4 ms·
+ I am familiar with Oneida. I am not so much interested in group marriage as I am in the institution of marriage itself..as in why do we need it? I have though
by jelliclesfarm 8y ago
+ I am familiar with Oneida. I am not so much interested in group marriage as I am in the institution of marriage itself..as in why do we need it? I have thought long and hard about it..if we didn’t have religion, would we need the institution of marriage? Marriage or rather formal legal marriage seems to be largely for the benefit of the state so they can tax and interfere with lives of citizens. Religion itself seems to need a large population all the time...I have never believed that there has been a true separation of church and state anywhere in the world...the state just seamlessly took over the power over how people live from religious institutions.
If we magically ‘forget’ the concept of marriage, as we know it tomorrow..what would change for us?
NOTHING.
+ Re Friday: I wonder if Heinlein made her AP only because she could be considered as ‘the other’ which likely separated the experiences of her character from the writer and the reader’s own identity and projections. If that’s what Heinlein tried to do, he failed.
I am trying to tie this back to how we would..in the future..consider cyborgs or robots or other APs. What would define sentience? I think heinlein..in his own way...was probably testing..Asimov like..rights and treatment of sentient non humans.
+ re male/female sexual proclivities, I think Heinlein did not take it lightly. I will fear no evil was entirely dedicated to the questions of what defines gender and what is it like to be trapped in the other genders body/mind. He approached the subject fearlessly. But apparently he was gravely ill and we don’t know who really ‘finished’ the book beyond the first draft. But it certainly sounded like Heinlein. This is one of the reasons I adore Heinlein.
+ you said, “your sentence suggests that neither of us are male”. You inadvertently touched upon a pet theory of mine. That ‘malesness’ is a mutation. All zygotes are female by default. It’s because of SRY gene that it turns ‘male’, as it were...being ‘male’ is merely ‘not being female’ having mutated from the default. So I consider the Y to be largely faulty code. I am not being a ‘rabid feminist’...I have been called that before but it can’t be more further than the truth..I do not hate men...I just find them amusing and interesting and annoying until I find them alien.
Regardless, I am sure this wasn’t the response you were expecting. So back on topic..female desire and sexual proclivities are somewhat standardized ...that doesn’t mean that women veer from the norm. (Ditto with men), but the awkwardness with Heinlein’s portrayal of female sexuality bordering on aggressive male sexuality seems forced because it’s almost like he wants to imprint maleness as default upon the female. It’s just ...well..odd. It doesn’t ‘fit or sit well’. I cannot articulate better.
+ i did not know about Virginia and Heinlein. Having said that, I often think of the other masterpiece..Nabokov’s Lolita. But HH took the voice of the unreliable narrator. Towards the end, the reader had empathy for HH because they have walked down the path with him and at the end of it, they want to hold his hand and comfort him. He is a monster but we feel sorry for him. We ‘understand’ him. Heinlein otoh is icky..his characters are aloof and we don’t want to be seen walking with him.
+ re authors’ gender..I have often thought that the most relatable writing comes from lived experiences. While a woman can write ‘like a man’, it might just as well because her lived experience reflected that...bit Heinlein writes women like a man. And he doesn’t do it from a third person narrative but from a first person narrative..which ..like I said before just doesn’t ‘fit’right. But that’s just my 2c.
- eesmith 8y agoThank you for your clarification. I was under the mistaken assumption that you were interested in alternatives to monogamous marriage, eg, might be poly-curious. Instead, you were questioning the existence of marriage. For that you will have to look towards cultural anthropology. A quick search shows finds, for example, http://www.oxfordbibliographies.com/view/document/obo-9780199766567/obo-9780199766567-0016.xml http://www.oxfordbibliographies.com/view/document/obo-978019... > Over the years as well, anthropologists have debated what lies at the very core of marriage as an institution and as a relationship, whether it is economic sharing, sexual access, childbearing and parenthood, or reproductive success. They also have debated whether marriage is best described in terms of sentiment and subjectivity, social or mental structures, or transactions and strategic choice. That is far outside of my depth. I can recommend looking at countries which have both formal marriage arrangements and less formal cohabitation laws to see some of the benefits of having a legal recognition. For example, https://www.island.is/en/family/marriage_and_partners/co_habiting_partners/ https://www.island.is/en/family/marriage_and_partners/co_hab... says that "rights of cohabitating people are affected by whether their cohabitation is registered or not", so they exist even without formal recognition, and "Individuals in cohabitation do not bear any responsibility for each other's financial support, and do not have the right of inheritance towards one another". As an example of the latter, from http://hhogman.se/cohabitation.htm http://hhogman.se/cohabitation.htm , "Stieg Larsson, the renowned Swedish writer who lived sambo for many years with Eva Gabrielsson. When he died in 2004, his father and brother, not Eva, inherited his wealth worth millions. There were law suits and a settlement, but this could have been avoided with a will." See also https://edition.cnn.com/travel/article/wonder-list-bill-weir-iceland/index.html https://edition.cnn.com/travel/article/wonder-list-bill-weir... for one US citizen's view about marriage, or the lack thereof, in Iceland. Regarding "formal legal marriage seems to be largely for the benefit of the state so they can tax and interfere with lives of citizens". Given my quote from earlier, your hypothesis does not sound correct. As an example, the medieval Icelandic state deliberately avoided having a strong centralized state. Your hypothesis would suggest that this would mean there was no need for marriage, yet we know from the sagas that there was marriage. See for example https://digitalcommons.wou.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1044&context=his https://digitalcommons.wou.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1... , which includes descriptions of marriage in pre-Christianity Iceland. Here is one thing that would change if we magically forget the concept of marriage tomorrow. If the next day I have a medical condition which renders me unconscious, who has the right to make medical decisions for me? I am married, so under the current legal system my spouse - someone I voluntarily decided to marry, and who best knows my opinions - has the first option. Not my family-by-blood, as that relationship wasn't voluntary. Here's another - who has the right to visit me when I'm in the hospital? These can all be addressed without marriage, but the result is still some sort of registration system, with some sort of arbitration system to decide how to manage conflicts. Which is close to what cohabitation systems are already like. I cannot conjecture on Heinlein's purpose in writing Friday. It may be addressed better in some of the references I gave earlier. Regarding again "dedicated to the questions of what defines gender", I think he did so within a binary gender essentialist viewpoint. I don't think he was 'fearless' in examining what the larger topic of what it means to be queer. The example I quoted about transvestites is one of the few in Heinlein's works. In his later novels, name one character who is asexual. 'Slipstick' Libby was a man who became a women, but her transition was nothing like what trans-women now experience. My comments were not so inadvertent, in that you mentioned your pet theory in recent comments of your, which I reviewed before responding. However, I don't believe that your use of the terms "mutant", and the terms "male" and "female" for zygotes, have much biological meaning, and certainly not once we get into culturally-defined gender. I also don't think your use of "faulty" has any biological meaning but is your personal interpretation. No system which has been around for 100+ million years can be described as "faulty". Monotremes don't have the SRY gene but do have males and females. The XY system also evolved several times, including in "some insects (Drosophila), some snakes, and some plants (Ginkgo)." It's further believed to have evolved from the temperature-dependent sex determination system of reptiles, meaning that male/female distinction is far older than the Y chromosome.