11 ms·
Facebook Planned to Spy on Android Phone Users, Internal Emails Reveal
- AlexandrB 8y agoI've often argued that the basic "dumb fucks" sentiment from Mark Zuckerberg's university days has not changed within Facebook's leadership and frequently got push-back that Mark Zuckerberg has matured and is now a responsible steward of our data. I feel vindicated by news like this. It's pretty clear that privacy overreach and violation at Facebook are not "accidents". It's standard operating procedure.
- species9606 8y agoI work at one of Zuckerberg’s charitable organizations, but I’m considering resigning because of this kind of thing. At some point it’s not possible to separate the charity from the source of the money.
- justapassenger 8y agoYeah, everyone hates Facebook, but is there anything new here? Targeted advertising based on location and relationship status? That's not a secret, that's one of the biggest selling point of their product. Can someone explain to me why should I be outraged?
- oriettaxx 8y agoThe content of https://github.com/BuxtonTheRed/btrmisc/blob/master/fb-643-extended.pdf https://github.com/BuxtonTheRed/btrmisc/blob/master/fb-643-e... is sure pretty embarrassing
- Nicksil 8y agoSave a trip to Twitter. Here's the link to the story: https://www.computerweekly.com/news/252458208/Facebook-planned-to-spy-on-Android-phone-users-internal-emails-reveal https://www.computerweekly.com/news/252458208/Facebook-plann...
- creato 8y agoThe twitter thread has a few of the source documents, and a few things not mentioned in the story, this particular e-mail seems... interesting: https://twitter.com/ashk4n/status/1099146500725063680 https://twitter.com/ashk4n/status/1099146500725063680 Also, that twitter user is a former senior leader at the FTC, and claims something here to be "textbook @ftc deception": https://twitter.com/ashk4n/status/1099164648379580416 https://twitter.com/ashk4n/status/1099164648379580416
- throwaway00d36 8y agoSerious question -- how does Facebook keep getting hit with these 5+ year-old emails getting published? Did they not have any email retention policy? Is the root cause that they migrated off of email and did all their sensitive discussions in "internal tools" with no actual data retention enforcement? If so, that seems quite ironic.
- dade_ 8y agoMany people keep copies of emails. Perhaps they feel compelled to make the information public, and maybe they felt more compelled once they received their RSUs and cashed them in. "Most full-time employees receive RSUs (restricted stock units) which are shares that become sellable on a set schedule over four years. " https://www.quora.com/Do-Facebook-employees-get-stock-options https://www.quora.com/Do-Facebook-employees-get-stock-option...
- reaperducer 8y agoMost of the recent documents have become public because of a court case.
- accountwhatever 8y agoAlso, here's a link to the full set of documents: https://github.com/BuxtonTheRed/btrmisc/blob/master/fb-643-extended.pdf https://github.com/BuxtonTheRed/btrmisc/blob/master/fb-643-e...
- joeseeder 8y agoWhere do fb recruit engineering talent ? are we (engineers) really that indifferent to what organizations we support do ?
- basementcat 8y agoIt depends. If you have a variety of employment options, it is easy to follow you “conscience”. When you have fewer options and more personal responsibilities (private school tuition, piano lessons, etc), you start to lose the luxury of working for less pay.
- brador 8y agoI wonder if they psychologically test for and target these traits during recruitment.
- renholder 8y agoThis would seem to make the most sense, as it's the same line of thinking around why only 1 out of thousands at the NSA would be a whisteblower (see: Snowden); despite the shady shit that they were (and probably still are) undertaking. Also, non-disclosure agreements really fuck people in the overall scheme of things. If you worked for Facebook and came out tomorrow showing some really shady shit that they were doing, it's conceivable that no other company would ever want to hire you. (I think the term is "black-balled" but not sure if it's still in use, today?) (Whistleblower laws only protect government workers and do not affect the commercial industry. Even then, the whistleblower laws only go so far...) So, you're damned if you do and damned if you don't.
- JohnFen 8y ago> you're damned if you do and damned if you don't. If having integrity and an interest in the public good aren't strong enough arguments to avoid working for these companies, then perhaps this one is.
- pdkl95 8y agoAfter their internal memos about valuing "connecting people" over anything else (like safety) leaked[1], some of the comments by Facebook employees were almost cult-like[2]: > Leakers, please resign instead of sabotaging the company > How fucking terrible that some irresponsible jerk decided he or she had some god complex that jeopardizes our inner culture and something that makes Facebook great? In particular, this included comments about wanting a loyalty test "screen" in their hiring process: > Although we all subconsciously look for signal on integrity in interviews, should we consider whether this needs to be formalized in the interview process? > This is so disappointing, wonder if there is a way to hire for integrity. We are probably focusing on the intelligence part and getting smart people here who lack a moral compass and loyalty. [1] https://www.cbsnews.com/news/facebook-memo-the-ugly-andrew-boz-bosworth-mark-zuckerberg-response-today-2018-03-29/ https://www.cbsnews.com/news/facebook-memo-the-ugly-andrew-b... [2] https://www.theverge.com/2018/3/30/17179100/facebook-memo-leaks-boz-andrew-bosworth https://www.theverge.com/2018/3/30/17179100/facebook-memo-le...
- Simon_says 8y agoAndroid phone users are a subset of all of humanity, so yes.
- FakeComments 8y agoHow is Facebook not producing malware? I struggle to see how they’re legally different from malvertising: perhaps there’s some vague terms about data or advertising (which also exists for malvertising! you agreed to the ads!) but at no point was there a “meeting of the minds” in which Facebook was authorized to bypass security mechanisms to exfiltrate data from the system. I don’t see how Facebook’s behavior is anything but classic “hacking”, and a willful abuse of the CFAA. I think it’s time we started addressing gigacriminals[0] like Zuckerberg: we need to stop pandering to people who commit millions of crimes a day, at “web scale”, and just use force. If Facebook doesn’t want to get the memo that wanton criminality isn’t okay, then it’s time to use force to correct the behavior. [0] I use gigacriminal in the technical sense: I believe Mark Zuckerberg, as the leader of an organization, has ordered over 1 billion criminal acts to be commmitted for his profit.
- TheTruth321 8y agoFacebook IS Malware.
- deytempo 8y agoSend him to prison
- riyakhanna1983 8y agoLock 'em up!
- chooseaname 8y agoFB is making a lot of people a lot of money. Good luck getting traction on getting Zuck to stop. Also, while I think Zuck is devious (based on the history of FB), I think Sandburg is the brains of the worst of FB.
- Andre607 8y agoI know we have lots of FB employees at HN. I would be genuinely curious to hear, via throwaway accounts if need be, about how FB staff rationalise things like this happening. Do you shrug it off as not a big deal in the long run? As FB still doing a net amount of good versus what you perceive as isolated incidents like this? I'm just in good faith trying to figure out how people willingly work and continue to work for outfits that repeatedly engage in behaviour such as this. I know there are lots of speculative reasons we can put forward, but I think we have a great opportunity here in our community to have first-hand input.
- effbee 8y ago(throwaway) I started at FB out of college relatively recently and wasn't there for very long, so I can't speak for longer-term/more senior employees but hopefully this is a bit helpful. I myself joined because I needed a job, the money was amazing, and I wanted to be in the Bay Area. When I went in, there were already questions about data privacy/elections, but this was still before Cambridge Analytica and the subsequent weekly bad news that's gone on for a year now. Personally I've never been a big FB user and wasn't that enthusiastic going in, but a) the money and b) the scale of their data/infrastructure/data infrastructure was attractive. My impression was that many employees hold a self-contradictory view about the extent of their influence at the company. When asked about their jobs, they tell you that they're working hard on fixing the problem and making impact ("where better to fix it than from inside?"). But when confronted w/stories like Onavo, they get defensive because "it's a big company, I had no way of knowing." Which is fair, honestly; the problem is that they think they can fix anything in the first place. Part of the problem is that FB advertises itself internally as being super transparent but it isn't at all. (This applies mostly to product/data+ML people. The infra folks I worked with for the most part just want to make their money and go home.) A lot of longtime employees joined when FB was good and amazing in the media, and it's hard for them to accept that it's really gone in a bad direction. A lot of younger ones join for the money, and/or because they're coming from FB's massive, culty college intern pipelines (especially if you come out of FBU) and confuse being dazzled by the perks with actually believing in the mission. The money is big for everyone (I was there for part of the long 2018 stretch where the stock price just fell and fell, and you could feel people getting antsy), and the defensiveness that comes from constantly seeing negative news is another part. Lots of blame thrown around internally (leakers, leadership, bad eng practices) but little responsibility; lots of sunk cost fallacy-ish thinking ("we all took jobs here for a reason, we can't just give up and leave").
- ggggtez 8y ago>Facebook, which charged 30% service fees on the transactions, revealed in the internal email, “that an overwhelming majority of Apps using Facebook Payments to solicit funds are likely fraudulent.” No surprise here, again. Facebook launches a feature that allows criminal behavior, reaps the profits, and only tries to roll it back after they are under intense scrutiny. There is an easy way to fix these repeated problems: Hire people who care about ethics. Of course, the fact that they don't shows that they are only looking for a rubber stamp. What kind of "privacy" team do they have that approved all the garbage listed here?
- salawat 8y agoI think Computer Science needs to come coupled with exposure to a philosophical ethics sub-curriculum. I run into too many intelligent people who haven't ever spared a thought toward how to recognize "what is right? What is wrong?" Philosophy may not equip you with a concrete answer, but it definitely equips you with the machinery to look at something and recognize there's more to the question than some manager saying it's legit.