5 ms·
> Even there an argument could be made that humane husbandry is positive-utility rather than the neutral of lab-grown, while also coming out ahead environmental
by CharlesW 8y ago
> Even there an argument could be made that humane husbandry is positive-utility rather than the neutral of lab-grown, while also coming out ahead environmentally.
Can that be true? Animals from U.S. factory farms generate >1 million tons of manure per day (open-air lagoons of animal waste are a special treat) and are responsible for an impressive percentage of methane emissions.
- ericsoderstrom 8y agoThere was a recent freakonomics podcast [1] from which I learned that greenhouse gas emissions mostly come from cattle breathing, not their manure (I guess the manure imagery that often goes along with describing livestock environmental impact is just used because it's evocative?). Also that livestock farming in the US only contributes 3% of the nation's greenhouse gas emissions [2], which I wouldn't call a particularly "impressive percentage". [1]: http://freakonomics.com/podcast/meat/ http://freakonomics.com/podcast/meat/ [2]: https://www.epa.gov/ghgemissions/sources-greenhouse-gas-emissions https://www.epa.gov/ghgemissions/sources-greenhouse-gas-emis...
- Maximus9000 8y ago> Also that livestock farming in the US only contributes 3% of the nation's greenhouse gas emissions "Worldwide, livestock accounts for between 14.5 percent and 18 percent of human-induced greenhouse gas emissions. The percentage is lower in the United States in part because our overall greenhouse gas emissions are so much higher than other countries" https://www.nytimes.com/2018/01/25/climate/cows-global-warming.html https://www.nytimes.com/2018/01/25/climate/cows-global-warmi...
- ericsoderstrom 8y agoTrue, but CharlesW's parent comment was specifically about "U.S. factory farms". And even 14.5% is significantly lower than what I would have guessed before listening to the episode.
- cco 8y agoDidn't the poster above say humane animal husbandry? What you describe it not humane animal husbandry.
- llukas 8y agoPlease describe sustainable humane animal husbandry at this scale.
- mrob 8y agoWe should develop an extremely potent and long lasting opioid that's destroyed by cooking (maybe some peptide could work). It needs to be powerful enough that we can keep the animals constantly high for their entire lives. Alternatively, figure out a practical "wireheading" brain implant with the same effect. Animals do not have any ambitions or desire for self-actualization that would be thwarted by this, and we already assume they have no right to life, so the arguments used against doing this to humans do not apply. With enough drugs/brain stimulation they could be perfectly happy in a factory farm.
- pell 8y agoOr we could create a meat tax, stop subsidies, create task forces who actually care about animal welfare and do randomized tests regularly so animal abuse can be limited. It would also help, if governments would actively work on making vegetarian/vegan options more lucrative. All of this is a process that could work out well in 15-20 years. We can, of course, also put animals on drugs so they're high while they live their miserable lives, sure.
- mrob 8y agoWhy would they be miserable? Embarrassed by the respectable high-class animals looking down on them for being junkies? Full of regret that they were too high to write that novel, or to travel to a foreign country? Both our plans have the same result: improved quality of life for animals, while still killing them against their wishes. Why not go with the cheaper option?
- mcv 8y ago> Can that be true? Animals from U.S. factory farms generate >1 million tons of manure per day Factory farms probably don't count as "humane husbandry". I've heard of desertifying areas in the Sahel being made greener again by having goats graze there periodically.