4 ms·
First of all the ARM chips Apple ships are designed for iOS workloads (check out the dominance of graphics in area and internal bandwidth on the iPad Pro chips
by gumby 8y ago
First of all the ARM chips Apple ships are designed for iOS workloads (check out the dominance of graphics in area and internal bandwidth on the iPad Pro chips -- it calls to mind the Alto's explicit tradeoff of bus bandwidth and screen refresh). Apple's ARM parts have been smokers for the past few generations but they aren't designed for the sustained performance and instruction mix targeted by Intel.
But that doesn't have to be true. MacOS CPUs need not be the same as the ones in iOS devices (after all they aren't today either).
Apple could very well design ARM instruction set chips with special pipelined or SIMD instructions that support, say, the kind of transforms Final Cut needs. They could make sure Photoshop was a barn burner on their machines if they thought that mattered. Etc.
The real question is the rest of the silicon (peripheral controllers like TB etc which they also get from their Intel deal).
As for the tired trope of "As much as Apple has neglected pros" -- I'm tired of hearing that. Yes of course their mix isn't perfect for everyone but holy cow, my MacBook Pro has 4 40GPS TB ports! Hell, I get a lot of work done on their smaller devices, and the ever increasing portability is a huge plus. I'm a pro, not prosumer, and it works for me.
I know my needs aren't the same as everybody else's, but I would bet that Apple knows the usage profile of everyone willing to share analytics, including how often people plug what sort of device into their machines. And I'm sure that informs their designs.
Every design will fail to be a perfect match for some set of pros, and of course they should complain. Maybe it's just that they are designing machines for me? (in which case: fix the damned touch bar).
- consp 8y agoYou are basically talking about the A76 core[1] and modified derivatives and its successors (e.g. neoverse[2]). [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ARM_Cortex-A76 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ARM_Cortex-A76 [2] https://en.wikichip.org/wiki/arm_holdings/microarchitectures/neoverse_n1 https://en.wikichip.org/wiki/arm_holdings/microarchitectures...
- close04 8y agoThe N1 is actually expected to be on par or faster than a Zen core in single threaded applications. Overall it would be a match for both Zen and Skylake-SP. Add to this Apple's specific brand of control over their software stack and you've got some exceptional potential to deliver high performance in a low power envelope. And all this while giving Apple full control over every aspect of their product (whether it leads to good or bad outcomes). Which could mean actual yearly refreshes instead of forgetting about a product for years because Intel had nothing in the pipeline. I mean if you're going to pay a hefty price premium you probably want something only Apple can give you. Not just a more expensive version of the same thing shipped by every other OEM out there.
- speedplane 8y agoMoore's law is dead. Switching architectures to something that is more customizable to your current process is one of the only ways to squeeze more performance out of a given chip. It's why companies are increasingly building their own ASICs. If Moore's law was alive, they wouldn't need to, they'd just wait for the next general purpose chip to come out.
- close04 8y agoThis isn't just a matter of Moore's law. The lack of competition over the past decade also played a major role. Intel didn't feel pressed to deliver anything and instead decided to milk the market. It doesn't even matter if tomorrow we find a way to bring back Moore's law (performance increase, not necessarily transistor density). Apple probably doesn't want to be back here 10 years from now if competition is dwindling. And again, if they want to charge a lot more than the competition they have to justify it. This is the justification. Give me a super optimized CPU for which major software companies optimize their software and you've got my attention. I imagine Adobe would make sure their SW gets tha last drop of performance on Apple's machines. May not be the case with the competition's run of the mill ARM core.
- speedplane 8y agoIt all comes back to Moores law. Today, there is more competition between chip fabs than ever. ARM is beating Intel in a number of markets. They are able to do so, because Intel is slowing down. Intel is slowing down because of Moore's law. The idea that a company would optimize a chip to their specific purpose is also a consequence of Moore's law. If performance did exponentially increase, there would be no point in optimizing for a task, because by the time you finished that, the general purpose solution would be faster.
- ksec 8y ago> (check out the dominance of graphics in area and internal bandwidth on the iPad Pro chips -- it calls to mind the Alto's explicit tradeoff of bus bandwidth and screen refresh). I assume you mean Die Area? Which isn't all that "dominant" if you look at Intel U Series Chip with near 50% of its die area goes to GPU, and even more so in Icelake.
- Marsymars 8y ago> The real question is the rest of the silicon (peripheral controllers like TB etc which they also get from their Intel deal). This is one of the reasons I think the 12" MacBook moving to ARM makes strategic sense - with a single non-TB USB-C port, it's already on par with the iPad Pro. (Technically behind, since the iPad has a 10 Gbps port and the MacBook currently only has a 5 Gbps port.) And I have a hard time sussing why Apple would have seemingly abandoned updates if they're not moving it to ARM.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- TheOperator 8y ago>As for the tired trope of "As much as Apple has neglected pros" -- I'm tired of hearing that. Yes of course their mix isn't perfect for everyone but holy cow, my MacBook Pro has 4 40GPS TB ports Yes apples support of high bandwidth ports has always been a selling point for pros. I can also mention their printer driver stack is superior, their audio driver stack is superior, their computers have good audio, their displays have consistently accurate colors, they are early adopters of qhd/5k/6k and offer computers with such displays at a steal of a price, osx is unix-like, there is various exclusive propietrary software, etc, etc. When I say "neglected pros" I mean it though. That trashcan mac pro sucked and the release cycle of the mac pro has been awful. The macbook pro went from being the fastest WINDOWS laptop to running into worse and worse thermal throttling issues while being saddled with a crap keyboard. The pricing has actually gotten worse relative to other brands and the quest for thinness is causing TCO to creep up due to lack of repairability/user servicability. Apple smacks of focusing on their luxury image with their thin/light obsession and not enough on their prosumer roots. Yes the improved portability is nice but the biggest jumps were years and years ago and Apple (and other brands) just seem to be getting stupid now.