3 ms·
What's underspecified is that the commoner doesn't answer randomly. He is either truthful or a liar, so if you add enough "what would you say" qualifiers, you
by tedunangst 16y ago
What's underspecified is that the commoner doesn't answer randomly. He is either truthful or a liar, so if you add enough "what would you say" qualifiers, you can figure it out.
- xenophanes 16y agoActually you don't need many qualifiers, just "Imagine in your head that I ask you if you're suitable to marry. What do you answer in your head?" If you speak to a liar, this gets two lies (negations) out of them. So anyone has to tell the truth.