13 ms·
He thought paying $10B in capital gains taxes was not enough and he should have paid more. I'm always annoyed when rich people say things like this. I had one
by reaperducer 8y ago
He thought paying $10B in capital gains taxes was not enough and he should have paid more.
I'm always annoyed when rich people say things like this. I had one say almost this exact thing to me in an elevator once.
There's nothing stopping him from paying more. He just writes a check to "Department of the Treasury" and sends it off to D.C. Problem solved.
But then he doesn't get to passive-aggressively whine about all of his piles of money that the government won't take from him.
- nicoburns 8y ago> I'm always annoyed when rich people say things like this. I had one say almost this exact thing to me in an elevator once. Why? Surely it's better than the alternative of them not supporting progressive taxation?
- rchaud 8y agoThe alternative in this case would be for Gates to use a part of his resources and influence to maybe advocate for such laws, instead of just talking.
- nicoburns 8y agoThis is a good point, and I totally agree.
- reaperducer 8y agoThe alternative isn't supporting progressive taxation. The alternative is picking up a pen and writing a check.
- fossuser 8y agoThat seems like a straw man to me - they’re saying the tax should be higher for people in their class generally, not that they individually wish to pay more.
- reaperducer 8y agoThen they should say what they mean instead of being, as I mentioned, all passive aggressive about it.
- fossuser 8y agoI don't think they are - I think it's just a misunderstanding of phrasing maybe? I interpret "I should have paid more" as I should be compelled to pay more, not "I wish I could pay more". The distinction being they'd rather not pay additional tax, but they probably should have to. I think the language is just somewhat ambiguous (specifically the word 'should').
- mhb 8y agoIf he thinks that the government can better allocate the collective amount of additional tax it could obtain from people in similar tax situations, why wouldn't he think the same about just his portion? Either he has a much higher opinion of his personal judgement in allocating his money (which is likely) than other people who he also thinks should be paying more tax or he should turn over the BMGF to the government.
- tempestn 8y agoI expect that it's not so much a higher opinion of his personal judgement as a higher opinion of his values and priorities. Obviously he feels their foundation is spending money on the most important things it can be; however I expect he also feels that the government will, on average, spend it on more important things than it would be used for by most people with similar levels of wealth.
- mhb 8y agoSo pretty much the same way most people think that their driving skills are well above average.
- 8y ago
- Jackim 8y agoI think it's still worth saying. Sure, one can write the cheque. But the problem is most don't have to and won't do it voluntarily.
- doppel 8y agoI am sure if someone really, REALLY wanted to give money to the government it would be possible with some effort. But it is actually fairly difficult to just give money (at least, in quite a few western countries) to the state that it does not ask for - everything has to fit within a system and match a budget, tax reason, invoice, etc., and you can't just have "EXTRA - From Bill Gates" somewhere in there for 10 billion dollars.
- reaperducer 8y agoBut it is actually fairly difficult to just give money (at least, in quite a few western countries) to the state that it does not ask for - everything has to fit within a system and match a budget, tax reason, invoice, etc., and you can't just have "EXTRA - From Bill Gates" somewhere in there for 10 billion dollars. My accountant says otherwise. She was the one who told me all that rich people have to do is break out their checkbooks to put their money where their mouths are.
- kelnos 8y agoIt's actually very easy. See, for example, https://www.treasurydirect.gov/govt/reports/pd/gift/gift.htm https://www.treasurydirect.gov/govt/reports/pd/gift/gift.htm The money is required to go toward paying down public debt, but I'd say that's worthwhile.
- mhb 8y agoSince money is fungible, you can imagine it paying for whatever aspect of government you fancy.
- plushpuffin 8y agoIt doesn't seem that difficult in the US. You just mail a check to a PO Box. https://fiscal.treasury.gov/public/gifts-to-government.html https://fiscal.treasury.gov/public/gifts-to-government.html
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- ezequiel-garzon 8y agoI can understand your feelings, and he is a bit contradictory in the sense that he has stated publicly that governments are not the best enablers for certain projects. He didn't give any examples, but I for one am convinced their foundation did way more with every dollar it invested in Africa than the UN or "the government" would have done with $20. In any event, he'll eventually will walk the walk in terms shedding most of his fortune: https://givingpledge.org/ https://givingpledge.org/
- wglb 8y agoDo you know for a fact that he did not?
- johnmcd3 8y agoThere's a big difference between personally trying to fund the US government (which doesn't scale) and his saying that people in or near his position should have to pay higher taxes. If you doubled the amount of taxes Bill has personally paid over his lifetime, it would amount to a few tenths of a percent of a SINGLE YEAR of US government tax revenue. I suspect Bill is saying that he-- and other very top earners-- should have paid more.
- MrMember 8y agoI always find it a bit disingenuous when someone who has already made tens of billions of dollars on capital gains and wouldn't be affected as much by an increase in the tax calls for it. Would the Bill Gates that had a net worth of $1 million call for increased capital gains taxes?
- creato 8y agoIt's really, really simple, to the point where I suspect that most people that make the argument you are making are being disingenuous. Bill Gates is willing to pay more taxes if other billionaires pay more taxes. If they don't, he isn't. Just like I think my taxes should be higher, but I'm not going to voluntarily pay higher taxes, unless others in my tax bracket also pay them. Even chimpanzees would probably understand and disagree with you [1]. 1. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4451566/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4451566/
- opportune 8y agothe person you're replying to will probably never agree with you because the idea of everybody individually contributing the taxes that they desire to pay to accomplish the means they desire to accomplish is a core part of hardcore libertarianism. It's like trying to argue with an antivaxxer.
- retsibsi 8y ago> Even chimpanzees would probably understand and disagree with you I think it's important to stress the practical side of the argument too, rather than just appealing to intuitions of fairness. Bill Gates probably believes (and is probably correct) that for any sum of money he is willing to part with, he could do more good by directing it toward carefully selected philanthropic causes than by donating it to the government. So when acting alone, there's no reason for him to unilaterally pay extra tax, unless he believes it will have very good indirect effects and/or is just seeking a PR boost. He also believes that if people in his class (including him) paid much more in taxes than they currently do, the world would be a better place than it is now. These two beliefs are entirely consistent, for at least two reasons: * For a lot of people in his class, the likely alternatives are not philanthropy vs. taxes, but non-altruistic spending vs. taxes. * There are, at least arguably, some things that government is better suited to doing than private charities are. Perhaps these tend to be the kind of large-scale projects that could be funded by higher taxes on all super-rich people, rather than anything that would result from a donation to the government by a single billionaire. Even if your opinion of government is very low and you disagree with the second point, the first should be enough to show that his position is perfectly consistent, and would be even for someone unrealistically altruistic and willing to be on the wrong end of an unfair situation.
- onetimemanytime 8y ago>>There's nothing stopping him from paying more. He just writes a check to "Department of the Treasury" and sends it off to D.C. Problem solved. And then some pr*ck in the Senate decides that 3 times as much as Bill Gates paid goes to a pork barrel project to create 25 jobs in his district? The best use of his money? Bill Gates and all with the Bill Gates' mindset should pay the minimum required and invest the rest to better the world privately.
- skywhopper 8y agoThis is silly. Bill Gates thinks his taxes should be higher, because he thinks all people earning money in the way he does should pay higher taxes. If he wrote a check to double his own personal tax payment it wouldn't make a dent in the US budget. But if you doubled the taxes every billionaire pays, it would make a huge dent. So he's saying, his class of wealth should pay more. If it's just him who does it, it doesn't solve the government's problems, and he's better off spending the money himself directly on the things he cares about. But if everyone at his scale paid more, that _would_ help.
- skh 8y agoBut then he doesn't get to passive-aggressively whine about all of his piles of money that the government won't take from him. Suppose you are right that he is being passive agressive. I strongly disagree with this assessment but let’s for the sake of argument agree that he is being passive aggressive. Why is his right to be passive-aggressive diminished? Is he not allowed to be passive-aggressive or hypocritical or any other negative view you have about him? The correctness of his view that people like him ought to be taxed at a higher rate is not dependent upon his character flaws or lack thereof. The belief ought to be judged on its own merits and not analyzed based on whether or not his character passes muster.
- rconti 8y agoI'm sorry, but that's such a non-answer. Of COURSE he could donate more money to the US Government. The point is that he thinks structurally the system should require that he and OTHER people like himself should have to pay more. By changing the structure, they change what people optimize for, and ALSO, at the same time, raise funds. As a philanthropist, I'm sure he personally feels that he's able to direct his money to more useful causes than the government does, just as many rich people who give nothing also make the empty claim that the government would just 'waste' their money. The difference is, in his case, he might well be right. But that still doesn't mean that a structure that taxes him and others like him at a higher rate wouldn't have a net social benefit.
- EpicEng 8y ago>Problem solved If the problem were "if only we had $2B more we could solve so many system problems." Of course, it's not, so no, no problems were solved even hypothetically.
- oarabbus_ 8y agoIt's almost like he wants to fix the system itself rather than simply pay more out of pocket. What an awful way to look at the world.
- vibrato 8y agoYou're talking about a guy whose full time job for the last 10 years and remainder of his working life is spending his fortune for the benefit of mankind
- dang 8y agoCan you please stop posting shallow, indignant comments to HN? I realize that's what the internet is for (or #2 anyway), but it's definitely what we don't want on this site. We've had to ask you repeatedly not to violate the site guidelines with uncivil and/or unsubstantive comments. Continuing to post them will eventually get you banned, and I don't want to ban you, so could you please fix this? https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html