4 ms·
I can't help but feel as though they ignored the huge range of existing examples of electric bicycles and instead assumed they were entering a greenfields marke
by ehnto 8y ago
I can't help but feel as though they ignored the huge range of existing examples of electric bicycles and instead assumed they were entering a greenfields market.
They are positioned very poorly. It's an unattractive folding bike that doesn't fold and costs too much. People who buy that style of bike do it because it folds, which is also the reason why it compromises on tire size and aesthetics. Anyone wanting an e-bike in that price range has a lot of much more interesting and practical bikes to choose from.
- perfmode 8y agoThe Uni Moke is a bike that GM should pay close attention to: https://urbandrivestyle.com/products/unimoke-urban-utlity-electric-bike https://urbandrivestyle.com/products/unimoke-urban-utlity-el...
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- flgb 8y agoYes with new products emerging every day that are much better designed and full-featured, like: https://www.tillerrides.com/features https://www.tillerrides.com/features
- walrus01 8y agoAs a person who would be the target market for one of these, here's why it's worse than the competition: a) if you're going to have a full length bike that doesn't fold, use something resembling a fat 29er (700C) mountain bike frame. It'll be much more rigid. And the user can do things like put a water bottle cage or two on it. b) 700C gives a much, much wider choice of good quality tires for road, cyclocross type tread pattern (like 700x32), and crosscountry mountain bike type width and tread pattern. c) the totally nonstandard crankset and crankset ring size mean that you can't easily find parts for it, compared to the cranksets and ring sizes you would see for a suspensionless 700C city bike based around a drivetrain like 2x10 or 2x11 in front, and 11-34 cassette in rear. crankset rings for use with 20" size wheel folding bikes are much more rare than normal size rings. edit: more: d) no specification on what derailleur it uses, what shifters/brake levers, no specification on what disc brakes it uses. which in the "serious" bicycle market ($2000+) usually mean junk. I want to see specific shimano or sram part numbers there.
- ehnto 8y agoAnd of course there are already bikes that meet your specifications on the market, electric mountain bikes are already refined as a consumer product. Like you said as well, the bicycle industry has parts standards and some trusted parts manufacturers that hold considerable sway for a consumer. GM may be able to catch some new riders off guard but they won't be breaking into the bicycle market with this offering.
- PunksATawnyFill 8y agoHey Fat America, Want to fool yourself into thinking you're "exercising?" Buy a motorized bike.
- Xylakant 8y agoThat shot went wide: > GM is launching the bikes in Germany, Belgium and the Netherlands Apart from that: Riding an E-Bike is still more exercise than riding a car. It's a good way to start for people that are not trained well enough to make a 10km commute by bike every day. It's also a good way to commute for people that want their commute to be relaxed and not too sweaty. Or people that have climbs on their way. Granted, no true Scotsman would ever use an electric bike or any of those newfangled aids like gear shifts and light steel frames. Hammered iron piping is the only way to ride.
- Shivetya 8y agoI figure its the same reason Harley Davidson [1] is entering the market. To get their name out into an area not normally associated with the brand. It gets them positive spin an area where they are either ignored and ridiculed for their other offerings. Plus it also comes down to throwing as many options at the wall to see what sticks. Harley has a large accessory and clothing setup already and dealers will need more than just sales of motorcycles. Rumor has it the corporate level is forcing dealers who want to carry the EV motorcycle; separate from the EV bicycles whose availability isn't quite known yet; nearly a hundred thousand for specific charging stations and layout. [1] https://electrek.co/2019/01/07/harley-davidson-livewire-e-motorcycle/ https://electrek.co/2019/01/07/harley-davidson-livewire-e-mo...
- ehnto 8y agoIt is weird that HD are targeting the electric mountain bike market as well. There are already incredible offerings from almost all the incumbent MTB manufacturers. It's a pretty established market, and HD has zero experience in making a good mountain bike whereas the incumbents have almost all had decades of it. It is a very nuanced field of engineering and their prototype looks 10x bulkier than existing products. Most E-MTBs look like normal bikes with a slightly thicker downtube, they are already that refined. I would almost say E-MTBs are the best offering from any range of e-bikes currently. Maybe they were just dabbling with prototype sketches. In regards to your comments main focus, it's facinating how much they lean on selling their brand versus their product. It almost seems as though they treat their dealerships like gym franchises.