3 ms·
There's a very good reason government isn't agile. "Individuals and interactions over processes and authority", "Empowered civil servants over procedures and b
by philwelch 16y ago
There's a very good reason government isn't agile.
"Individuals and interactions over processes and authority", "Empowered civil servants over procedures and bureaucracies", and "Responding to change over following a plan" are all fantastic descriptions of a dictatorship. Deadlock, bureaucracy, process, jurisdiction, authority, barriers and limits to power are defining characteristics of a limited, constitutional government.
- gordonguthrie 16y agoI agree. This manifesto is a recipe for 'capture' of the state by social or ethnic groups and the creation of corrupt clientistic societies.
- DSpinellis 16y agoStrangely enough, Greece (which I had in mind when I wrote the blog post) has plenty of processes, procedures, bureaucracy, and comprehensive regulations AND also ranks quite low in the Transparency International Corruption Index, in part due to endemic clientilism.
- gruseom 16y agoThat's a pretty ahistorical comment. Dictatorships can be plenty bureaucratic. And bureaucracy has its origins in non-democratic societies.
- philwelch 16y agoHistorically, someone empowered to act outside of the normal bounds and restrictions of the republic was called a "dictator". The word we use today is derived from the actual title the Romans gave someone when they wanted their republic to be what we would describe as "agile". Eventually, that tactic worked against them.
- gruseom 16y agoWhat you're saying strikes me as hopelessly anachronistic. Nothing like "what we would describe as 'agile'" can possibly be retrofitted thousands of years back. The agile movement comes out of a humanistic anti-corporatist agenda (for want of a better way of describing it) that is practically unthinkable before, say, 1950. If not 1970.
- philwelch 16y agoWanting to be more flexible and effective than the process allows you to be is as ancient as processes. I don't see the flaw in the analogy at all.
- lotharbot 16y ago"Deadlock" is another way of saying the government isn't currently changing the rules. It amazes me that people think this is a bad thing. It's good that we have a government that is able to change the rules. It's very good that the government has to follow the proper process/procedure to do so, that they have to get broad support and go through all of the necessary legislative, judicial, and executive steps in order to change the rules citizens must follow. It's a good thing that "individuals" and "empowered civil servants" can't go changing the rules on a whim; those are not hallmarks of agile governments but of corrupt ones.