4 ms·
It's because there is no direct comparison. No country on earth with single payer or other universal coverage has anywhere near the number of citizens nor geog
by AndrewKemendo 8y ago
It's because there is no direct comparison.
No country on earth with single payer or other universal coverage has anywhere near the number of citizens nor geographic or social diversity as the US.
Now, that doesn't mean we can't learn from those countries, but our own smaller scale federal health care systems (medicare, VA, tricare) are already large enough to compare with and done so.
It's quite unfortunate, but the entire federal system has to change in order to lay the groundwork for a single payer system.
- objektif 8y agoI think this diversity can be benefitial for insurance right? Isnt that the whole idea behind the idea of diversification?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- dragonwriter 8y ago> No country on earth with single payer or other universal coverage has anywhere near the number of citizens nor geographic or social diversity as the US. That's both not true (the PRC exists, and alone is sufficient to disprove that no country with universal coverage exceeds the US on any of the measures you listed) and not relevant, as none of those are significant per-capita or per-GDP healthcare cost drivers.
- AndrewKemendo 8y agoI'm sorry, just to be clear, you're making a serious contention that the PRC 1. Has universal healthcare (false) and 2. that it's something that is to be imitated?
- dragonwriter 8y ago> you're making a serious contention that the PRC 1. Has universal healthcare (false) The PRC has universal healthcare coverage entitlement by national policy, financed and administered largely by local governments under national standards (with central subsidies to poorer regions), and has over 95% of the population covered through public-funded programs. [0] > 2. that it's something that is to be imitated? The claim was no country with certain features exists; being worthy of imitation was not one of the features. I never advocated emulating the PRC either in general or in the specifics of their mechanism of addressing universal healthcare access; in fact, I specifically pointed out that, as well.as being false, the claim about countries sharing those features was irrelevant to the healthcare discussion (which implies that a country meeting the supposedly unmet description has no particular reason to have special status as a model for the US.) [0] https://international.commonwealthfund.org/countries/china/ https://international.commonwealthfund.org/countries/china/
- AndrewKemendo 8y agoI'm familiar with the "claim" they stake, however the actual system has effectively nothing resembling a functional national system like the "OECD First World" systems that the US is being compared to. That's saying nothing of its outcomes or service level by the way. Simply in reference to its structure. It's not even in the same ballpark.
- benj111 8y ago"No country on earth with single payer or other universal coverage has anywhere near the number of citizens nor geographic or social diversity as the US" Why is this relevant? The UK for example has a population of 60+ million (v US's 300+ million), if that figure doubled or halved, I don't think that would fundamentally change how the NHS operates. Just like it doesn't fundamentally change how it operates in central London or the Scottish highlands.
- Amygaz 8y agoYou are just being sarcastic, right? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_ranked_by_ethnic_and_cultural_diversity_level https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_ranked_by_et...
- AndrewKemendo 8y agoNote that the AND operator in my statement isn't an OR operator
- moorhosj 8y agoSemantics aside, you haven’t established that those are primary drivers of cost or effectiveness. France and UK have 10x the population of Norway and are considerably more diverse. Can you prove where this impacts their respective costs?
- AndrewKemendo 8y agoI'm not making any specific claims about either of those aspects, simply that you can't compare two populations that are incredibly different in this manner.
- moorhosj 8y agoYou haven’t shown any supporting evidence of why you can’t compare them. Universal healthcare has shown to scale from Norway, Sweden, Denmark size to Spain, Italy, Canada, Australia size to UK, France, Germany size. What is the evidence it can’t scale to US size?
- AlexandrB 8y ago> No country on earth with single payer or other universal coverage has anywhere near the number of citizens nor geographic or social diversity as the US. This argument is so bizarre. Larger population sounds like better economies of scale to me. And social diversity? I mean we're talking about Homo Sapiens here. A kidney is a kidney is a kidney, no matter your cultural background.
- AndrewKemendo 8y agoUnfortunately those factors are relevant, as cultural and lifestyle and wealth differences make big differences in health outcomes. Healthcare also hasn't shown that it can scale or that margins increase with more centralized services, while maintaining service levels. Said another way: doctors (the bottleneck for service) are expensive to grow, take a long time to make, in high demand, and work serially (no parallel service provided). It's a structural problem, not just a policy one.