3 ms·
The parent comment is just replying to say that it's anti-democratic. You're side-stepping the question with an orthogonal one. There's no perfect political sy
by bobthepanda 8y ago
The parent comment is just replying to say that it's anti-democratic. You're side-stepping the question with an orthogonal one.
There's no perfect political system. Despots can be good and they can be bad; they can free the serfs, or they can instigate a genocide. But unlike well-implemented democracies, despots have a single point of failure. What happens when the 'enlightened' despot is wrong?
- freedomben 8y agoI wasn't intentionally side-stepping, I was asking an honest question regarding what I perceived to be a presupposition of his, namely that being anti-democratic is equivalent to being morally wrong. I could be misunderstanding him tho, as I did have to infer that from his comment about "rich people" running things. Yeah it's a good point. If we stipulate that anarchy can't work (which I don't believe necessarily, I'm agnostic on that, but for sake of discussion I'll stipulate), then I can't really think of a better system either (assuming we're actually talking about a direct democracy like Ancient Greece had). The people can and do get things wrong, but it does seem less likely that the people as a whole will be tyrants than one or a few individuals.