristics and domain-based workarounds will no longer be effective.
- taneq 8y agoTo be fair, self-hosted ads are a thing on some sites and often don't get blocked by adblockers. I know I don't specifically go out of my way to block such ads because they're generally on sites that I'd like to support.
- Nextgrid 8y agoDo these self-hosted ads also embed malware (stalking/tracking code)? If they do not then I'm 100% with you and would totally support this kind of self-hosted advertising. However this example is a bit different, the site in question is going out of their way to being a reverse-proxy for a spyware command & control server, and the entire domain should be considered & blocked as such.
- taneq 8y agoIf we're just talking about tracking then they don't need to because the site already gets all of your requests. They inherently know what pages you're viewing on their site because they gave them to you. A great many sites run this kind of analytics (often including client-side ones to track user actions - think medium.com's "most highlighted paragraph) and it's not considered malware. If you're talking about them selling the data gathered by these, then that'd be less common but certainly not unheard of. If you're talking about them doing something more nefarious on your machine (keylogging/cracking) then hopefully that's pretty hard to do against a modern browser and any site caught doing so would never get any traffic from me again.
- Nextgrid 8y agoThe problem we're discussing here is not about the site having a record of all the legitimate requests needed to load a page. The problem is that the site is now serving a piece of (third-party, but that's besides the point) malware explicitly designed to monitor events that would normally not cause a network request (and thus wouldn't be logged), and then sending that to a malicious third-party through a reverse-proxy.