2 ms·
> Many of my developer friends insist that "Normal users don't care!". I am not so sure. I am with you. I've spoken to a lot of non-technical users in my life.
by pdimitar 8y ago
> Many of my developer friends insist that "Normal users don't care!". I am not so sure.
I am with you. I've spoken to a lot of non-technical users in my life. Their very typical and often response on the matter is "it is how it is, I cannot change it, of course it's annoying but I have no alternative" -- this is about ads, heavyweight sites and possible tracking/spying.
So IMO most non-technical people accept it as a fact of life but would rejoice if the Web became lightweight again.
- TeMPOraL 8y ago> So IMO most non-technical people accept it as a fact of life but would rejoice if the Web became lightweight again. Yup. There's also a subset of non-tech people who don't have a basic mental model for how things work; from those, I hear "my computer is slow, probably has viruses, could you help?". I come, and the computer is often fine - it's popular websites that just went through another bloat-up cycle, and the computer struggles with them. Installing uBlock can make such computer live for another year, but ultimately people end up discarding perfectly good hardware just because the web keeps accruing bloat.
- krapp 8y ago>So IMO most non-technical people accept it as a fact of life but would rejoice if the Web became lightweight again. What most non-technical people want is for the web they're using now to work faster. The problem is, the people who want to make the web lightweight again seem to want to do so by eliminating the modern web entirely. No one seems to be asking how we could make the web that exists, and that billions of people actually use, better.
- pdimitar 8y agoI am asking. What would you propose?
- TeMPOraL 8y ago> The problem is, the people who want to make the web lightweight again seem to want to do so by eliminating the modern web entirely. Not entirely, though it may seem that because many proponents of lightweight web - like myself - are just tired of the modern one, and have comparative experience of how to make a site many times more functional and use the fraction of resources at the same time. > No one seems to be asking how we could make the web that exists, and that billions of people actually use, better Circling back to 'pdimitar point upthread: people use what they're given. They have no love for it, they just don't have any other choice. This way people adjust to the growing bloat of the web, and the same way they could adjust back to the leaner web. And yes, many are asking how to make the web that exists better. Not many want to hear the answers, because they begin with "stop doing the crap you're doing right now". The answers are, stop doing SPAs for pages that fit the document model (which is 90%+ of them). Stop putting useless gimmicks on the frontend - like that Cleave.js thing from yesterday, for example[0]. Stop pulling in all the trackers and ad network scripts. Design your page function-first, form-second. It's a hard sell, because it goes against several strong social phenomena, like CV-oriented and fashion-driven development, very lucrative surveillance capitalism business models, vendor lock-in and SaaS-ification of everything. That's why at least part of the solution will have to be technological - just asking people to behave isn't going to cut it. -- [0] - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19233637 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19233637