5 ms·
Moore’s law is dead! Also, I think Murphy’s law should be removed, it’s less true than the other laws here. I read a fantastic article many years ago in the A
by dahart 8y ago
Moore’s law is dead!
Also, I think Murphy’s law should be removed, it’s less true than the other laws here.
I read a fantastic article many years ago in the Atlantic where the author was analyzing and deconstructing an airplane crash, and in it was a paragraph about how Murphy’s law is completely backwards, and in reality if things can go right, then they will. Things will almost always go right unless there’s no possible way they can, in other words only the extremely rare alignment of multiple mistakes causes catastrophes. Can’t remember if the author had a name for the alternative Murphy’s law, but I believe it, especially in software. We get away with crappy software and bugs & mistakes all over the place.
- art0rz 8y agoAs I interpret Murphy's Law, it's not so much about failure in actuality, but more about anticipating the failure, and designing your code/product/system for the worst case scenario.
- dspillett 8y ago> it's not so much about failure in actuality Murphy himself was unhappy abut the common interpretation of his law, which is negative rather than cautionary, implying a vindictiveness to exist in inanimate objects and the laws of chance. > but more about anticipating the failure, and designing your code/product/system for the worst case scenario Which was his intent. IIRC the phrase was coined while working on rocket sleds for a land speed record attempt. He was essentially trying to achieve "no matter what happens we want to maximise the chance of the pilot being alive afterwards, if some of the equipment survives too that is even better" and promoting a defensive always-fail-as-safely-as-possible engineering stance.
- dahart 8y ago> Murphy himself was unhappy abut the common interpretation of his law, which is negative rather than cautionary Are you sure about that? Murphy's actual statement was negative and not cautionary. He was criticizing a person, not saying something cautionary about the nature of the universe. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murphy%27s_law#Association_with_Murphy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murphy%27s_law#Association_wit...
- AnimalMuppet 8y agoExactly. You can't say "That won't happen" or "that's unlikely to happen". You have to have a way that handles it so that, even if it does happen, the guy on the sled doesn't die.
- 0_gravitas 8y agoI think people interpret Murphy's law incorrectly most of the time. We can extrapolate from "Anything bad that can, happen will happen", and get the statement: "If something can physically happen, given enough time, it will eventually happen." I like to think its sort of a very tangential sister idea of the mediocrity theory.
- dahart 8y agoI'm not sure I understand what you think is incorrect; your explanation seems to align with the common interpretation. Here's the article I was thinking of. Totally worth the read, aside from discussion of Murphy's Law... https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/1998/03/the-lessons-of-valujet-592/306534/ https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/1998/03/the-les... "Keep in mind that it is also competitive, and that if one of its purposes is to make money, the other is to move the public through thin air cheaply and at high speed. Safety is never first, and it never will be, but for obvious reasons it is a necessary part of the venture. Risk is a part too, but on the everyday level of practical compromises and small decisions—the building blocks of this ambitious enterprise—the view of risk is usually obscured. The people involved do not consciously trade safety for money or convenience, but they inevitably make a lot of bad little choices. They get away with those choices because, as Perrow says, Murphy's Law is wrong—what can go wrong usually goes right. But then one day a few of the bad little choices come together, and circumstances take an airplane down. Who, then, is really to blame?" Of course, regardless of which way you interpret Murphy's law, the law itself and this alternative are both hyperbolic exaggerations. The main question is more of which way of looking at it is more useful. In terms of thinking about safety, it seems like both points of view have something important to say about why paying attention to unlikely events is critical.
- 0_gravitas 8y agoI suppose what I generally mean is that most of the people that I've talked to only consider it within the scope of "what can go wrong", and seem to never consider the more general statement. I'm certainly not claiming to be the first person to think such a way, if that's the impression I gave off. Murphy's law is a favorite of mine because it's the perfect driving board for conversations about infinite probabilities and aliens and simulation stuff.
- scarejunba 8y agoIt’s also in Understanding Human Error by Sidney Dekker when talking about normalization of deviance. Everything that can go right will go right and we’ll use that to justify deviance more and more.