9 ms·
People do get that, but waiting for people to spontaneously start doing the right thing is just not a very good strategy. That's why we need a carbon tax. To f
by andrepd 8y ago
People do get that, but waiting for people to spontaneously start doing the right thing is just not a very good strategy.
That's why we need a carbon tax. To force people to.
- kodablah 8y agoAlways another regressive tax needed as the only way to solve a problem. There are other options that don't so egregiously favor the ones with money.
- jogjayr 8y agoCarbon taxes can be offset with a per-person tax credit. This makes it revenue neutral while ensuring that big consumers pay more taxes. They do it in British Columbia already [1] 1. https://www2.gov.bc.ca/gov/content/environment/climate-change/planning-and-action/carbon-tax https://www2.gov.bc.ca/gov/content/environment/climate-chang...
- skosch 8y agoYou make it revenue neutral – look up fee and dividend, the method favoured by most economists. The bottom ~2/3rd of households would, on average, get more money back than the tax would cost them.
- npongratz 8y ago> The bottom ~2/3rd of households would, on average, get more money back than the tax would cost them. Please correct me if I'm misunderstanding: 2/3rds of households would first have to pay up, and then they'll get more money back than they paid in? If that's true, it sounds like it would be instituting needless added complexity, with a layer added for politicians and bureaucrats to take a cut before giving it back.
- dontreact 8y agoThe value add of the layer in complexity is that the costs of some goods but not others would go up. This would make buying and investing in renewables more favorable economically.
- npongratz 8y agoSo the value add is to artificially add a cost to one form of energy production to make it cost more than another form? That does not sound like a "value add", but rather a simple "cost add," with government agents making the demands and meting out financial (and eventually, physical) punishment for non-compliance. And we really want to add complexity and inconvenience to 2/3rds of households just so they can get their money back?
- jaggederest 8y agoIt's called a pigovian tax, and it's widely considered the most efficient way to deal with these kinds of negative externalities. For most lower income households, they would actually be receiving a net increase in their income, since they emit less than the mean carbon output.
- dontreact 8y agoBurning fossil fuels has a real cost to everyone which is not priced appropriately by the free market (this is a well known economic effect known as a negative externality). This tax corrects for the artificially low costs.
- bwb 8y agoPeople are busy and stressed and don't have time to think about stuff like that. That is why the government, aka society, have to make those calls and enforce them. People need guidance to make the right decisions in an already complicated world. If we can't get people to eat right, value science, save an emergency fund, or so many things why do we keep acting surprised when they don't even know what global warming is.
- EGreg 8y agoWe don’t just need a carbon tax. We need the public to support it unlike the French public. So we need to redistribute the carbon tax as UBI. So people say “more carbon tax please!” Climate Justice. Contact Andrew Yang who is running for President and tell him his UBI needs to be funded with a carbon tax!
- tim333 8y agoI think if you had a properly planned tax so you could say this is fair and will fix or at least significantly reduce the risk from global warming then people would be ok with it. The present ineffectual stuff doesn't really achieve much.
- EGreg 8y agoYou are too naive to think that, in my opinion. It is also unnecessary to rely on this dream about human nature when we can just do the UBI thing which is strictly MORE incentive. Not to mention that it lets us introduce UBI’
- SVResponsible 8y agoUBI just makes landlords richer. Why not have the country simply pick up the carbon tax for individuals?
- EGreg 8y agoWhat does that even mean? Go into depth on both of your points.
- michaelt 8y agoIf 10 families are in price competition for 9 houses* the price will be $1 more than the poorest family can afford. Which will probably leave the second-poorest family struggling. If (in your justified pity for the poorest and second-poorest) you give everyone a free $1000, the equilibrium price will simply rise by $1000 leaving the same families struggling and homeless. This is the model armchair economists use to explain reports that Bay Area employees paid 4x the national median household income can struggle to find housing. Of course, if you instead think of Detroit, where many properties are abandoned and some change hands for as little as $500, the model is far less applicable. *Assuming a simple model of a closed system where all houses are identical, there are no houses outside the system, no possibility of building new houses, and families are as densely packed as possible.
- wjnc 8y agoAs an economist I fully agree. It's not the solution but the measure that helps consumers in ranking all possible solutions. Why is flying without kerosine tax? Why do we spend a few k€ on electric car subsidies per MT less emitted. A tax would make things like this transparant. All we need is some party with the clout of the EU or US to get this thing going. There is no opting out trading with us and no opting out for local citizens. With 1/4th (?) Of global GDP on board it would be the transformative step in starting towards drawdown. All other measures are doomed to fail without it. You can't invest in anything CO2 related when you can't capture the gains. Make no mistakes: CO2 accounting and taxing will be a massive invitation for corruption, gaming and bad actors. But we don't have another option except heavy handed top down regulation.
- sideshowb 8y ago> CO2 accounting and taxing will be a massive invitation for corruption, gaming and bad actors That's the problem already. We've had a CO2 price for a long time - but it's meaninglessly low. I can only presume because of lobbying from those with vested interests.
- karambahh 8y agoCO2 fraud has been uncovered in the EU VAT zone[0] 1.6 billion euros skimmed by a dozen people in France. Up to 10 billion for the EU as a whole. Unfortunately I could only find sources in french or hebrew but the amounts amassed by this operation is staggering. [0]https://fr.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fraude_%C3%A0_la_TVA_sur_les_quotas_de_carbone?wprov=sfla1 https://fr.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fraude_%C3%A0_la_TVA_sur_les...
- JoshTko 8y agoCan't we make fines high and give anyone that reports fraud a cut of penalty?
- jaggederest 8y agoThere's a similar concept to a Pigovian tax for fines, I think of it as a "Pigovian fine", which is the price at which the likelihood of getting caught times the fine exceeds the cost to pay the tax directly. So if you have a 1% chance of getting caught, the fine needs to be 101x the tax. This is why so many e.g. banking and consumer protection fines fail to achieve their goal - the cost of adhering is more than the probability of getting caught times the fine, so it's economically rational to not pay.
- everdev 8y agoAnd, people don't usually put themselves at an economic disadvantage. If their neighbors are buying cheap goods, they probably will too.
- ptaffs 8y agoI disagree, with advertising and brand loyalty, often people spend more than they need to on equivalent goods.
- everdev 8y agoSure, if it's a marginal cost increase or if you're wealthy. But middle-income families typically aren't going to spend 25-50% more on a comparable product to save on CO2. There was a big push decades ago to buy American, but it largely failed because for the majority of people living paycheck to paycheck, spending 25-50% more to have an American flag sticker on your purchase wasn't worth it.
- gowld 8y agoAlso because there is 0 accountability that the flag sticker is honest. Sometimes the only part that's "made in USA" is the effort of applying the sticker.
- noir_lord 8y agoMy partner and I are a middle income family (though comfortable because we live cheap) and we buy based on a bunch of factors including brand loyalty and environment policy (as much as you can find out without it turning into a full time job).
- BurningFrog 8y agoI don't think China would consent to being taxed like that.
- vkou 8y agoThey don't have to consent. That's the whole point of tariffs. They can be imposed unilaterally (As we have recently seen with the US - China shoving contest. Which, of course, had nothing to do with the environment, or carbon emissions, and everything to do with political optics.)
- Kephael 8y agoIf the West stops trading with China then they will invade Taiwan and Okinawa and also supply modern weapon systems to North Korea.
- astrodust 8y agoThey'll do that regardless when the time is right.
- vkou 8y agoThis is Tom Clancy fairy-tale nonsense. China wants a nuclear-free Korea, for the same reason that the United States wants a nuclear-free Mexico and Canada. Nuclear super-powers aren't keen on letting their neighboring satellite states limit their foreign policy, by arming them. A carbon tax is not 'stopping trade'. It's an increase to the price of goods that are energy-intensive to manufacture, or ship.
- Kephael 8y agoThe Chinese aren't going to allow any sort of tariffs that would threaten their rapid industrialization without serious saber-rattling.
- bjlorenzen 8y agoThis is pure speculation. Meanwhile, our government is actively invading and occupying how many countries?
- SVResponsible 8y agoA carbon tax will disproportionately hurt people who did not cause this problem. We should be nationalizing our energy industries.
- losteric 8y agoRegulations across borders are ineffective, usually useless... and good luck promoting conscientious consumerism. We need tariffs on imports from polluting countries.