21 ms·
Is Matter Conscious? (2017)
- trainingaccount 8y agoNo, but information is.
- DATACOMMANDER 8y ago>Is matter conscious Not gonna read that. No. No, matter is not conscious. Go home nautil.us, you’re drunk.
- satori99 8y agoAre you not made of matter? Or are you not conscious?
- AllegedAlec 8y agoToast is made of matter. You are made of matter. Therefore, you are toast.
- jajag 8y agoWell, at least some matter is conscious - i.e. me - and perhaps you...?
- dang 8y agoRegardless of whether matter is conscious, could you please not post unsubstantive comments to Hacker News?
- DATACOMMANDER 8y agoThe substance of my post was that I find the question absurd on its face.
- rosser 8y ago"I think this is dumb" isn't substantive. Why you think it's dumb — maybe even with links to supporting material? Totally different story.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- alexkavon 8y agoI think conciousness would be a potential property of matter, but no not all matter is conscious. The question should actually be: Does all conciousness have matter? Which brings up many more questions, such as: What even is the topic?
- visarga 8y agoNot quite all the matter, but self replicating agents under the right circumstances (evolution) can be. Consciousness is fundamentally a function that preserves the agent in its environment. It's a combination of two optimisation processes - massive random search for its architecture, and learning. It's only purpose is to exist, thus it has to protect the needs of its body and make more of itself. If it doesn't take this purpose, then it is replaced by other agents that do.
- TaupeRanger 8y agoNot a good explanation. Why would a physically instantiated function feel like anything at all, rather than just a bunch of matter moving around? The question is about why the feelings themselves exist. "Functions" do not ever describe the feeling of the smell of chocolate or falling in love. That is the mystery. You have not remotely touched it.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Retra 8y agoFunctions can describe pretty much anything. If you don't see how they can describe something, then you're just using the wrong functions.
- TaupeRanger 8y agoYou misunderstand. A function cannot offer a description of the taste of chocolate. That is the kind of description I am referring to.
- visarga 8y ago> Why would a physically instantiated function feel like anything at all Because its life depends on it. Seeing a berry and not distinguishing its colour could be fatal. > rather than just a bunch of matter moving around We're all a bunch of matter moving around. But we have perception - which is just a neural net converting images to image representations (and other senses in a similar way), and a value function - which rates the expected future rewards in a situation. Perception + value (emotion) creates what philosophers call qualia. These systems have been created by evolution because they are useful for survival. > The question is about why the feelings themselves exist. Again, because we have specific apparatus that computes perception representations and estimates future rewards related to our current situation and action, and because these representations are essential for life to continue. The key differences between an agent and a non-agent are self replication and learning. We have these qualities while rocks don't. Self replication enables evolution and gives an intrinsic goal, a constraint if you will, to the agent. The constraint is what learning and evolution optimise against. More fundamentally, it's a process that maintains low entropy (order) of the body inside the environment by actively compensating for perturbations.
- ravenstine 8y agoI've hypothesized something very similar on my own. Perhaps we'll discover that consciousness, or rather the experience of consciousness, is either a property of matter in specific complex arrangements. Or not matter but perhaps spacetime in some respect. It doesn't really explain how consciousness works, but could explain why it's been so hard for us to understand, just as we don't really understand the nature of existence. I don't believe it, but it's a nifty thing to ponder over.
- agumonkey 8y agoI feel that the best interpretation of it is the thing you should never think about.
- goatlover 8y agoThat would be a form of strong emergentism, which is kind of magical in that properties that don't exist and can't in principle be predicted from earlier states come into being. But it's not like we get to make the rules of what's real. Something about existence is deeply mysterious, so why not consciousness?
- dang 8y agoDiscussed at the time: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14066341 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14066341
- dfilppi 8y agoOf course. We are matter.
- quickthrower2 8y agoSo are rocks.
- state_less 8y agoRocks react in a simple way. If you strike them, they reverberate. One could argue this is a very simple type of consciousness.
- TaupeRanger 8y ago/woosh. The article is talking about the idea that all matter is conscious.
- goatlover 8y agoBut not all of that biological matter is conscious (or at least we don't know that it is in the way the article proposes), and that includes your nervous system.
- baruchthescribe 8y agoFor an entertaining examination of the question of consciousness and its implication for philosophers, I recommend Rupert Sheldrake's lecture here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SFhsObpja8A https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SFhsObpja8A
- pdpdpd 8y agoA draft of a paper exploring a novel, fundamental theory of consciousness, rooted in physics: https://s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/psyphy/PsyPhy.pdf https://s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/psyphy/PsyPhy.pdf
- skissane 8y agoIn summary, neutral monism. In my opinion, here is a far better article on the same topic: https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/neutral-monism/ https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/neutral-monism/
- goatlover 8y agoI thought the author was advocating for panspsychism, where all matter has a least a minimal amount of consciousness (or consciousness is what matter is non-relationally). Neutral monism means that matter and consciousness emerge from something which is neither (like math in the platonic sense or something we have no conception of).
- _Microft 8y agoJürgen Schmidthuber (an AI researcher for those not familiar with the name) gave an interesting explanation what conciousness is in an AMA that he conducted in 2015 on Reddit. I just submitted that in an extra thread [0] because it seems worth discussing. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19241278 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19241278
- eanzenberg 8y agoThis is interesting, very interesting take, but it still doesn't explain where _other_ people's consciousness comes from. Through reductive reasoning, it doesn't explain why calculators and any matter shouldn't have consciousness.
- posterboy 8y agoA calculator processes maybe 64bits, in a machinery that is rather limited, certainly not enough to emulate it's environment, unless a more complex machine operates it.
- goatlover 8y agoHowever, bits, information and software have the same problem as math that was mentioned in the article. And that is that they are abstract and relational, unlike the concrete qualities of experiencing color, pain, a dream, etc. So I doubt that any amount of bits will do any good, just like no math equation is going to become conscious. What would it even mean for an equation or bits of information to have conscious experiences?
- posterboy 8y agoThat's nonsense. A large part of maths is having the right feel for it, numbers are--paradoxically--qualitative. An equation is the application of a join operator, a formula is an operation, thought is operating and you are just thinking of lines scribled on paper instead.
- tigerlily 8y agoI could have been born at any time, in any place in the universe - or not at all, for that matter. Why do I get to experience the universe in a unique way? What gives rise to this?
- nabla9 8y agoTime exists in order that everything doesn’t happen all at once and space exists so that it doesn’t all happen to you.
- dustfinger 8y agoA consequence of time is that every event does not all happen at once. A consequence of space is that everything is not all in one place. Perhaps a consequence of spacetime is that events have a location and a moment, but no guarantee of order?
- hndamien 8y agoI've always been confused that due to time dilation, everything from the perspective of a photon happens all at once, yet there is an order. If time is effectively dilated to the point that time has stopped for the photon, what happens in the year of travel over a light year of distance?
- gotocake 8y agoIt can’t be stated enough: photons don’t have a perspective. Talking about what a photon “sees” is a non-starter. It’s also important to note that light follows null geodesics in spacetime, and while on paper that can look like no time elapses between emission and absorption, it still can’t tell us what it would “be like” to be a photon. If you want to go in that direction though, then this could help. As you approach c, length contraction in the direction of travel is extreme. In “theory” a photon doesn’t really travel at all, the universe is flattened like a pancake in the direction of its travel. There is no time for events to occur “at once” and no year passes on a lightlike curve. A photon is emitted and absorbed without a “subjective” interval, so talking about what such an interval might be missing that point.
- yters 8y agoIf so, then some math equation is conscious, too. It is like asking what color is that smell?
- TaupeRanger 8y agoNo and no. Math equations are abstract concepts within the mind. This question is about how the mind exists in the first place. Nothing here even remotely implies that math equations are conscious.
- phkahler 8y agoDoes the Mandelbrot set exist? We have a mathematical description of it. It's easy to write software to create pictures "of it". Mandelbrot himself wrote software to create an image of it based on his definition - prior to knowing what it looked like. Indeed, he was surprised at the complexity of what he saw. Did that set of points exist prior to a human stumbling on its definition? Does it exist independent of someone rendering an image of it? I would argue that it does exist - and always has - in some form.
- gotocake 8y agoThis is effectively Max Tegemark’s TOE, the Mathematical Universe Hypothesis. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mathematical_universe_hypothesis https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mathematical_universe_hypoth... Tegmark's MUH is: Our external physical reality is a mathematical structure.[3] That is, the physical universe is not merely described by mathematics, but is mathematics (specifically, a mathematical structure). Mathematical existence equals physical existence, and all structures that exist mathematically exist physically as well. Observers, including humans, are "self-aware substructures (SASs)". In any mathematical structure complex enough to contain such substructures, they "will subjectively perceive themselves as existing in a physically 'real' world".[4]
- phkahler 8y agoWell said. In my previous comment I deleted a paragraph where I wrote something like: If there exists a mathematical model/definition of our universe - weather that has been discovered by humans or not - that is sufficient to ensure that it exists. While I have read of the "existence" of mathematical objects I was not aware of anyone writing that we live in such a thing - I figured it must be out there somewhere. Thanks for the link and providing a name for the concept.
- eponeponepon 8y agoSome matter is conscious. My fingernail is not, but it's a subset of the matter that equals me, and I am conscious (you'll just have to take my word); I am a subset of the matter that equals all matter, so it has to follow that the set of all matter is conscious, though subsets of it are not. It's all a matter of where you draw the boundaries.
- ci5er 8y agoUmmm. It's clear that the you that you think of as you does not identify with your fingernail, but is it not arrogant to assume that there is not a greater or lesser entity that incorporates your fingernail in its identity that might be conscious?
- dustfinger 8y agoI recall as a child once that I literally thought the following: > I can accept that the universe can give rise to agents with RI or AI. I can even accept that as a consequence of this, some of these agents may have self awareness. I am such an agent. Yet, I struggle comming to terms with the fact that "I" am aware of myself. I wish I could live long enough to find out how.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- IdiocyInAction 8y agoYeah. I think a lot of people have that issue. I have read about and understood a lot of physicalist theories of consciousness, but I have yet to see one that explains my subjective bubble of experience. I could see how this is all an illusion, but I can't see why I can perceive it then, why I have these vivid subjective experiences. Conciousness is really quite odd, especially because I realized that most of the important functions in the brain are unconcious. I don't find dualism satisfying either; it is not a testable theory.
- posterboy 8y agoMaybe the understanding you are looking for is something that the mind is not interested in. You can hardly formulate the question and the only fair answer is to tell you to not ask the question before you get lost in it. The mantra of yoga and all that jazz was to stop wondering, to find focus. Finding the right words and understanding the problem are two orthogonal problems. Dualism is a good word, and separation is essential to learning. The consciousness just observes the subconsciousness, not the outside world. In that sense, dualism makes perfect sense, but it's only testable by introspection. Empathy helps recognizing that behavior in others. Recognition and socializing is much more important for consciousness than seeing. Even single celled organisms can detect light, but that doesn't count as consciousness. Yet we might call plants our friends, figuratively, and "theory" derives from a root "to perceive".
- md224 8y ago> I don't find dualism satisfying either; it is not a testable theory. I understand the sentiment here, but I also think we should be careful when it comes to the assumption that the truth -- whatever it happens to be -- will be a testable theory. Whether or not something is true is a fact independent of larger epistemological concerns. Then again, perhaps you're just saying that if the truth turns out to be non-testable, then the truth won't be satisfying, which is a reasonable position (and I might agree).
- cobbzilla 8y ago> And a radical change it truly is. Philosophers and neuroscientists often assume that consciousness is like software, whereas the brain is like hardware. This suggestion turns this completely around. When we look at what physics tells us about the brain, we actually just find software—purely a set of relations—all the way down. And consciousness is in fact more like hardware, because of its distinctly qualitative, non-structural properties. For this reason, conscious experiences are just the kind of things that physical structure could be the structure of. I'm not sure I buy the thesis, that conscious experience is the "hardware" and the brain is the "software". It's hard for me to understand how a rock is ultimately comprised of conscious experiences, at its most fundamental level. The attempt to tie together the "hard problem of consciousness" with the "hard problem of matter" comes across a bit square-peg/round-hole to me. If I had to take a wild guess at these- Hard problem of matter: it really is just vibrating strings at the bottom, and this is indeed where physical reality and math become indistinguishable. Blows the mind, and still so much more we can learn. Hard problem of consciousness: I wish I knew more about the evolution of nervous systems, how can we tell when chemistry/biology becomes conscious thought? It's clearly some kind of feedback loop. In the future we could safely & non-invasively study the "bootstrap sequence" for various species brains as they make their first neural signals, from the earliest stages. I really think we can solve this, or get a lot closer, but it will require some far-future technologies.
- _jahh 8y agoBeing a rock would be a much heavier experience, weighted with the gravity of expectations for it to support the structures of shorted lived beings.
- DanielleMolloy 8y agoAre we all just the same universe perceiving itself? (Which philosophies have developed this thought?)
- roberttod 8y agoI can only know for sure that I am conscious, I only assume others are conscious because they are built kind of similar to the way I am. Though if we weren't conscious then would we talk about consciousness? What other topics wouldn't we talk about if we weren't conscious? We could still talk about experience because it would be functional, e.g. "I am experiencing pain" could be something I expect to come from an unconscious thing that has evolved to communicate pain in order to avoid death. Could a conversation about consciousness occur from unconscious things?
- avar 8y agoYes, but more specifically you seem to be fumbling your way towards a well-known though experiment in philosophy: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Philosophical_zombie https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Philosophical_zombie
- taneq 8y agoP-zombies bug me. For a p-zombie to be functionally identical to a human, it would have to process all of the same inputs as the human, including its looped-back internal inputs regarding its own state. Asserting that it's possible to do so without producing an equivalent inner life to that of a 'real' human is just asserting some kind of supernatural basis for consciousness.
- HillaryBriss 8y agowe have the viewpoints of a lot of living beings here, but none from any actual, static, dead matter. sometimes our voices can be so numerous and loud they crowd out and frighten others. i guess what i'm saying is: can we perhaps take a breath, create some space and hopefully encourage some dead matter to step up and offer its perspective?
- blaze33 8y agoRecently learned about what I call the curse of consciousness: the ability and constant urge to question the world, this condition that comes with intelligence and never goes away. So, what is consciousness? Life? How does the world works? Why didn't life come with an instruction manual? What is there to do? And why do I have so many questions that no one already solved?
- denom 8y agoFor a phenomenological treatment, see The Spell of the Sensuous by David Abram. The idea that consciousness exists throughout the world as a gradient is not new. The modern industrial conception of mind (newly transformed by the technological revolution) prescribes a more limited domain for theories of the mind.
- posterboy 8y agoYes! Humans are matter and Humans are Conscious ergo at least some matter is conscious. Rather, matter is the conscious. But it's not just the matter, it's also the radiation and what have you between it.
- md224 8y agoThis is an interesting essay, but as someone who agrees with Brentano that intentionality is the mark of the mental, I have to disagree with the second half of this passage: > Our own consciousness is also usually consciousness of something -- it involves awareness or contemplation of things in the world, abstract ideas, or the self. But someone who is dreaming an incoherent dream or hallucinating wildly would still be conscious in the sense of having some kind of subjective experience, even though they are not conscious of anything in particular. I have no way to prove this, but I firmly believe that even in extreme states of consciousness, we are still conscious of something, in the sense that our attention is directed somewhere... our mind is always attending to something in particular. That "something" could be a bizarre fragment of a bizarre experience, but it's still something. I don't believe it's possible to be conscious without our attention being directed somewhere, even when the content of our experience appears to be maximally diffuse and unfocused. (In those cases, the content just is the object of our attention, the thing we are conscious of.)
- golemotron 8y agoI think you could switch around nouns randomly in this article and arrive at an article that made as much sense.
- paraschopra 8y agoPanpsychism is exciting. But there are two problems in it. One is the combination problem: what sort of collection of atoms are conscious and what are not. If you propose then that only agents or complex systems are conscious, you are faced with the second problem: the boundary condition. What do you call an agent, and why? I’m ultimately hopeful that subjective experience will come to be seen as something fundamental. But the difficulty is that we can’t just make up new entities / concepts in the world that don’t agree with current scientific facts. So such a science of consciousness has to be compatible with modern findings of neuroscience and psychophysics. It’s exciting times! Let’s hope that we’re able to get a grip on this question of why we have this subjective experience of red colour.
- trixie_ 8y agoI think panpsychism argues that everything is conscious, at all levels, simultaneously. There are no boundaries. What you experience as a boundary is just the limit of your awareness. Just as you don't consciously beat your heart or heal your wounds. And if you think about it a lot it's tough to really tell where your own boundary brain/body ends and the environment begins. I like the panpsychism stuff because it resolves some other problems as well 'the transporter problem' - are you the same person after transporting star trek style? Under panpsychism it doesn't matter because you are unawarely everything anyways. Also the 'the split problem' - say I separated you atom by atom to create two new people with half your parts - which one would you be? or both simultanously? or none? Panpsychism makes answering these questions easy as it argues that you are unawarely both. A lot of people are trying to explain how we are discreet entities that arise from non-discreet pieces. Trying to figure out where boundaries end/begin. When do you become conscious. What is conscious and what is not. The paysychism theory explains all these things in the other direction by saying nothing is discreet. The sense of discreetness may as well be an evolutionary illusion for the survival of my bag of atoms. Who knows what is true though, it'd be a breakthrough if there were a way to experimentally validate any of these theories..
- jacobsimon 8y agoI don’t disagree with the problems you describe, but I don’t think panpsychism explains any of these problems either. It’s a non-answer, and functionally equivalent to saying nothing about consciousness. The “evolutionary illusion” you describe is precisely what we’re trying to understand: the brain is doing an extraordinary magic trick and no one knows how.
- wwarner 8y agoNice interview with Phillip Goff on CBC Ideas: https://www.cbc.ca/amp/1.4822151 https://www.cbc.ca/amp/1.4822151 . He reiterates B Russell's point: The least extraordinary thing we know is that we're aware of nature, and we're made of the same natural substances that make up the external world. Therefore the extraordinary claim is that there can be no consciousness outside of the body. In other words, it requires extraordinary evidence. He makes the conventional dismissive attitude sound pretty chauvanistic. It's a good interview.
- jacobsimon 8y agoI think opinions like these ignore the immense complexity of the animal brain compared to other natural materials. We are not made of the same stuff as the rest of the external world—living things have a very precise configuration of cells and connections, and the slightest deficiencies or disturbances lead to complete loss of consciousness
- lisper 8y agoExactly. The sand on the beach and a CPU are made of the same stuff too, but arguing that therefore beach sand can compute is obviously absurd. The consciousness of all matter is just as obviously absurd.
- vokep 8y agoBut beach sand DOES compute, once treated and arranged in a certain way. The ability to compute is present in all matter. The ability for consciousness is present in all matter in the same way. Perhaps these abilities are one and the same.
- lisper 8y agoI can cut down a tree, mill it into lumber, and build a house out of it. It does not follow from this that a tree is a house. Once a tree is "treated and arranged" in the particular way that turns it into a house it is no longer a tree. Likewise, once beach sand is "treated and arranged" in the particular way required to make it compute, it isn't beach sand any more. > The ability to compute is present in all matter. No, it isn't. If you think it is, tell me how to build a computer out of a single hydrogen atom.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- kwccoin 8y agoLet us reduce this to a simpler question. Can Matter detect i.e. collapse quantum wave? If it is conscious but cannot even detect quantum event, is it really conscious? As this is physical event we can check, we can at least determine that.
- Retra 8y agoBest learn some actual quantum physics before you start pretending to understand it.
- empath75 8y agoI don’t get the need to push consciousness down the stack. Where is the beach in a grain of sand? Where is the song in a molecule of air?
- blueadept111 8y agoThis is one of the very few articles I've read about the nature of consciousness where the ideas presented are cogent, consistent, and novel (to me). She does a terrific job of explaining the current state of affairs in philosophy of mind, about as clearly as anyone could, and then describing a new paradigm.
- yesenadam 8y agoYes, I read it after reading the comments on this page, expecting a silly mess. But no, it was well-written, for that kind of piece - it's popular internet journalism, not a professional philosophy journal, people! For what it's worth, the 'matter is made from consciousness' view does seem unlikely in the extreme to me. I thought it was strange the term '(philosophical) idealism' wasn't used once, as it seems that's what most of the article was describing. Maybe she didn't want to confuse people with the more common meaning of 'idealism' today (to do with ideals, not ideas). Russell was a Hegelian idealist for a few years in the mid-1890s, like a lot of British (and American) philosophers, and published a book on Leibniz in 1900. (It's probably not a great introduction to the subject, but David Stove's Idealism: A Victorian Horror-Story is a very funny long essay by the Australia philosopher, mostly ridiculing the arguments used in support of idealism, in detail. Stove's Gem - winner of his Worst Argument in the World competition[0] - is worth being able to recognize in the wild.) [0] https://web.maths.unsw.edu.au/~jim/worst.html https://web.maths.unsw.edu.au/~jim/worst.html
- knowThySelfx 8y ago"Maybe matter is made from waves/vibration could be more plausible?" Thinking about Quantum Double Slit Experiment and such.
- djakjxnanjak 8y agoCan we say that consciousness is a process that occurs when matter is arranged in a particular way? In the same way that you could say a whirlpool is a process that occurs when water is arranged in a particular way. All of the water molecules in the vicinity are participating in the whirlpool, but that doesn’t mean that all water everywhere has “whirlpoolness” all the time. It doesn’t seem like a divine mystery to me that a brain could have consciousness while a single atom from a brain doesn’t - it just means that consciousness is complicated and requires many parts to be assembled. In the same way that a single atom of silicon isn’t a computer or a single molecule of water isn’t a whirlpool.
- yokljo 8y agoWhat if your consciousness exists outside your physical brain, and within your brain is basically an aerial that is "tuned to your frequency", so no matter where you are your brain will always communicate with the same consciousness. I suppose with that theory comes the ability for two brains to tune into the same consciousness, and various other fun implications. Is there already a name for this?
- Ste_Evans 8y agoIs there already a name for this? Yes, "philosophy", or more colloquially "bollox".
- goto11 8y agoIt is called the mind-body duality.
- goldenkey 8y agoIn the same vein, there are theories that subunits of our brain are conscious in their own right. And if the visual cortex could communicate itd say "Stop showing me cat memes!!" :-)
- robotresearcher 8y agoDualism. Or ‘Mind-body dualism’ to disambiguate with other uses. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mind–body_dualism https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mind–body_dualism
- qyv 8y agoWhat if we all share the same consciousness, but are simply unable to comprehend it? To me the idea that all concious entities are in fact shared is comforting, because it implies that what we do with our lives will always be remembered. Even after our lives end, our singular consciousness, with all of our memories, thoughts and feelings, remains.
- yokljo 8y agoAnother fun implication if it really were aerial-like, is that our consciousness would have a sort of "maximum bandwidth". I think this theory is actually pretty convincing. It would be awful if you were conscious of every single thing your brain did, including all your subconscious thoughts and motor neurons firing. That is why you are conscious of much more specific things like vision, hearing, touch and so forth. Generally the signals within your brain would be akin to random data, so surely they would be post-processed by your brain into a useful contiguous "conscious-ready" signal. That post-processed signal would probably be sent from one location, and therefore the aerial analogy works well. When you go under general anaesthetic, that specific part of the brain would stop transmitting completely and you don't experience a single thing until it wears off and it starts transmitting again. When you sleep and dream, the signal is just a mess of neatly post-processed signals coming from different parts of your brain, so you are still basically conscious. I read somewhere that if you stimulate a particular part of someone's brain, it can make them temporarily unconscious, which would make sense with the aerial analogy. If that's how it works, then maybe our sense of time passing is directly proportional to the amount of data sent. So if your brain transmits a lot of stuff in a short time, that short real-time seems like a long conscious-time, and vice versa. It's clearly a flawless theory ;)
- e3b0c 8y agoHas anyone read Schopenhauer's books like The world as will and representation? His idea doesn't seem to be talked about much. However, I would admit that I don't fully comprehend the ideas of that book either.
- Ste_Evans 8y agoThese kind of silly ideas refuted here: http://backreaction.blogspot.com/2019/01/electrons-dont-think.html http://backreaction.blogspot.com/2019/01/electrons-dont-thin... Tl;DR only the physical properties of matter observed in the Standard Model can contribute to consciousness at the energy levels in the brain, apparently. These kinds of problems are not going to be solved by "philosophers" who don't know enough neuroscience or physics, as any proposed ontology will have to fit with scientific observation. When will cranks like the author of this article be booted out of the academy? The article is utter drivel.
- cam_l 8y agoMy favourite explanation of the emergence of consciousness inherent in matter is an article by Elizabeth Grosz. It makes an argument for what i guess is a version of panpsychism that sounds, philosophically, very practical. http://www.parrhesiajournal.org/parrhesia15/parrhesia15_grosz.pdf http://www.parrhesiajournal.org/parrhesia15/parrhesia15_gros...
- Ste_Evans 8y agoYes, but the problem is it is contradicted by scientific observation: http://backreaction.blogspot.com/2019/01/electrons-dont-think.html http://backreaction.blogspot.com/2019/01/electrons-dont-thin... What do we call academics who ignore current knowledge that contradicts their ideas? Cranks. A subset of cranks being most "philosophers".
- goldenkey 8y agoOh please suppress your ad hominem "crank" attack. The post you linked gets so many things wrong, its as if they are battling an entirely different entity. Electrons don't need to think to be conscious because thinking != consciousness. Experiencing their state is all that needs to occur to satisfy consciousness. The idea is that consciousness experienced is 1:1 with the state of the matter producing the consciousness. Also, the randomness in quantum behavior could actually be how conscious entities think. Electrons may only have a couple states but they get to roll the dice, fairly, on those states. Just like we think we do, even though our decisions are random..not actually "willed."
- Ste_Evans 8y agoThe point is that the author of the Nautilus article is not just wrong (reason provided), she is ignoring well-known current knowledge which makes her idea facilely wrong i.e. she's a crank. It's a fact, not ad hominem. The physicist simply states that the only properties of matter that can be appealed to in explaining consciousness are those described in the Standard Model. Or the Standard Model is wrong. Are you saying the observations of the Standard Model are wrong?
- yreg 8y agoThe other way to look at this is that consciousness emerges from a certain kind of structure and processes independent of the matter it is represented on. Consciousness would emerge in our brains from the neural structure and activity, but it would also emerge when computed in a computer simulation or (as a thought experiment) calculations on paper or xkcd-esque pebbles in sand. That would make the computer, calculations on paper and pebbles in the sand as conscious as a human. Which, admittedly sounds just as crazy as the idea of consciousness being tied to all matter.
- daoxid 8y agoDoes consciousness produce any measurable effect? For a time I thought consciousness is some kind of by-product of some kinds of computation which doesn't influence the computation itself. But how can I then know that I am conscious? And if I know that I am conscious, then consciousness must have a measurable effect, right? Because the knowledge that you are conscious should be reflected somewhere in your brain. However, whenever I think about consciousness, I have the feeling that I am missing something obvious but important. It's just so confusing.
- visarga 8y ago> Does consciousness produce any measurable effect? In the morning when you wake up do you make a sandwich? If you didn't have consciousness, you wouldn't. So your body would cease to exist in a short time. Consciousness has measurable effects - every time it saves us from hunger, danger, and other bad situations, or when it leads us to good situations.
- vokep 8y agoBut theoretically you could just as well be a philosophical zombie, getting up and making a sandwhich. Electrical lights on in the brain but no light of consciousness.
- MaxBarraclough 8y agoYou're describing intelligent decision-making and prudent action, not consciousness. We are conscious even when doing nothing, and computers show us that systems showing some sort of 'intelligence' needn't be conscious. (I'm being very imprecise about the meaning of 'intelligence' here, mind.)
- vanviegen 8y agoFollowing that logic, a robot vacuum that can have itself charged is conscious?
- visarga 8y agoIt's at least conscious of its energy.
- AllegedAlec 8y agoIt's a good thing that Betteridge's law of headlines continues to be true. I never understood the appeal of this idea, to be honest. This article also doesn't seem to think there are any strong arguments for it. Or at least, if the writer has them, they do not present them in any cogent way, instead piling appeal to emotions one upon the other until the entire thing collapses under its own weight.
- Razengan 8y agoMost questions of this sort remind me of "Can submarines swim?" If we build an AI that can interact via natural human language, and ask it about its internal state, and it replies "I am happy.", is it happy? And whatever criteria we use to decide that machines cannot really be happy the way we can be, could a hypothetical species that thinks at a "higher level" than us, use similar criteria to determine that humans can't really think?
- visarga 8y agoAn AI would have a goal, even if it is simple curiosity, and its happiness is related to the distance from its goal. It would evaluate each situation and action with regard to the goal and decide on actions that lead to it, learning from past mistakes. 'I am happy' is possible for us because we have an innate goal - to live, to reproduce, to maximise our rewards, rewards which have been programmed into us by evolution. AIs can have rewards and can learn to act towards them, thus they can have emotion which is just a map from the present situation to the goal.
- natosaichek 8y agoI disagree with basically everything you just said. An AI might not have a goal. If it did, its happiness may or may not be related to the distance from the goal. It might not evaluate every situation and action with regard to it's (presumed) goal. I don't think we do have a (single) innate goal. Everyone has different goals, and they are not innate. Emotions are not a map from a present situation to a goal. AI might not have emotions.
- visarga 8y ago> I don't think we do have a (single) innate goal. Survival. And that includes many subgoals such as feeding, safety, autonomy, being part of a group, curiosity, and making offspring, all preprogrammed into the brain by evolution. Artificial agents would have goals preprogrammed by humans instead, such as 'winning at Go'.
- ozy 8y agoIf you have a theory of consciousness, but it doesn't include something about learning, the theory is incomplete, most likely wrong.
- edem 8y agoDo any of you know about Process Philosophy: https://www.iep.utm.edu/processp/ https://www.iep.utm.edu/processp/ ?
- dalbasal 8y agoEnough credible people have publicly considered the idea credible for me to open my mind. But... I have to keep my mind open with a brace. otherwise, it'll call occam's razor & snap shut. At the heart of consciousness particles ideas (I think) is the idea that conciousness can't emerge from nonconscious stuff. This is counterintuitive to me. We now know of all sorts of emergent phenomenon. Species emerge (from other, sometimes simpler species) and that emergence dynamic turned slime into ND Tyson. Substances like coffee and coffee tables emerge from basic particle characteristics like charge (to borrow their example). Chemistry emerges from particle physics. Biology emerges from chemistry. Can someone point me to the starting point? I must be missing something. Why can't non-conscious matter, arranged precisely, think?
- 0_gravitas 8y agoThey way that I've always thought about it is this: We are the physics that drives us, everything else is an abstraction. Chemistry as a thing didnt emerge from particle physics, it is an abstraction of particle physics, a higher-level view on how certain particles interact, and biology is an abstraction of chemistry, "when we combine certain chemicals this stuff happens". But if we take a moment, we zoom in and zoom in and we will find that the common denominator is that things exist in these ways because physics is doing what it does. The insane rube-goldberg machine of the human body is still a rube-goldberg machine that is being driven by physics, theres millions of layers of complexity, but it's still physics all the way down.
- MaxBarraclough 8y ago> it's still physics all the way down The existence of physics doesn't demonstrate that dualism is wrong.
- daoxid 8y agoAlthough I generally agree with you, I think there is a difference between the emergent property of a coffee table and that of consciousness: the particles the coffee table is made of are "just" matter, and so is the coffee table itself. But consciousness seems to be something different than matter (or maybe this is just a false assumption of mine). So while I find it intuitive that a table emerges from a number of particles, I think there is a qualitative difference between particles and consciousness. You can zoom into a coffee table until you see individual particles, but what would it mean to "zoom into" a consciousness?
- rawmodz 8y agoI think there is a mutually intertwine relationship between Time and Consciousness. Time => Consciousness => Time => Consciousness. I don't think Time is inside Consciousness.
- knowThySelfx 8y agoEven Time is a variable construct - affected by Gravity (Time Dilation etc)
- cybervegan 8y agoThe neural network of nematode worms has been modelled in software, and a robotic avatar has been built for this "mind". It behaves very much like a real nematode worm. Real nematode worms appear to be conscious to an extent, in so far as they forage for food and mates, and retreat from danger or threats. I don't think we would argue that nematodes have the same level of consciousness as we do. If the mechanical model also does this, it it conscious too? We also know that different animals display different levels of consciousness, in many ways reflected by the amount of brain mass they posess; animals with far simpler brains appear, by and large, to be less conscious than animals with larger, more complex brains. We also know that damage to brains alters the properties of consciousness, as do interference with brain chemistry or electrical activity. It seems more likely that consciousness is an emergent property of the interactions between the physical structure of the brain/nervous system and electrical/chemical messaging. I think that assuming matter has a special, magical property of "consciousness" is just re-hashing the unfalsifiable concept of a "soul".
- visarga 8y agoI agree. I'd like to add that consciousness is an emergent property of the interactions between the agent and the environment. The environment is what feeds the agent with perceptions and reward signals, enabling learning to happen.
- acqq 8y ago> just re-hashing the unfalsifiable concept of a "soul" Yes. It comes from religiously inclined or deeply religious philosophers and “philosophers”. Once they fix they “belief” they search for any possible way to fit the reality, which otherwise wouldn’t support their belief, with their already pre-decided goal. Even worse, the last time I’ve checked, nautil.us was financed by the people with such goals: https://www.templeton.org https://www.templeton.org "The Foundation takes its vision from its founding benefactor, the late Sir John Templeton, who sought to stimulate what he described as “spiritual progress.”" And, as a more obvious parallel, if you ever wondered who produces "Ancient Aliens" on History Channel, it's also non-accidentally the guy who wants more "spirituality", in his words: "It’s really a show about looking for God. Science would have you believe we are the result of nothing more than a chance assemblage of matter" whereas "Ancient Aliens" "offers seekers an origin story." https://www.nytimes.com/2018/07/21/style/ancient-aliens.html https://www.nytimes.com/2018/07/21/style/ancient-aliens.html Yes, both behind the "conscious matter" and behind https://knowyourmeme.com/photos/158327-ancient-aliens https://knowyourmeme.com/photos/158327-ancient-aliens is a "spirituality" drive.
- dandare 8y agoI for one fail to understand what is it so mysterious about consciences. Also, the article spends way more time lamenting the mystery than explaining what the so-called "hard problem of consciousness" is. Yes, we can not build consciousness yet, so what. We have a very good reason to believe it is completely based on matter and physics because everything we have seen so far seems to be based on matter and physics. One way or another, our brain seems to be some kind of computing meat machine that runs some kind of program(s). In order to keep us alive, this program is trying to predict what will happen next. A lion appears to be running in our direction? I predict it will get closer and closer and then it will eat us. Next step: in order to better predict the future, model in also your own actions. I will not stand here if I know a lion is going to eat me, I will run to that nearest tree. So the brain predicts that we will end up climbing that tree. Then, model in your understanding of the future and better grab a rope before you start running to that tree. Throw in all kinds of imperfections, remnants of older systems, evolutionary pressures, instincts and emotions and voila, you appear to be conscious.
- JoeAltmaier 8y agoThat describes behavior, but not the sense of self-awareness? If conscious means, reacting to the environment (opposite of unconscious) then that could make sense. But if it means self-aware it doesn't get any closer to explaining that.
- dandare 8y agoMaybe I don't understand the question. What else is "self-awareness" than a program calculating its own actions based on the knowledge of its own prediction ability? Can you disprove such program will be self-aware? Can you prove your self-awareness is something more?
- JoeAltmaier 8y agoThat's the whole conversation right there. I'm aware of my surroundings in an immediate sense with many states of being inside my head, immersed in my surroundings, caught up in the moment and many others across the spectrum. Unrelated to my cognitive function, logic or fitness for calculating action. I could create a device that says "I'm self-aware" but does it make it so? You can get your Echo to do that.
- vagab0nd 8y agoI've been wondering this for a long time: if we can understand every detail of the inner working of the brain, what happens if I observe my brain in real time? Is it like calling a function recursively without an exit condition?
- Retra 8y agoObviously not? Looking at your brain is not the same as executing it. You'd just be looking at pictures. It'd be more like calling a function that reformats it own source code.
- SideburnsOfDoom 8y agoIf matter can't be conscious, then what can? The choices seem to be: 1) consciousness can emerge from matter, and human beings are exhibit A for this. 2) human being are not conscious. c) There's a "ghost in the machine", a soul, spirit or some other kind of supernatural ghost that's not reducable to matter as we know it.
- EliRivers 8y agoArrangements and patterns, perhaps. The matter isn't conscious. Consiciousness is in the arrangement of matter.
- SideburnsOfDoom 8y ago> Consiciousness is in the arrangement of matter. Right, that's what "emerge" means in option A. https://www.researchgate.net/post/What_is_your_definition_of_emergent_properties https://www.researchgate.net/post/What_is_your_definition_of... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emergence https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emergence
- Madmallard 8y agoMaybe I'm super naive and if so please educate me, but honestly why are we even considered conscious? Can't basically everything we do be just explained by the brain reacting to its environment? Even the derivative thoughts and actions and stuff you perform is just the brain reacting to itself as well. It's not like the brain is disconnected from itself, it's connected to sensing organs and everything everywhere inside. Other observations: The older you get, the more robotic people seem, especially younger people and the mentally ill. It's like you can exactly see why they would say or do something based on what you know about their life or situation or even just the contexts beforehand.
- itry2develop 8y agoI think some people are using the tests for intelligent life for conciousness, which is wrong. Does the matter, dead or alive, experience its surroundings at some base level? If you are not a rock, then dont "lifesplain" for that rock. I question, is it really the presence of energy, which all matter has, that leads to a relationship with other energy in the universe?
- qqqwww 8y agoIf you find this topic interesting I think you'll benefit from reading "The unfortunate dualist" http://themindi.blogspot.com/2007/02/chapter-23-unfortunate-dualist.html?m=1 http://themindi.blogspot.com/2007/02/chapter-23-unfortunate-... The whole book "The Mind's I" is a fascinating collection of stories and essays dealing with this topic.
- Ste_Evans 8y agoNo. Next question!