17 ms·
YouTube Just Demonetized Anti-Vax Channels
- charliebrownau 8y agoPlatforms that censor speech List :- * Facebook * Twitter * Google * Youtube * TUMBLR * Pateron * Stripe * Paypal * Twitch * Spotify * Apple * pin interest * LinkedIn * Mailchimp * Wordpress * mastodon * azure * Mastercard * Godaddy * MEDIUM * Shopify * Cloudflare * pusher * WIKI * Reddit * teespring * Slack * coinbase * GOFUNDME * VISA * Square * Bitpay * ROKU * Netflix * Indiegogo
- HeavenBanned 8y agoGood for them. This is a necessary Public Health intervention. Bioethicists will look back on this and agree that it was necessary.
- tfha 8y agoThis is overstepping. Yes, anti-vax is not well founded, and yes, YouTube is a private entity that can do what they want, but this tells me YouTube is willing to get involved to push an agenda. And that gives them a lot of political power.
- wbxrs 8y agoIt's not like this is their first. And yes, companies like these have too much political power. That's something we all know. The question is how to fix that.
- Gigablah 8y agoHit them where it hurts, their wallet. Tweet at all their major advertisers to boycott them unless they stop demonetizing antivax channels. It’s easy!
- mey 8y agoWhat would you rather have them do?
- atom_arranger 8y agoI'd rather they stopped paying everyone. That would at least not show any bias.
- newprint 8y agoFk them. People who endanger other people's lives and do it intentionally, have no place on YouTube. Thing is, if anti-vaxxers were not pushing their propaganda, I wouldn't have any issues.
- thebluehawk 8y agoI disagree. I think their policy of reacting to content that is harmful and dangerous is a good idea. It's not like the are censoring them. They are still free to spout whatever nonsense they want, they just won't be monetarily compensated for putting other people's lives at risk. If someone made a cleaning video that encouraged users to mix bleach and ammonia to make a super cleaning liquid, I don't think anyone would disagree that it's harmful and dangerous.
- lmilcin 8y agoThe worry is why a service that is designed to show people-created content should wield unlimited unilateral power to selectively decide what is going to be shown and what is not. Why a company and not a judge can decide what is not covered by freedom of speech? Can a large company just decide this because, well, it is large? I understand anti-vac people are seriously misguided and are posing threat to others but has there been any ruling on this or Youtube just decided it doesn't like it? I am of the opinion that this needs a transparent process so that YOUR rights are not stomped on when you are in minority. Say you we are transported back 200 years and you express an unpopular belief that black people should be made free and allowed to vote (and women too!) Who is to decide you are not allowed to even express your opinion because majority of the society thinks what you say is complete bullshit (why, who's going to do all this work?)
- lacksconfidence 8y agoThey haven't decided that people can't see this content though. The content that is already there is staying up, new anti-vax content can be uploaded and will (likely, i can't know for sure i suppose) be suggested if you are watching another anti-vax video. They have only demonitized the content, deciding they wont pay money for anti-vax content.
- lmilcin 8y agoFair point. You are correct, they were not prevented from expressing their opinion.
- TomNem 8y agoYoutube is not nor should be required to pay money to channels they do not want to. Saying that not paying money to channels is pushing an agenda is plain silly.
- steffandroid 8y agoYoutube already has enormous political power and its algorithm already pushes various agendas - in this instance, a particularly harmful one. Demonetising anti-vax videos is merely course correction.
- rincebrain 8y agoWhere do you draw the line between, say, anti-vaccine conspiracy theories, and actively advocating and planning harm of oneself and/or others? Both sides of that particular discussion would argue the other one is doing things that are actively harmful to others. I think one side is grossly unfounded fearmongering that's doing long-term sometimes irreparable harm to a great many people, some of whom are vulnerable and unable to decide for themselves, but they would say the same about people who encourage vaccination. I'm just trying to convey that almost any form of filtering qualifies as pushing an agenda, and it's just how controversial we find the topic that affects whether it bothers us. (Work for elgooG, not on anything even remotely related to Youtube, all opinions are my own, etc.)
- kyrra 8y agoPinterest made their search system not return any results related to vaccination as a way to combat it. https://www.wsj.com/articles/next-front-in-tech-firms-war-on-misinformation-bad-medical-advice-11550658601 https://www.wsj.com/articles/next-front-in-tech-firms-war-on...
- fzeroracer 8y agoEvery single company has an agenda. Every single company in America at least has enormous political power. Ultimately if we were to argue purely from a free market standpoint, this is an ideal scenario of users using their leverage to change how a company behaves, functioning as the free market is supposed to. If you disagree with the government stepping in to control things, then the logical conclusion is the users stepping in to control things.
- empath75 8y agoWhy should a private company be forced to publish opinions it disagrees with?
- alacombe 8y agoWhy should a private company make a cake for a customer asking for the display of a message they disagree with ? Private companies are already bound to anti-discrimination provisions, this is no different. Either private company are free to do business with whoever they want (including on a gender, race, and religion basis), or they don't. You can have it either way, but not both.
- amaccuish 8y agoAnti-vaxxers aren't a protected class. You can have it both ways, I don't understand why there's always a desire for clear-cut principles. Life is grey, and blurry principles are much more adaptable to changing circumstances.
- Proven 8y agoCan't say I noticed many ads of any kind (either pro or anti) on YouTube in the past 2-3 years. I demonetized all of YouTube a long time ago. Whatever ads do play or recommended continent appears, I distrust them and never click on it because as other comment said, they have an agenda. ZeroCredTube. Notice that antivax side doesn't have a "product" to sell while provax does. Guess which one makes more money for The Evil Boys
- icebraining 8y ago> Notice that antivax side doesn't have a "product" to sell That's simply not true; the channels they demonetized like iHealthTube and LarryCook333 do sell products (both their own and others') - usually "naturopathic" books, treatments, etc. Some of these can be quite expensive.
- alexandernst 8y agoI'm actually OK with that. Those people are endangering themselves and the ones that can't get vaccines because of several medical conditions.
- SubuSS 8y agoA question I have always wanted to hear the debates on: Do we want corporate entities dictating/enforcing social rules OR Do we want the elected government to be our moral compass and have corporations abide by the same / help the government enforce the same?
- JeremyMorgan 8y agoNo.
- melling 8y agoYou can still watch the videos, the producers just aren't getting paid.
- r00fus 8y agoWhy does it need to be an OR? If you run a platform you should be able to exercise your view of morality on there, assuming such morality is permitted in the jurisdictions you're working with. I have long held the belief that the "global no-regulation" Internet was a frontier mentality, and as it becomes more crowded, we will see a balkanization as places like Saudi Arabia, China, US and Europe have different rules/mores. What this means for the digerati and the Internet's impact on freedom of information remains to be seen.
- edmundsauto 8y agoUhh, given those choices, I 100% prefer corporations enforcing social norms.
- tomschlick 8y agoIf I had to choose... corporations. If you dont like what Youtube does you can use another service. It's hard to go to another government though.
- janpot 8y agoEver heard of elections?
- deleted 8y ago
- JeremyMorgan 8y agoMay not be a popular opinion but I'll share it anyway. I believe anti-vaxxers are nuts. I believe they are dangerous. I believe YouTube is a private company who can do what they want with their company. So why does this leave a bad taste in my mouth? Because they have so much power and influence and they can pull the plug on what could be called a difference of opinion. Yes, it's a horrible opinion but it's still empowering one side of an equation. Yes, Youtube may be "right" about Anti-vaxxers, but what happens when they're wrong? What happens when they decide to silence or stifle a group that's actually trying to help the good of the people? It's a complex issue to say the least.
- rhizome 8y agoThe plug isn't pulled on them, the videos are still accessible. Are you saying that people who post on YT have a right to monetization?
- goldenchrome 8y agoI would agree with you if this was a subjective matter. But it's not subjective in the slightest. It's not an opinion. People who are anti-vax are spreading incredibly dangerous lies and it's already starting to cause outbreaks around the world. This is a clearcut case where people are dying because of misinformation.
- monochromatic 8y agoYouTube has a tendency to demonetize videos with a conservative viewpoint too. Is that subjective enough?
- Sohcahtoa82 8y agoNow hold on... Are they really being demonetized being conservative? Or are they being demonetized for being racist, bigoted, transphobic, etc?
- monochromatic 8y ago
- Pharmakon 8y agoSmart, this should change the media narrative from their utter bollocks of handling the comments thing. YouTube may be equal parts soulless and incompetent, but their PR strategy isn’t terrible sometimes. On the other hand, antivaxxing is one of those problems crying out to stamped into the dust. I don’t particularly care if some decides to eat lots of fruit instead of getting chemotherapy, because their cancer isn’t contagious. Immunization though, is a matter of public health, and my patience for precious fools on a mission is precisely 0 when it could hurt people I care about. Still... why the hell is this something we let YouTube decide? The problem with antivaxxers isn’t their YouTube channels, it’s the fact that our lawmakers are too cowardly to pass some laws around the issue. YouTube shouldn’t be in a position to exert this kind of power, and this isn’t how issues should be tackled. This doesn’t solve anything, it just obscures it. A solution involves restricting access to public spaces for selfish morons who don’t get vaccinated, and yes, their children. Edit: Sorry I just realized that my comment is on the border of being little more than a rant. Like a lot of people here I suspect that this is the intersection of two issues I care about deeply; a big tech company’s questionable, situational ethics and enormous power, and the horror of people facing debilitation or death because of pseudoscience. I’m angry, I’m frustrated, and while I know having the government intervene is fraught with danger, it seems necessary especially in cases of public health.
- bb88 8y agoThe problem with this trend now is that people have realized the truth they want can be the truth we all have if they're willing to yell loud enough about it.
- xvilka 8y agoShould have just blocked these accounts on sight.
- not2b 8y agoCool, now we need to work on Facebook. A couple of days ago I got a paid ad from an antivax group, a particularly evil one because they pretend to be medical experts: Physicians for Informed Consent. Their idea of "informed consent" is a ton of misinformation that grossly exaggerate the risks and understate the benefits of vaccines. They paid Facebook to show me the add. I reported it; Facebook says they "understand" why I didn't like it but it doesn't violate their guidelines.
- sethkravitz 8y agoI don't see the issue with demonetizing them. They are still free to post, show up in search, free to trend, etc... All YouTube is saying is that it will no longer pay them to spread dangerous misinformation.
- aurizon 8y agoWhy have antivaxxers host 20 second pix in their videos of kids who died of measles, mumps, chicken pox, polio, scarlet fever, whooping cough, diptheria (one inserted at random by youtube - like ads) They do it for tobacco
- wrs 8y agoThere's an interesting meta-twist here… YouTube is trying to prevent the spread of dangerous "viral ideas" that enable the spread of dangerous physical viruses. The ideas are arguably a part of this health crisis as much as the viruses are. So this is a sort of "meme vaccination" to slow the spread of those ideas. Imagine if there were YouTube channels in the 19th century promoting the idea that surgeons washing their hands causes surgical complications. What would be the appropriate response?
- crashedsnow 8y agoIs that really equivalent? Anti-vax arguments risk convincing someone to put their children, and those around them in grave danger on the basis of fundamentally flawed arguments that can be made to sound compelling. I don't think the argument for hand washing ever met this criteria.
- burger_moon 8y agoIf I remember right a YT channel needs at least 4k subscribers now as of last year change to qualify for monetization on your channel. So I'm surprised there's channels big enough which are dedicated to this anti vax thing to be monetized in the first place.
- crashedsnow 8y agoI think it's 1k not 4k https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/72851 https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/72851
- mycorrhizal 8y agoIt seems crazy to me that we expect companies to tackle this problem. If you don't vaccinate your children when there are no extenuating circumstance (https://www.cdc.gov/vaccines/vpd/should-not-vacc.html https://www.cdc.gov/vaccines/vpd/should-not-vacc.html). Then how can this be seen as anything but neglect and child endangerment, which should be handled by child protective services.
- Sohcahtoa82 8y agoITT: People talking as if being demonetized is equivalent to being removed. Anti-vax channels have not been deplatformed. They can still post their videos on YouTube. They just can't profit from it anymore.
- kodablah 8y agoITT: people dismissing neutrality concerns and are using the specifics of the non-neutral actions to derail from the general point about objectivity.
- amaccuish 8y agoAre platforms like YouTube meant to be neutral? I never expected it to be. I don't expect to find terrorist beheading videos on there. I applaud YouTube for taking a restrained but decent step to help this crisis.
- yongjik 8y agoThis is one of those rare cases when I want to say "Think of the children!" because there are actual dead children. No, your hypothetical concern of authoritarian government doesn't trump dead children, because the slippery slope can go both ways. If we are okay with a few kids dying because our freedom is so sacred, where do we stop? Sounds silly? That's because slippery slopes are mostly silly. It's basically a glorified straw-man.
- tomp 8y agoDo you use the same argument to oppose abortion?
- berbec 8y agoIf you are of the opinion unborn children are children, you can. Not all people subscribe to that belief. This simple fact is why the pro-choice/life debates go nowhere. If you disagree on this basic point of fact, no amount of discussion will change your mind. If you believe fetuses (fetii?) are people, then abortion is murder. If unborn are not people, it's a medical procedure between a doctor and a patient.
- halfjoking 8y agoWow this thread has the most heated arguments I've seen on this site. My feeling is that since this is HackerNews, instead of arguing about censorship of idiots... let's instead build a startup to solve this. It seems anti-vaxxers main concern is that vaccines are unsafe due to preservatives. Why doesn't someone make a startup that has "freshly killed virus" that charges $10k per vaccine? Do you know how much money you could make from celebrities advocating these preservative-free vaccines? People would sell their homes just to get these "safe" vaccines from the startup. It's a win-win-win solution... someone gets rich, the idiots do whatever it takes to get vaccinated or they get put in jail (let's jail them for child-abuse if they don't vaccinate), and we still have herd-immunity in society. So common HN, someone has to have the capital to get this started. Let's solve this.
- CM30 8y agoOh hey, they actually did something decent for once. It doesn't help much with their other recent mistakes (accidentally banning channels who used CP for Pokemon GO/Club Penguin videos, demonetising videos/channels based on comment content, outright telling a large channel they were disabling comments on their videos at random, etc), but this anti vaccination conspiracy stuff shouldn't really be a thing in 2019. Then again, this is probably the one place in which my views on free speech would come into conflict, since while I do feel people should be allowed to say/write what they want for the most part, anti vax stuff is both scientifically/factually wrong, dangerous to society and dubious all round.
- charliebrownau 8y agoHate Speech is anything the GLOBAL SOCIALIST LEFT hates or disagrees with This wont be the last or first group of channels that are:- * De listed * De platformed * videos Removed * Ads removed * No notifications , etc If you want FREE SPEECH then use free speech platforms I recommend ALL content creators migrate to BITCHUTE ASAP
- Grue3 8y agoWhen will religious anti-science channels get demonetised? Creationism is just as bad as anti-vax, except way more people believe in it.
- charliebrownau 8y agoPlatforms that DONT censor speech * Minds + mewe (FB alt) * Gabai (Twitter alt) * Bitchute (Youtube alt) * Tutanota + Protonmail(email alt) * Wire (skype alt) * Librepay (Donation alt)(Warning they use STRIPE+Paypal) * subscribestar (Donation alt)(No longer using STRIPE+Paypal) * Startengine (Kickstarter alt) * peertube (DIY self host youtube stream style server) * stream.me (steaming alt) * Voat (Reddit alt) * Movim (Tumblr alt) * Pixelfed (Instagram alt)(one admin is an leftist) * @GetTogether (meetup.com alt) Also look into:- * searX.me or Duckduckgo or startpage (search alt) * OpenStreetmap - instead of Google maps * imgtc or tineye - free image upload site * Linux - Win/MacOSX replacement * f-droid.org - Google Play Store ALT * Mumble - Discord ALT * Gitlab (Github alt) * spreadshirt - shirt merch alt Regards Charliebrownau
- throwaway3449 8y agoThis is definitely a free speech/democracy issue. Why nobody discusses the facts instead: - no vaccine was/is ever tested against inert placebo in clinical trial. How the hell can we let manufacturers get away with this? - majority of (media) cited epidemiological studies around safety are just (very) bad - so as a result we have here following situation: people claiming to be injured (also killed) by untested and massively deployed product (that also saves lives, yes) and we have no data to calculate the benefit/risk ratio. Instead we just vilify them. I can understand how/why (majority of) scientific community maintains the old reductionist paradigm. But how this can stay out of scope of investigative media is beyond me. (edit: formatting/grammar)
- karmakaze 8y agoHow much better would the internet be if all content was demonetized? Never mind that we may not know how to make it sustainable for the moment. This incident is just starting to show how click=$ and optimizing for $ fails. We need alternative, truer motivations.