3 ms·
How can plasma transfusions not have gone though rigorous testing? Has it not been done routinely millions of times for decades? I understand it's not been pro
by BurningFrog 8y ago
How can plasma transfusions not have gone though rigorous testing? Has it not been done routinely millions of times for decades?
I understand it's not been proven to have any health benefit. But the safety of the procedure must be extremely well known.
- ianhowson 8y agoFor a treatment to be granted 'FDA approval', the FDA needs to see evidence of two things: safety and efficacy. Even if a treatment is demonstrated to be safe, if there's no evidence of therapeutic benefit, they won't approve it.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- BurningFrog 8y agoYeah, if you parse out the words, that is all they're actually saying. "There is no proven clinical benefit" and "there are risks associated with the use of any [...] product".
- ianhowson 8y agoThey're also not saying "Ambrosia Medical must stop administering this treatment". They're just saying "we don't approve". So this thing on the Ambrosia website: > In compliance with the FDA announcement issued February 19, 2019, we have ceased patient treatments. doesn't quite make sense, because the FDA hasn't publicly asked Ambrosia to stop, and the FDA never did approve transfusions for the purpose of life extension or anti-aging. They're not complying with anything, because that announcement wasn't a 'cease treatments' notice. So we don't really know why Ambrosia has chosen to stop.
- magduf 8y agoSo why is chiropractic and homeopathy allowed?
- ianhowson 8y agoI can't speak for chiropractic as that's out of scope for the FDA and I have no knowledge of the regulatory process there. Homeopathy and supplements are classified as food, not medicine. Therefore, they're not required to seek FDA approval. (They still have to meet food safety standards, of course.) If they could do anything meaningful, they'd be required to reclassify as medicine and undergo approval. So you get this fun situation where anything useful is locked up and can only make very specific claims about what it can cure. The things that can't cure anything can make weasel-worded claims about anything.
- hopler 8y agoAging is the an FDA approved disease, but every symptom of aging is.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- mips_avatar 8y agoI mean plasma products aren’t zero risk. But yes pretty low risk. One of the problems with FDA approval processes are that they wont approve anti aging trials. Because basically the FDA only allows you to treat a problem and it doesn’t consider aging to be a problem. https://www.politico.com/agenda/story/2017/12/13/anti-aging-research-drugs-000595 https://www.politico.com/agenda/story/2017/12/13/anti-aging-...
- oh_sigh 8y agoWouldn't you just need to go one step further? Aging isn't a problem, but macular degeneration, or erectile dysfunction, etx from aging is a problem, so you can treat that.