3 ms·
This censorship slow motion train wreck started back when these third parties inserted themselves into what used to be person-to-person interaction. First, it w
by mindslight 8y ago
This censorship slow motion train wreck started back when these third parties inserted themselves into what used to be person-to-person interaction. First, it was that they were simply providing convenience and hosting. Then editorializing, because simply following the DMCA wasn't draconian enough. Then algorithmically determining what content we should even see, because self-selection requires thought. Then going all-in on filter bubbles as search capability failed. Then gaming the recommendations for their perverse metric of human time wasted.
Unfortunately, from a business perspective there isn't really much other choice. If Youtube solely put itself out there as a commodity video hosting site (with no discovery), then people could switch at the drop of a hat. Whatever they were using for discovery would simply grow a video hosting feature, and we'd get Newtube. As in all media, what matters is the captive audience.
The only real path forward for freedom is to repudiate this corporate-mediated garbage and start seriously adopting software based on peer interaction. As long as third parties remain in the loop, the incentive to blame them for not doing our preferred magical thing is just too strong. Hopefully this can happen before these censorship calls grow loud enough to start targeting alternative protocols themselves.
- CuriousSkeptic 8y agoIn tandem we should start thinking of economic systems more capable of investing in such platforms. We’ve more or less tried both extremes of public vs private owners of capital. Could we try a commons based economy next? I mean, at least developers, seems capable of producing massive wealth in a decentralized fashion more or less motivated by the public good (or aligned interests) as open source, with very limited capital assets. What if we could make more capital available to that part of the economy?