3 ms·
You can only regulate what you can measure. Ownership is very easy to measure. And tax progressively.
by scotty79 8y ago
You can only regulate what you can measure. Ownership is very easy to measure. And tax progressively.
- LoSboccacc 8y agoAnd suddenly one landlord owns ten companies trough subsidiaries and trusts. This is yet another nice trick that won't work. Besides, price and demand curve would still apply where it was one landlord or hundreds. What would help is to encourage housing density to increase supply. That has two main drive: building regulations (mandate building of a certain height) and taxation (tax building by footprint and not by height/units) Messing with ownership will only make people creative.
- scotty79 8y ago> And suddenly one landlord owns ten companies trough subsidiaries and trusts. This is yet another nice trick that won't work. If you own anything that owns property (and etc. down the chain) then you pay same progressive tax on all properties owned directly on indirectly (minus the tax already payed by subsidiaries if the lawmaker feels so generous, he may not be, because why not discourage creative ownership). > Besides, price and demand curve would still apply where it was one landlord or hundreds. Sure, but if ownership is not that beneficial for large capital holders then less money is used to buy properties. If there is less money and same amount of properties then prices drop. Then more individuals can afford properties, and demand for renting is lower and rents go down. > What would help is to encourage housing density to increase supply. That has two main drive: building regulations (mandate building of a certain height) and taxation (tax building by footprint and not by height/units) If there's more property to buy but plenty of capital to buy then big landlords just buy more and hold, even empty property. Higher supply would probably drive down price a bit, but not as much as you'd expect. The problem is not only insufficient supply but competition between people who have too much capital and people who have barely enough. First group just drives the prices up for everybody, as high as the other group can barely suffer through.
- walshemj 8y agoAsk how that worked out when the UK went for system built high-rise estates or the projects in NYC
- AdrianB1 8y agoTaxes are not a punishment, it is a fair contribution to the costs of having a government and society. If you make it a punishment you turn it into the whip you use to herd cattle, recognizing you treat people like cattle.
- sm4rk0 8y agoMega-landlords are not people.
- scotty79 8y agoTaxes are not a punishment. Taxes are the way of financing government and whatever government decides should be financed. What to tax however is open for debate. First you have to be pragmatic and tax things you can measure. If you can't reliably measure something people will just dodge your tax. Then you have to avoid taxing too much things that are necessary for the economy. What you can safely tax are the behaviors you want to get rid of, like smoking or drinking, or using too much electricity, or emitting co2, or hoarding real estate. If you reduce these behaviors through taxing it's all the better. Taxes are not fair in any shape or form. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sin_tax https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sin_tax
- anthonybullard 8y agoThat's actually not obviously safe at all, you are now basing your recent stands if behavior that in your own estimation is not desired. This creates a really weird incentive structure for legislators and regulators alike.