2 ms·
I'd say there are established rules on this for fair use. You might adding some meta information with attribution and doing automated checks on e.g. the scope o
by jillesvangurp 8y ago
I'd say there are established rules on this for fair use. You might adding some meta information with attribution and doing automated checks on e.g. the scope of the use in the context of the new work. This is a greenfield currently; people are very sloppy with attributing or even acknowledging each other's content. Also, rights to the content is something you could manage in a registry by e.g. stating that content reuse with attribution is allowed by the content owner.
All I see in discussions on this topic right now is this apocalyptic thinking which in my view is not a productive, at all. Where's the counter solution or the improved proposal? The debate on this only seems to get going when legislation is about to be passed; which is typically too late. Youtube as a victim is not going to cause me to shed tears.
Vague amateur interpretations of interpretations of what somebody said on a blog leading to ridiculous conclusions about what it all means are just noise. This is not the end of free speech, satire, or the internet. Wasn't the case for GDPR either. I see this as just a necessary step to get out of the abusive mess that is the status quo of today where people just do whatever without regard for copyright.
Sure this proposal is less than ideal and the process for creating it is flawed. There are probably many ways things can be improved further; how the impact for honest businesses and individuals can be mitigated; etc. Lets have that debate instead of doing nothing and hoping this topic goes away (which of course it won't). In my view concrete improvements might be a lot easier to get support for in the EU and other countries like the US with powerful lobbies for changing the law on this front (this is not an EU problem) than arguing for nothing to happen.