3 ms·
I've often wondered why malaria eradication campaigns always seem to target mosquitoes rather than the mosquito-borne parasites that actually cause the disease.
by pmoriarty 8y ago
I've often wondered why malaria eradication campaigns always seem to target mosquitoes rather than the mosquito-borne parasites that actually cause the disease.
Wouldn't it make sense to go after the root cause rather than merely its host?
- daniel-cussen 8y agoThe mosquito is made of more parts and they're more differentiated than a virus, so there's more ways to make it fail. EDIT/Errata: Malaria is not a virus.
- tgb 8y agoMalaria isn't a virus, FYI. Nor a bacteria.
- biomcgary 8y agoMalaria is caused by a protist (a singled celled organism), not a virus. To some extent, you are right about the mosquito being a bigger target. However, the larger reason is that Plasmodium populations (the protist) are larger than mosquito populations and, consequently, can evolve around human modifications faster.
- gpm 8y ago- Less types of mosquito's - Way (many orders of magnitude) less # of mosquitos than parasite organisms (malaria is a single celled organism, mosquito's are ~1 million celled organisms). - Mosquito's reproduce sexually, malaria reproduces asexually, someone had a good idea about how to target sexual reproduction.
- throway88989898 8y ago> often wondered Lack of a vaccine. Drug resistance. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Malaria https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Malaria
- gpm 8y agoDo vaccines even exist for organisms in the same class as malaria? I've always associated them with viruses.
- gotocake 8y agoYou can vaccinate against some bacteria, but I’ve never heard of a vaccine for a protist although there are ongoing attempts. This rundown is pretty thorough as to why it’s chalenging, and why that challenge is related to the complexity of something like Plasmodium compared to a simple organism like a bacteria or virus. https://www.nap.edu/read/9027/chapter/6 https://www.nap.edu/read/9027/chapter/6 The malaria parasite has multiple, immunologically distinct developmental stages and effective immune avoidance strategies. Single-antigen and single-stage vaccines have proved disappointing. Multi-antigen, multistage vaccines, which elicit different kinds of immune responses directed toward different antigens, appear more promising. High antibody levels can be effective against sporozoites and blood-stage parasites, but a cytotoxic cell response is needed to attack the critical liver stage, and antibodies are clearly needed to block transmission. Selecting the optimal antigens from among the stages in the parasite's life cycle and devising optimal formulations and delivery systems to elicit the desired immunologic response is a complex and difficult task, one that must be based on scientific knowledge, but will also require empirical testing of multiple potential vaccine products. Remember that a vaccine needs to produce an immune response that doesn’t lead to cytokine storm or devestating autoimmune response.
- throway88989898 8y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vaccine-preventable_diseases https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vaccine-preventable_diseases Not an expert, but it is #25 on that WHO list.
- credit_guy 8y agoIt was added to the list in 2016, but with the mention that, while a vaccine exists, it's not commercially available [1] "Recent progress has been made with the completion of a Phase 3 trial of the RTS,S/AS01 candidate vaccine and review by the European Medicines Agency and WHO. There is currently no commercially available malaria vaccine." [1] https://www.who.int/immunization/research/development/malaria/en/ https://www.who.int/immunization/research/development/malari...
- chr1 8y agoIn addition to the objective reasons why it is not possible mentioned by sibling comments, there is a subjective reason that many people don't like mosquitos, and think they deserve eradication independently from malaria.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]