3 ms·
> I attribute that at least within the United States to "trickle-down economics Trickle-down economics has never been a policy promoted by any economist (left
by dmix 8y ago
> I attribute that at least within the United States to "trickle-down economics
Trickle-down economics has never been a policy promoted by any economist (left or right) in history nor a policy of the US or any western country. It was originally a political invention. And quite an effective one at that because the media/pundits have used it for decades as a strawman to endlessly attack. Of course it's far easier to win against an adversary who doesn't exist.
> Years ago, this column challenged anybody to quote any economist outside of an insane asylum who had ever advocated this “trickle-down” theory. Some readers said that somebody said that somebody else had advocated a “trickle-down” policy. But they could never name that somebody else and quote them.
> It is not just in politics that the nonexistent “trickle-down” theory is found. It has been attacked in the New York Times, in the Washington Post, and by professors at prestigious American universities — and even as far away as India. Yet none of those who denounce a “trickle-down” theory can quote anybody who actually advocated it.
https://www.nationalreview.com/2014/01/trickle-down-lie-thomas-sowell/ https://www.nationalreview.com/2014/01/trickle-down-lie-thom...
Sowell's longer treatise on it goes into it in greater detail exploding this myth:
http://media.hoover.org/sites/default/files/documents/Sowell_TrickleDown_FINAL.pdf http://media.hoover.org/sites/default/files/documents/Sowell...
>> We fight for and against not men and things as they are, but for and against the caricatures we make of them.
- J.A. Schumpeter
- arcticbull 8y agoI actually read the entirety of the longer treatise you posted before following up now. I think it's important to consider that Reagan's budget director, David Stockman, was quoted in the Atlantic as saying "It's kind of hard to sell 'trickle down,' so the supply-side formula was the only way to get a tax policy that was really 'trickle down.' Supply-side is 'trickle-down' theory." IMO the goal of taxation as a system is not just to maximize tax revenue -- although that's an important component -- and lowering marginal rates may do that. It's also about ensuring fairness and mitigating some amount of wealth inequality. Just because a tax policy increases revenues by lowering marginal rates doesn't mean that "trickle down/supply-side economics is working" -- compared to, for instance, a wealth tax. The treatise focuses on the A vs. B of lowering vs. not lowering top taxes as the defining factor of trickle-down, but it misses the forest for the trees. Other solutions exist which may yield better outcomes for all. The component I found particularly weak in the treatise was "if we don't lower their tax rate the rich will keep hiding money in tax-free muni bonds" and left it at that, and threw their hand up. Great, tax those. Or all holdings. Then we can pick up where we left off.
- dmix 8y agoI'm not seeking to defend Reagan's policies but I'm curious when did David Stockman said Trickle Down in the Atlantic? Was it their policy during the administration as trickle down is characterized? He is a political pundit who was trying to rebut a (now) common political myth. The fact he parroted it back in an article a decade or two later doesn't mean it was the policy of the executive branch or any economist. Which is entirely the point.
- arcticbull 8y agoBy the way, thank you for posting the article, it was a great write-up and an enjoyable read. I found the Stockman quote in a November 1981 WaPo/Atlantic article [1] which would have been, if I'm not mistaken, in his first year in office as OMB director? Sorry I'm not more familiar with this, I'll have to do some more reading too. [1] https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/opinions/1981/11/22/what-david-stockman-said/8278b9e5-c979-4b91-8001-d82dd2816f06/?utm_term=.4881031c621a https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/opinions/1981/11/22/w...
- dmix 8y agoYou sound like a smart guy and it'd take me pages to properly respond to everything. I try to avoid online political debates because I haven't found much ROI in investing in them. But I'm sure Sowell would be highly critical of the mainstream economic policies of both parties in recent eras. He's far more preferential towards earlier US economics. I will say that there's a big myth that the US has been on some big market-oriented supply-side binge since the 1980s which is a giant myth in itself. The size of western governments, everywhere, has exploded since the 1970s... even if the tax rate hasn't. Sowell would be just as critical of any policy directly benefiting the wealthy as well. He sees the far bigger problem as the countless "well-intentioned policies" intended (or at least sold) to help the poor/middle class that back fire, do nothing, or more often creates highly inefficient systems where only the politically connected get social benefits. I highly recommend his book "Wealth, poverty, and politics" [1]. It'd do a 100x better job than me at explaining his general worldview, which is closest to mine. And it's hardly just lower taxes for upper/middle and keep the rest of the political machine the same (which is probably worst of both worlds IMO). [1] https://www.amazon.com/Wealth-Poverty-Politics-Thomas-Sowell-ebook/dp/B01DWW2F32/ https://www.amazon.com/Wealth-Poverty-Politics-Thomas-Sowell...