3 ms·
The real problem with typical Live Coding setups is that the text size is often way too small. You have to massively increase the size of the font or zoom the U
by minimaxir 8y ago
The real problem with typical Live Coding setups is that the text size is often way too small. You have to massively increase the size of the font or zoom the UI so that it's readable for the users, especially those who are viewing the stream on mobile/a small subwindow (one unintended perk of the Electron-based IDEs is that changing font/UI sizes uniformly is easy to do).
I strongly disagree with streaming at 720p30: the low resolution combined with what's said above makes it very hard for the viewers . As long as your upload bandwidth is sufficient (>6 Mbps) and your computer processing power is sufficient (quad-core CPU), I do recommend 1080p60 for future-proofing. Your viewers can lower the quality if necessary, and the exports to YouTube maintain 1080p60 as well. (EDIT: Maybe not: transcoding is apparently not always available for smaller channels, so bandwidth for users can be a concern)
It's worth noting the Streamlabs Alerts are just HTML, and as a result supports as many CSS hacks as you want (e.g. fonts/sizes/colors)
- xpaulbettsx 8y agoThere's zero reason to run 60FPS for a text editor, turn it down to 15FPS and take that extra bandwidth and put it into quality - if you're worried about the YouTube quality after-the-fact, you can run two encoding jobs though it's a bit rough on your CPU
- minimaxir 8y agoDouble-checked: Twitch does say transcoding is "as available" for non-partners: https://help.twitch.tv/customer/portal/articles/2785927-joining-the-affiliate-program https://help.twitch.tv/customer/portal/articles/2785927-join... Hmm, I could have sworn that I had the options available when watching smaller channels, but they may have been Partners. > There's zero reason to run 60FPS for a text editor It does make things surprisingly more fluid, especially for window navigation/scrolling (although you get into the 30fps vs. 60fps debate). If you're using a webcam that also does 60fps, it makes it consistent too.
- mxscho 8y ago> Double-checked: Twitch does say transcoding is "as available" for non-partners It's mainly done for non-partnered channels with high view count (at latest after requesting it manually).
- tastroder 8y agoIf they had it on smaller streams, there also seems to be some mechanism that kicks in when a stream restarts multiple times (my guess would be some heuristic thinks there might be problems and tries to be helpful).
- mxscho 8y agoAlso, like you said, enabling transcoding needs a stream restart right now. Guess this could be improved. Maybe the system's heuristic just doesn't really remember sessions after some hours have passed so it needs to see a high view count again before turning on transcoding (after the restart).
- xpaulbettsx 8y agoI'm not disagreeing that it looks nicer, but trading FPS for clarity is definitely a good idea for live coding. I edited my previous comment, Twitch seems to have improved on this front
- philliphaydon 8y agoThe extra bandwidth would still be pretty small since the screen is mostly static. Unlike streaming a video game which is far more intensive as all 60 frames could be different within that second.
- minimaxir 8y agoNot 100% sure if that’s the case here because of the Constant Bit Rate setting, but there are definitely fewer artifacts.
- philliphaydon 8y agoOh, I didn't know Twitch requires CBR. I guess it makes it easier to determine what the end user can stream without issue.
- nickjj 8y agoAgreed. As someone who makes videos, I'm always jacking up the font size for tutorial videos. I normally keep my editor's font size at 11px pixels, and it lets me easily fit 3 code windows + optional sidebar at 80 characters, and I can sneak in a terminal in 1 spot on demand without it bothering me too much. Then I have a browser and documentation open on my 2nd monitor. It's a very productive set up running at 2560x1440. But in "video mode" I have to record a 1920x1080 area of my screen, and on top of that boost the font size of my editor and terminal font size to 40px. It basically means coding with 1 file visible at a massive size. Even splitting my browser and code editor side by side isn't a good idea most of the time when recording videos because it hides too much of the code. Then for documentation, that can't sit on the 2nd monitor because if you're talking about it, it needs to be on the streamed monitor. It's like coding inside of a coffin instead of a nice 2 bedroom apartment.