3 ms·
Suppose I, operating in the US, rent some physical storage space in Europe from a European storage company, and then ship a box of documents to them and tell th
by tzs 8y ago
Suppose I, operating in the US, rent some physical storage space in Europe from a European storage company, and then ship a box of documents to them and tell them to put them in my rented storage space.
I don't think there is any serious doubt that a US court or US law enforcement with a warrant would be able to order me to contact the storage company and tell them to ship the box back to me.
The European country the storage unit is in would not see this as some attempt at exercising extraterritorial jurisdiction. To them, it is just a routine interaction between me and a service provider I am using in Europe. That my motive for asking for my box back was to satisfy a court order rather than because I actually wanted to use my documents is irrelevant.
(This works both ways. A French court ordering a French company that had stored physical documents to retrieve those documents would not raise issues in the US if the French company was using a US document archiving service to hold them).
I don't see why there should be any difference between my physical documents that I keep in a box in a Paris storage unit, and my electronic documents that I keep on an Amazon server in the Paris AWS region.
- cesarb 8y agoIn your example, the US court is ordering you to request the documents. There's no question that the US court has jurisdiction over you. What about this variation over your example: instead of contacting you, the US court bypasses you and asks directly the European storage company. This is much more questionable, since a US court shouldn't have jurisdiction over an European company.
- DuskStar 8y agoFunnily enough, in the GDPR equivalent (you, a EU resident, hire a company in the US to store a box for you) the EU bypasses you and requires the storage company to have an effective security guard and fire suppression system...
- ionised 8y agoThe difference is that in this case the US considers itself the owner of all data on US and Eu citizens alike. The EU merely says that you cannot store Eu citizens data without the necessary safeguards in place and permissions asked. This is a very different issue in my view. The US has an inflated sense of entitlement, whereas the EU is being protective and inhibiting of data collection on its citizens by foreign organisations.
- logfromblammo 8y agoFurther suppose that I prearrange instructions with the storage company such that they are to ship my documents back to me in the US, only if I ask that they be destroyed, and to ignore any other requests for shipment. Am I guilty of contempt of court if I do exactly as the court orders, knowing that the only way to accomplish the end the court desires is to do something the court has likely already ordered me to not do? The foreign entity could just as easily have instructions to not release the documents until presented with evidence of my death, then release them to my heirs, or respond only to requests from my lawyer that contain the word "cockatiel". The only reliable and reasonable way to handle it, is for the US court to request extradition of the documents from the French authorities, and rely upon them to seize the documents and transmit them with clear chain of custody directly to the US court. If the court is aware the documents exist, and that they lie in a foreign jurisdiction, they have no particular reason to rely upon me for their retrieval. It is dangerous to even try, if I am in any way uncooperative.