3 ms·
The point you're making is orthogonal to the one I was making: the force ~ voltage analogy breaks down at KCL/KVL (as well as ungrounded inductors), while the f
by colanderman 16y ago
The point you're making is orthogonal to the one I was making: the force ~ voltage analogy breaks down at KCL/KVL (as well as ungrounded inductors), while the force ~ current analogy breaks down only for ungrounded capacitors.
"Ungrounded capacitors" refers to capacitors which do not have at least one terminal connected to the reference voltage (ground). These break the force ~ current analogy because with that analogy, capacitors, which are two-terminal devices, are analogous to flywheels, which are one-terminal devices. The velocity (voltage) of the second terminal is effectively zero.
Your reading of my post is close to correct. The force ~ voltage analogy is incorrect however you look at it because KCL and KVL don't hold. The "old" force ~ current analogy does hold except for the case of ungrounded capacitors, which the replacement of flywheels with inerters remedies.